Saturday, August 1, 2009

AN EXCHANGE WITH EM KEATON RE THE HOMOSEXUAL ISSUE IN THE EPISCOPAL CHURCH

July 8 To EM Keaton

The Oasis Elizabeth Kaeton, Executive Director, 973-430-9909e-mail: EMKaeton@aol.com


Would you please comment on the following:

"A major issue faces the Christian Church. Christianity is being confronted with a campaign by homosexuals and their supporters to disparage Sacred Scripture by insisting the ancient teachings on same-gender sexual behavior are wrong. Specific Bible verses, described as "clobber passages" by homosexuals and their supporters, are characterized as being in error and misconstrued. Homosexuals are assaulting the generic Christian Church with specific attacks on the Bible and its interpretation.

Many consider the rise of the homosexual movement as an episodic occurrence, whose manifestation will be temporary in duration. This may be true. There is a large difference with what is happening today compared to the past, however. That difference is the coincident influential effects of 1) the overwhelming, largely sympathetic mass media, and 2) the economic exploitation induced by the immense affluence of prominent homosexuals. Church leaders in certain denominations are allegedly being bought, coerced, and indirectly manipulated.

What does this mean to the Church? The Homosexual Agenda is not to convert Gays and Lesbians to Christianity. The Agenda is for the Christian Church to accept homosexuals as a part of their secular objective to change the cultural and legal fabric of the nation. The Bible stands in the way of this objective. It stands in the way of the ordination and marriage of homosexuals. It stands in the way of declaring homosexuality a normal and natural lifestyle, with all the implications this has for the secular domain, the Christian Church and the witness of the Church to young people and the world.

The attack on the Sacred Scripture must not stand. The assault is a fundamental heresy. It is a lie directed at the Christian Church so homosexuals may gain their secular objective. It is time for the Christian Church to respond ecumenically to this challenge to God's Word. It is time to affirm the Bible's teaching, and to insist on the call in love for confession and repentance from individual homosexuals who sincerely seek Jesus Christ with the great hope of His forgiveness and salvation."

July 8 Reply from Elizabeth Kaeton

Dear Gentleperson, I am always very flattered to be asked my opinion. Thank you.

If it doesn't seem impolite I'd like to ask a few questions before responding to you: What is the source of this quote? Who said it and under what circumstances? What group or organization does s/he represent?

Who are you? Am I to believe your name is Otis Page, Jr.? Do you represent a particular interest group or theological position? Why do you seek my opinion? Is this to be a discussion between you and me, or do you plan to use this conversation as part of a larger dialogue?

Thank you for your inquiry and response.

Faithfully,

Elizabeth Kaeton

July 8 - Reply to E M Kaeton

My name is Otis S. Page Jr, I live in Arroyo Grande, California. I am a Christian. I do not have an affiliation with any church denomination. My wife is Episcopal. I was married in the Episcopal Church in Goshen, New York. I have recently been informed of the Homosexual issue and I was introduced to this by my sister-in-law who is active in the Episcopal Church. I received your E-mail address via a paper you wrote that is published as a part of Anglicanvoice.org. My purpose in sending the quote to you is to get the reaction from various parties as to the meaning of the statement, and its implication in the great argument that is taking place. I have no plan at this time except to say that I am attempting to find the truth on this matter and I feel it is important to get all sides of the issue because of its profound historic implication. Does this answer your question?

Who are you, may I ask? I do appreciate your replying to the E-mail. Respectfully. Otis Page


July 9 To Elizabeth Keaton. I have read your Web page, and I now am informed of your ministry. Otis Page

July 9 Who are you? I'm not going to respond to thin air.

Michael Hopkins
StGeoGD@aol.com

July 9 Michael. My name is Otis S. Page Jr, I live in Arroyo Grande, California, which is located on the Central Coast of California, equidistant from LA and SF. I am a Christian. I do not have an affiliation with any church denomination. I am not affiliated with any organization which concerning either the secular or the religious issue of homosexuality. My wife is Episcopal. I was married in the Episcopal Church in Goshen, New York. I have recently been informed of the Homosexual issue and I was introduced to this by my sister-in-law who is active in the Episcopal Church. My wife and sister-in-law have cousins that are active lesbians. I have hired and managed lesbians who have worked both directly and indirectly for me. But that was years ago when I was active in the Computer Industry. I received your E-mail address via a paper you wrote that is published as a part of Anglicanvoice.org. My purpose in sending the quote to you is to get the reaction from various parties as to the meaning of the statement, and its implication in the great argument that is taking place. I have no plan at this time except to say that I am attempting to find the truth on this matter and I feel it is important to get all sides of the issue because of its profound historic implication. Does this answer your question? Have I mad myself clear?

I very much appreciate your replying to me. I hope my inquiry is not burdensome to you. Otis Page

July 10 Otis, Now that we know a little more about each other, you'll forgive me if I remain hesitant to respond to your question. I fear my response will be much too obvious, now that you know who I am and the work God has given me to do.

However, I do appreciate the motive which has caused you to contact me and ask for my reaction that quote. I did do a very brief search of Anglican Voice Web Page, but couldn't find it easily enough for me to know the author or source.

Your search for the truth is a nobel cause, and worthy of at least an attempt on my part to respond to your question. While I have graduated from seminary and met all of the requirements necessary for graduation and ordination, I am not an authority on scripture or church history or tradition. Neither am I a politician, skilled in the ways of rhetoric and debate.

I am a woman. A mother. A neighbor. A citizen. A Christian. A priest. A pilgrim. I love God and follow the teachings of Jesus, guided and strengthened by the Holy Spirit. If I thought for one minute that the teachings in the bible forbade me to love the woman I have loved and lived with in faithful monogamous relationship for the last 23 years, I swear to you that, while it would cause me monstrous pain and confusion, I would end my relationship with her right this very minute. Obviously, I am not so persuaded. However, that does not tarnish the sincerity of my words.

This is not to say that I or any other member of the lesbian or gay Christian community "disparage Sacred Scripture" or "insist that it is wrong" (I point out that, just as not all heterosexuals are Christian, neither are all homosexuals Christian.).

It means that I do not know how an intelligent, well-informed person can read the story of Sodom and Gomorra in Genesis 18 and insist that this is evidence of God's abomination of gay and lesbian people.

I don't know how any intelligent, well-informed person can read the rules of Leviticus, which were written to preserve and build up a nation after the Diaspora, and pick and choose among the rules and say that this is evidence of God's condemnation of lesbian and gay people. Clearly, it is the ancient Hebrew nation's condemnation, which is understandable, given the time in and circumstances under which it was written. But, God's judgment? I don't think so.

I don't know how anyone can read scripture, which has two creation stories, two lists of the Ten Commandments, along with all of the ways in which scripture condones the subservience of women and the slavery of others, condemns left-handed people, and quotes Jesus as being very, very clear about divorce, and not understand that the Bible was simply not written to be taken that literally.

A wise man once told me that the Bible is not a law book, it's a guide book.

That is not a "disparage of Sacred Scripture". I read it through another lens -- the one without the blinders on. The one which allows me to engage my intellect and ask questions as I read. The one which allows me to open my heart and listen for the wings of the Holy Spirit flutter across the page and inspire me to love God more deeply. The one which allows me to open my eyes and seek the mind of Christ, that I may follow him into the heart of God.

The rest of the article, I found, was so mean-spirited and ill-informed that it is simply not worthy of comment.

There are lots of good books written on the subject of methods of biblical interpretation. There are also some wonderful books written by people who have struggled to make sense of what scripture has to say about homosexuality. I will only mention three: Is the Homosexual My Neighbor by Letha Scanzoni and Virginia Ramey Mollenkott, Embodiment by James B. Nelson, and any one of the three books written by John McNeil, a Jesuit and a self-affirming gay man.

You may find reading these very helpful in your pursuit of the truth.

I hope this has been helpful to you. I will be happy to send you a more complete bibliography if you wish.

Whatever happens as a result of this exchange, Otis, I promise you this: I will keep you in my prayers. Please pray for me, a fellow pilgrim on the pathway to find truth, and, in so doing, to catch a glimpse of the face of God.

(the Rev'd Canon) Elizabeth Kaeton


The four understandings of homosexuality articulated in the Lambeth report on Human Sexuality, and quoted below, accurately described the opinions held among us. There are:

"those who believe that homosexual orientation is a disorder, but that through the grace of Christ people can be changed, although not without pain and struggle;

"those who believe that relationships between people of the same gender should not include genital expression, that this is the clear teaching of the Bible and of the church universal, and that such activity (if unrepented of) is a barrier to the Kingdom of God;

"those who believe that committed homosexual relationships fall short of the biblical norm, but are to be preferred to relationships that are anonymous and transient;

"those who believe that the Church should accept and support or bless monogamous covenant relationships between homosexual people and that they may be ordained."

We therefore find ourselves in a process of discernment and "testing the spirits" and are instructed by the observation and wise words of His Grace, the Archbishop of Canterbury in a letter addressed to one of our primates, and which I have his permission to quote.

" First, let us remind ourselves that in reality the discussion at Canterbury was the very first time the bishops as a body had discussed it [homosexuality] at any length. A Resolution was passed that indicates where bishops stand NOW on the issue; it does not indicate that we shall ever rest there. That MAY be the case -- but who knows?

"Second, the debate showed -- and showed me more powerfully than I had ever seen before -- that argument and controversy solves nothing.

"We need a new kind of 'conversation' -- one that begins with respect for the integrity of another and a willingness to study the scriptures together, to reflect on our experience -- including the experience of homosexuals -- and to share in a process which attempts to put into practice what the writer Joseph Monti once called 'The Church as a community of moral discourse'. It is time we got a discourse going and started discouraging the polemic and bitterness that is around."

Therefore, in answer to your concerns, and in the interest of fostering conversation and "moral discourse" and an even greater relationship of affection and understanding, we invite each of you to visit those parts of our church which cause you concern so that you may inquire and learn directly what has animated certain responses to the above mentioned resolutions.

July 11 I thank you for your prompt and sensitive July 10 response to my E-mail of July 8. My inquiry is in part attributed to the Bishops statement regarding “the four understandings” in the Lambeth report, as follows:

“Therefore, in answer to your concerns, and in the interest of fostering conversation and ‘moral discourse’ and an even greater relationship of affection and understanding, we invite each of you to visit those parts of our church which cause you concern so that you may inquire and learn directly what has animated certain responses to the above mentioned resolutions.”

Those four resolutions are repeated as follows with my comments on each one:

“those who believe that homosexual orientation is a disorder, but that through the grace of Christ people can be changed, although not without pain and struggle;”

Comment: I agree with this, for it is verified by my own experience. I will clarify this later.

"those who believe that relationships between people of the same gender should not include genital expression, that this is the clear teaching of the Bible and of the church universal, and that such activity (if unrepented of) is a barrier to the Kingdom of God;”

Comment: I agree, for this dispenses with the problem of sexual lust, the infamous calling of the flesh.

"those who believe that committed homosexual relationships fall short of the biblical norm, but are to be preferred to relationships that are anonymous and transient;”

Comment: I think the debate is often confused by the issue of those who are loving, same-sex companions as contrasted with the perception and reality of homosexuals who advocate “genital expression.”

"those who believe that the Church should accept and support or bless monogamous covenant relationships between homosexual people and that they may be ordained."
Comment: This conclusion is obviously where the great debate is centered; it specifies what will be the decided in Denver.

With this preamble in mind, I wish to ask a few questions about the statement made in your E-mail regarding Scripture. Your recitations about Genesis 18 (I believe you meant 19?) and Leviticus are understood. Respected commentators hold Paul’s statements in 1Cor 6:9 and Rom 1:24-27 were founded on the Old Testament declarations. I am particularly interested in your view of these verses “in the interest of fostering conversation and ‘moral discourse’ and an even greater relationship of affection and understanding,” as stated by the Bishop.

Considering your suggestion, I have looked up homosexuality on amazon.com, and I have ordered Scrogg’s “The New Testament and Homosexuality” and McNeill’s “The Church and Homosexuality.” After considering these, I will consider your other suggestions. In light of your offer to send me “a more complete bibliography,” I would be pleased to receive it if the task is not too burdensome for you.

I respect your wish to dismiss those parts of the article that you consider to be “mean-spirited and ill-informed.” With your permission, I may wish to raise them at a later time. But, first may I have your comments regarding1Cor 6:9 and Rom 1:24-27?


July 12 Dear Otis, I am perfectly delighted that you have ordered both McNeil's and Scrogg's books. You may also find books by Daniel Helmeniack (sp) and especially THE GOOD BOOK by Peter Gomes very helpful.

As I've said, I'm really not a biblical scholar, so I'd prefer to wait until after you've read Scrogg's and McNeil's books before we have that discussion. Even at that, I repeat that while you will not be discussing scripture with someone who is not educated, you will not be in conversation with a scholar, either.

I do want to address your comment concerning "changed homosexual behavior". Let me be very, very, clear: ANY behavior, ANY SEXUAL BEHAVIOR can be changed. Case in point: I was married for seven years and had two children with this man I thought I loved. When I came to understand that my marriage was a disaster and my life was in chaos because, in great part, of my God-given sexual ORIENTATION, I had some decisions to make. I had to change my behavior.

Once I accepted the way God made me, my orientation, I could change my heterosexual behavior and behave in a way which had greater authenticity and integrity with God's creation. I suspect that, if someone has been in a homosexual relationship which has produced an unhappy life, one can also make choices to change one's BEHAVIOR. That, however, does not change one's ORIENTATION.

My experience as a pastoral counselor with many, many gay men who have made this choice to change their BEHAVIOR and marry a woman is that this almost always has disastrous results. I am working with a couple right now, in fact, who have two preteen children, recent converts from Catholicism, who have been living with the reality that he is gay.

They are not the first to tell me that in their "Separated/Divorced Catholics Support Group", the predominant reason for the separation or divorce is due to the homosexuality of one (usually male) of the couple -- primarily because of continued infidelity.

This particular couple has decided to have an "open" marriage and stay together -- "for the sake of the children". I'm not certain of the wisdom of this, but it is not my decision to make for them. It is my job to help them live with their decision, pointing out the problems along the way, and helping them to make adjustments in their course.

By the way, he's as happy as a clam -- and she , , , well, I cannot bear to look at the pain in her eyes for fear that I will burst into tears.

They are very much like two priests I know. Both gay men. Both married to women. Both with two children. They stay married because, at this point, it provides them the life they want to live -- community support, family relationships, etc. However, they both live duplicitous lives and have been seen in the most dangerous gay bars in a nearby big city. Not surprisingly, both are ardently anti-ordination of women and lesbigays. It's very, very sad.

All of this is to say that I think that "changed homosexual behavior" is an unfortunate term which denies or masks the complexity and mystery of the gift of sexuality. There is a wide range of sexual expression: celibate to promiscuous, heterosexual, bisexual, gay and lesbian to transgender.

When Kinsey spoke of 10% of the population being homosexual, he was referring to one aspect of the entire spectrum of sexual orientation. This is the 10% who have NO choice about their homosexual orientation. There is, at the other end of the spectrum, another 10% who have NO choice about their own Heterosexual orientation.

Everyone else falls somewhere along the continuum, depending on a combination of nature, nurture, intimacy needs, cultural expectations, family roles, etc., etc., etc.

I also have a problem with the term "sexual lust" which you use. I think it's more aptly described as "adolescent behavior", which, as you may know, knows no chronological boundaries.

Mature people of ANY sexual orientation have impulse control on ALL of their appetites -- including their sexual ones. Indeed, if one watches movies or TV, there seems to be a much greater problem with heterosexual lust than a tiny segment of the lesbigay population -- who also do not identify as being Christian.

Which leads me to my final point. The fact is that I, like you and like most people, can behave sexually with anyone: hetero, homo or auto. That's not the point. For me, genital expression of one's sexuality flows out of one's sense of intimacy, one's need to be in relationship. That is involved with issues of trust and emotion. Which stems from one's understanding of self. Which flows from one's own nature and the way one has been nurtured. Which are gifts from God.

What is obscene about the present debate is our need to demonize people. I have a friend who says that the worst thing to happen to people of color and lesbians and gay men is that the Cold War ended. What she is saying is that now that we've stopped fighting "the commies", we've found another "enemy".

Archbishop Tutu has said, "The Lord of the Church would not be where the Church is on this issue (of homosexuality)". I believe he's right. Enough for now. Enjoy your reading. Elizabeth+

July 12 Elizabeth. I thank you again for your prompt reply. I need to digest what you have said, and I will give send you another message as soon as I have. This is really heavy stuff! Otis

Summary notes on Kaeton’s e-mail of July 12:

1- There is a wide range of sexual expression: celibate to promiscuous, heterosexual, bisexual, gay and lesbian to transgender.

2- 10% of the population being homosexual ; at the other end of the spectrum, another 10% who have NO choice about their own Heterosexual orientation.

3- Everyone else falls somewhere along the continuum, depending on a combination of nature, nurture, intimacy needs, cultural expectations, family roles, etc., etc., etc.

4- "sexual lust" is more aptly described as "adolescent behavior", which, as you may know, knows no chronological boundaries.

5- Mature people of ANY sexual orientation have impulse control on ALL of their appetites -- including their sexual ones.

6- there seems to be a much greater problem with heterosexual lust than a tiny segment of the lesbigay population -- who also do not identify as being Christian.

7- The fact is that I, like you and like most people, can behave sexually with anyone: hetero, homo or auto. That's not the point.

8- genital expression of one's sexuality flows out of one's sense of intimacy, one's need to be in relationship. That is involved with issues of trust and emotion.
Which stems from one's understanding of self. Which flows from one's own nature and the way one has been nurtured. Which are gifts from God.

9- What is obscene about the present debate is our need to demonize people.
"The Lord of the Church would not be where the Church is on this issue (of homosexuality)".

July 13 Dear Elizabeth, I have been promised delivery of McNeil's and Scrogg's books on the morrow. After their reading I will definitely consider Helmeniack’s (sp) and Gomes’ books, as you have suggested.

You say you are not a Biblical scholar. Neither am I. But that fact should not deter either of us. The great wonder and marvel of the Scriptures is our being able to read them, compare the commentaries on them, and trace these commentaries through time. This allows us to understand and judge the evolution of doctrine. Biblical scholarship, like all scholarship, is tested on the meeting ground of application, where life’s reality compromises theory and challenges precepts formally held. That is why I am very interested in what you said in your last e-mail.

I will return to the Scripture question after my readings, for I sense the Scriptural consideration would be premature in light of your last e-mail.

Your statements are startling. They have inspired a number of observations, questions and possible conclusions. So I beg for your patience while I seek confirmation and affirmation on a number of points you have made.

1 - You make an important distinction regarding Behavior and Orientation. You conclude Behavior can change but one’s Orientation does not. You suggest Orientation is God-given, in essence a gift.

Questions: Do you equate Behavior to conduct? Is improper Behavior wrong either in terms of intent or execution? Does improper Behavior equate to Biblical sin? Does Orientation apply exclusively to one’s sexuality? Or does Orientation like Behavior have different manifestations?

2 - You suggest, by example, where one’s behavior contradicts one’s orientation that person is troubled.

Question: Can a person of one orientation “love” another of a different orientation? (Where loves definition is truly the caring for another that is greater than the caring for one’s self.)

3 - You further postulate an important concept: that in the spectrum of orientations, at one extreme are homosexuals (say 10%) and the other heterosexuals (10%) and the great middle 80% cover “a wide range of sexual expression,” “depending on a combination of nature, nurture, intimacy needs, cultural expectations, family roles, etc.”

Comment and question: Is this an accurate interpretation of your statement? This is a remarkable concept. Can you give me some authoritative and/or explanatory references on this concept. If the concept is your perception only, can you more fully explain the concepts of Behavior and Orientation as they apply to this mass of humanity, the 80%? Are Behavior and Orientation a fluid state for the 80% based on the factors you stated?

4 - You then make the claim that “‘sexual lust’ is more aptly described as ‘adolescent behavior’, which knows no chronological boundaries.” Then, “Mature people of ANY sexual orientation have impulse control on ALL of their appetites -- including their sexual ones.”

Comment and Question: I believe I understand the subtle point you are making in terms of “adolescent behavior.” The point on “maturity” is really profound, in the context of all you have said. Does an immature sexual appetite, misapplied in terms of behavior, constitute sinful conduct? Is this Augustine’s “concupiscence? May I equate “sexual lust”, a term you deplore, to “sexual appetite” as you have characterized it? Can “sexual lust” founded in love between two people be good? Does being a Christian effect, in any way, one’s behavior? Now a really important question: Can Christian behavior overcome or modify the “appetites” inspired by one’s orientation?

5 - You conclude this section of your e-mail by stating a great truth, that, “there seems to be a much greater problem with heterosexual lust than a tiny segment of the lesbigay population -- who also do not identify as being Christian.”

Question: Are heterosexual womanizers an example of an Orientation where improper Behavior is evident? Is this behavior sinful? Of the 10% of confirmed heterosexuals, and the great 80% in the middle ground, how prevalent is the
the manifestation of male-heterosexual-womanizing? Is this practice quantifiably greater compared to the behavior of homosexuals? If so, what is your guesstimate?

6 - You answer one question in my last e-mail by saying, “genital expression of one's sexuality flows out of one's sense of intimacy, one's need to be in relationship. That is involved with issues of trust and emotion. Which stems from one's understanding of self. Which flows from one's own nature and the way one has been nurtured. Which are gifts from God.”

Comment and question: This is profound stuff, Elizabeth. There are few keys in Scripture about this mystery. The question here is framed by the possible motive for “genital expression.” Is that motive “selfish” or “loving”, where lust’s fulfillment in “genital expression” is exclusively or mutually obtained?

7 – I wish to comment on your final thought, “What is obscene about the present debate is our need to demonize people.” I am trying to understand this, and you are being very generous with me in explaining your view. If I was to take a course in “Human Sexuality 101”, would the concepts that you have enunciated in your last e-mail to me, the basis for my questions and comments in this e-mail, be fully explained? Or, are your comments the source of your own knowledge based on exclusive personal experience or a consensus that is being developed by a few people, such as yourself? Do I make myself clear?

Please bear with me, for I do not wish to try your patience. I am trying very hard to understand. Otis.


July 13 Otis, I'm not sure why I'm responding to you. I don't know what you do for a living, but my pastoral and administrative responsibilities are pretty absorbing. If you didn't live in California, I'd ask that you stop by for a face to face visit. I'm quite certain we'd get more accomplished in an hour in person than hours in cyberspace.

However, there is something compelling about your questions, something refreshingly honest and earnest, and, I think, important to you. I guess I'm still drawn by such inquiries and find them irresistible.

My day began at 6 AM at the bedside of a woman who is dying of breast cancer and will end sometime tonight around 9 when I come home from a liturgy being conducted by the Clergy of Color Caucus to bid farewell to a man for whom I was Spiritual Director during his process of vocational discernment (he also happened to be the first man of color to be ordained in this diocese and is a dear friend).

My day seems to be filled with loss of one sort or another. Forgive me if I sound weary. I have 25 minutes before my next appointment -- for the past 5 years I have been chair of the board of the AIDS Resource Center in Newark -- for two years prior to that, I was it's Executive Director. Let's see how much I can accomplish before God calls me to the next bit of work.

1. Yes, when I speak of behavior I am speaking about the way one conduct's one's self. "Improper" behavior is an interesting term, isn't it? Who judges which behavior is "improper"? See, I'm not sure what that means, exactly. Paul talks about behavior that is "outside one's nature" as being sin. So, when one performs an act which is "outside of one's nature" (which, for me, is the impulse to do good, to love mercy and do justice and walk humbly with God, as Micah says), is one way to define sin.

Our Catechism defines sin as "the seeking of our own will instead of the will of God, thus distorting our relationship with God, with other people, and with all creation." (BCP pg 848). This, to me, makes Paul's words sound like a verse in this wonderful song of faith, if you read that being "outside of one's nature" as "seeking our own will instead of the will of God".

I am using the word "orientation" to describe sexuality, and yes, orientation has a wide variety of manifestations, all over the human spectrum, from hetero, lesbian, gay, bi, and transgender to asexual.

2. Can a person of one orientation "love" another of a different orientation? Why, of course! I personally would give my life for any one of my Bishops. I believe they would lay down their lives for me. As far as I know, every one of my bishops are male and heterosexual. Do I want to have sex with any of them? No.

3. Based on my reading of Kinsey and Nelson, and my 29 years as a registered nurse and 13 years as a pastoral counselor, I have come to a place of confidence in making these statement.

4. Here is where you are working too hard to split hairs. I suspect a very strong undercurrent of fundamentalist thinking. There's the voice of a very punitive judge in all of your questions. The most telling, however is this: "Can Christian behavior overcome or modify the "appetites" inspired by one's orientation?"

My goodness, Otis, just read about the life of King David to know whether or not the love of God is an inoculation against "lust". A dear Roman Catholic priest friend of mine said it best when I caught him admiring a woman who walked into church: "Just because I'm on a diet, doesn't mean I'm not interested in what's on the menu."

Here's how I see it -- and I do not mean this to be interpreted in the narrow, judgmental way which seems to be your first impulse: Once one knows God through Christ, one always seeks the path which leads to the greatest good. Does that modify behavior? Of course it does. Straight and gay. Male and female. Old and young. Good and bad. So,

5. Yes -- if by a "womanizer" you mean a heterosexual male who uses women for sexual gratification only -- a life in Christ CAN change this behavior. Clearly, "using women" or any other person does not place one on the path which leads to the greatest good. Is promiscuity "sinful"? On the face of it, it would seem that the easy answer is "yes". However, I have known people for whom episodic promiscuity has been the pathway to the greatest good. If that person had not fallen so far from grace, they never would have discovered just how much God loves them.

Besides, it's getting harder and harder to define promiscuity. Bette Midler may have really struck a resonant cord when she said, "A promiscuous person is anyone who is getting it more than me." That's a little bawdy, even for me, but you get the point. It's all a matter of judgment isn't it? And, who judges? Who among us is without sin? Is someone who has been married 5 times guilty of "legal promiscuity"? Who decides?

Luther was right in his advice: "Sin boldly. But love more boldly still."

In the final analysis, it has to do with the unconditional love of God and the free gift of grace. You didn't do anything to deserve either. You can't do anything which will make you worthy of God's love or grace. It is yours for the asking. And, if you mess up, all you have to do is to earnestly repent of your fall from grace and it is yours for the asking -- no questions asked.

You are not justified by works alone, but by faith.

God is amazing -- absolutely amazing, no? It's why Paul said that nothing, absolutely NO THING can keep you from the love of God in Christ Jesus -- not powers or principalities, not even YOU can keep YOU from the love of God. God will search you out and put a fire in your bones, like Jeremiah, until you are disturbed enough to return to God.

Gotta go and do my Mother's work. I don't know how long I can keep this up. Why not read some more and then we'll have another 'cyber chat' Just remember, Otis: NO THING CAN KEEP YOU FROM THE LOVE OF GOD. Not even YOU!
Blessings, Elizabeth+

July 13 Now Elizabeth, this is Otis. I promise to not bother you again until after this e-mail and I have done some reading. But I must comment on your e-mail's ending, to wit: "NO THING CAN KEEP YOU FROM THE LOVE OF GOD. Not even YOU!"

I disagree, Elizabeth. Sin can keep you away from the love of God. Since you called on Luther, I will also. The following is from his commentary on Romans: "Hence Christ calls unbelief the only sin, when he says, in John 16, 'The Spirit will rebuke the world for sin, because they do not believe in me.' For this reason, too, before good or bad works are done, which are the fruits, there must first be faith or unbelief, which is the root, the sap, the chief power of all sin."

I disagree with the teachings of Julian of Norwich, that there is no wrath in God. Romans 1:18-32 clearly says there is a wrath. It is sin that separates us from God via the quenching and grieving of His Spirit. But, we need not argue; I do want you to know that there are going to be some things I disagree with you on.

What I am trying to understand from you, based on what you have "taught" me, is netted out as follows as it pertains to sin: I believe you are saying one's orientation is not the basis for sin; behavior is. And as we map the spectrum of orientations there is only one issue, and that is how our behavior effects our "sinfulness" in the eyes of the Triune God. Am I getting close?

About me, I am an old fella (age 68) from the State of Maine. I worked in the computer industry all my life, having started with IBM back in '53. I have done a lot of things. I started the first company to build floppy disk drives back in '73. I lived in Princeton one time, and have relatives in Jersey. I didn't become a Christian until I was 54. And I was a bad-actor before that event when the Holy Spirit came into my life. I believe He has done His work in me (Rom 6).

I am still married to the same woman (She's from Goshen, N.Y). We have four children all in their forties. And we have eleven grandchildren.

My narrowness is nothing more than my propensity for specificity, even in theological terms. What am I after? All I want is the truth, Elizabeth. Why are you talking to me? Without appearing arrogant, you may consider it a form of God's call. All I want is the truth. And I hope that He will disclose it to me one way or another. Otis


July 13 My dear man, I just got home after a very emotional good bye to my friend at church and then a quick stop over to my friend who is dying. She's getting closer to taking her leave of this earthly life. Her courage is amazing. I, on the other hand, am an amazing coward. Still. After all these years. Even though I know she is going from this place directly into the arms of Jesus, it's still hard to let her go. I'm already missing her.

So, I'm unwinding before I say my evening prayers and do Compline by checking into my e-mail, and there is your post. I suspect that, somehow, I knew you were also a "Maine-iac". I lived for 2 years in Bar Harbor and 5 years in Portland. That may be part of the draw. However, there is something more: I distinctly heard the flutter of wings at least once or twice while reading and responding to your post.

There is not doubt: God is in this with us. Of this, I am quite certain.

Well, Mr. Otis Page, Jr., you self-described 68 year old fella, you can disagree with me all you want, and I mean no disrespect, but I'm telling you here and now that not even sin can keep you from God and God's unconditional love for you. Indeed, sin, like all mistakes, can sometimes be the only opportunity we have to experience God's love. This probably sounds as incoherent as a fifth grader trying to explain the mystery and depth of God's love but here's my best shot:

God loves us so much that God allows us to make our own mistakes so that we can know just how much God loves us. You don't have to agree with that. But, if you are searching for the truth, there it is as I know it. We are loved. We are forgiven. No matter what. Everything else is just details. That's not just Good News. That's the greatest news there could possibly ever be. If I did not believe that as truth, I'd rather not take my next breath.

I suspect that may be way too simplistic for the sophisticated mind of a computer expert. No doubt, I sound like a foolish simpleton to you. But, you know, it's taken me all of my 50 years on this earth to accept that as truth, and sometimes, I scarce can take it in. It's the only thing which gives me the absolute confidence to assure dying people of their final resting place in the arms of Jesus. And, that we'll all be together again. Because we are loved before, into, during and out of this life and into the next.

Final word -- at least for a while: Yes, you've got it right. Orientation and behavior are different entities. Orientation is the way one is created. Behavior can be adapted or changed. Yes, belief in a Triune God can and does change behavior, can lead to a more ethical life, in keeping with traditional Biblical values: faithfulness, loyalty, lifelong monogamy, generosity, serving humankind, preserving creation, self-sacrifice, repentance, love, mercy, justice, humility, striving for excellence, returning to give thanks, and expressing praise and gratitude to God -- just to name a few.

Enjoy your reading. If you think there are books which have influenced your thinking which you feel I should read, don't hesitate to let me know them. I don't know if I'm supposed to be teaching you anything. I am just speaking the truth as I know it. And, like Jesus, I find that I often face critical issues with the same question with which he faced Pilot: "What is truth?" I may not know WHAT truth is, but I do know WHERE it is often hidden: in the midst of the struggle to find it.
I'll pray for you, Otis. Pray for me, a sinner of God's own continual and loving redemption.

Your sister in Christ, e

PS: You may want to revisit our Web page. There's a wonderful sermon by Virginia Ramey Mollenkott and one I preached for Pride Sunday. There's also pictures of our 10th Anniversary Celebration and our "float" in the NYC Pride Parade. You can also link onto Louie Crew's Web page. He's got an amazing section entitled JOY ANYWAY! A wonderful collection of essays and sermons by some of the real bright lights in the lesbian and gay Christian community.

Happy Reading.



July 13 Bar Harbor and Portland! My home town is Damariscotta. I left there
in '49 to make my fortune. Where did you go to school? Your writing is convicting even after I qualify your theology.

I know you want to let this go, and I do too, but I have one observation that is very much on my mind. Why the mixed signals from homosexuals. If they are born that way, and they believe it, even after all these years of persecution, why don't they just let it go in the name of "same sex companionship?"

This concept has been understood for years. No one really gives a damn what they do behind closed doors. They are just loving people holding hands. Doing no harm. Just doing their thing. They are despised no more than the town fool or the rich family in the neighborhood.

If the thrust of your belief is in a dedicated monogamous relationship where trust and fidelity is the bond, why hasn't this core of believers separated itself from the hard line openly militant homosexualism that really turns the majority of people off. These people are not believers and I believe they never will be. Why disparage your program by fronting the Homosexual Agenda in the Episcopal Church? Isn't that what the original quote inferred that I asked you to comment on?

I know you have been fighting "the good fight" and my observations are not new and are redundant. So forgive me if I belabor the obvious.

Regarding the thoughts about God's purpose, I believe the good news (the Gospel) is the bad news is ended for those who believe. I do believe His salvation is particular and limited. I do believe in election, the irresistibility of His grace, and the perseverance of the Saints. I have thought about it very seriously.

You may call me Calvinistic, but I refuse to carry that flag. Calvin was one of many commentators that I have studied. I do believe in the Bible and inspiration of the Spirit (1Cor 2:12). I used to read Romans every day! I have twelve commentaries on Romans and five complete Systematic Theologies. Read 'em all including John Miley (Arminium). My favorite heretics? Marcion and Pelagius. These bad guys made good things happen! Amen!

You may think of my theology as Christocentric with a great emphasis on His Holy Spirit, then Pauline traced through Augustine through Luther/Calvin, etc. I very much respect your belief and I understand it, for my wife's cousin is ordained. She lived in Montclair and has been active in the Jersey area. But this shouldn't separate us from my quest on the truth about the homosexual movement in the Church, unless you tire of me in this quest that I have. Otis
July 14 Otis, my dear, I do not tire of your writing. I'm actually amazed that the criticism I so often have of cyberspace -- that it is a one-dimensional and therefore not a good medium for conversation among strangers -- has gotten quite a dent in our exchanges. I feel as if I've known you for years, and yet I wouldn't recognize you if I passed you on the street tomorrow.

NO, I am not tired of your writing. I am simply swamped with work right now -- with the additional burden of trying to get ready to go on vacation for the month of August, which is a great deal of work, if that makes any sense.

I just answered your question about the politics of the Lesbigay Movement and its impact on Christian Lesbigays in an essay (Pride and the Shame-Bearers) I wrote for The Wellspring, the quarterly letter of The Oasis. If you send me your address, I'll be happy to send you a copy of what I wrote. I promise not to put you on our mailing list. It will be a one time deal. Just this info. Promise. It's up to you. Let me know.

In terms of the Calvin label -- listen, my friend, you have a right to name your own reality. Indeed, I have a great deal of problem with the label "liberal". Actually, I'm quite conservative, next to some of my friends, who actually scratch their heads in disbelief at some of my strongly held opinions. In other arenas, probably the ones in which you circulate, I'd be labeled a flaming radical, wanting to destroy everything Christianity stands for which, of course, is just not true.

I'm actually an Anglo-Catholic, liturgically, but preach more like an evangelical (I've been told/teased that makes me an Anglo-Baptist -- sort of "Just As I Am Without One Plea, With Incense"). If anything, I'm pretty orthodox -- I have my eyes firmly on the Way of Jesus -- who was pretty orthodox himself, which was why he was considered such a radical by the Sanhedrin. Does any of that make any sense?

Anyway, back to the salt mines. We're making paper fans for some of the Black churches in Newark which don't have any air conditioning. They have a picture of Jesus knocking at the door on the front and, on the back they say (ready?)

"I'm a FAN of The Oasis"

The old ladies will LOVE them! They don't understand for one red hot second what this ministry is all about, and they really don't care, but they absolutely ADORE my partner who is a nurse and comes once a month and takes their blood pressure and checks their sugar and their feet, and they LOVE our kids and always ask about them. They know I love Jesus and them and, in the final analysis, what all the fuss about anyway?

As Ms. Mozelle Waiters, now 84 years young, said to me once, "Chile, seem lak all some Christians wanna do is pick on somebody somehow to make theyselves feel better: blacks, women, and now, you folk. I'm sure that's like to break Jesus' heart. Jus don't pay them no never mind, honey. You live your life the way Jesus tells you to, and don't block the blessings that will come." Unfortunately, part of my work is to 'pay them some never mind', but that doesn't mean I have to block the blessings.

You have been a blessing in the midst of a whirlwind of activity. I have more hope now for reconciliation in the church that I've had in a long time. Shalom,e


July 14 Dear Elizabeth, You have been in my thoughts today. I understand your statement of your self-perceived orthodox inclination (the conservative side) contrasted with your aptitude for social activism magnified by your defined orientation (the liberal side).

This mornings papers announced the Vatican’s discipline of Sister Gramick and the Rev. Robert Nugent. The article emphasized the churches teaching, “orientation in and of itself is not sinful but is objectively disordered.” Paraphrased in terms of your teachings, I would state “the orientation is okay the behavior is not.” Now I believe you would disagree in this important respect: that the behavior is only wrong where its application is wrong. Am I correct?

Please send the article that will answer some of the questions raised in my last e-mail: My address is 606 Myrtle Street, Arroyo Grande, CA 93420.

I was frankly apprehensive when I read of the Vatican’s decision. This concern is for you, Elizabeth. I sense the issues here are rapidly coming to a close. I wish to understand it. The hope for “reconciliation” in your Church is certainly influenced by the Vatican’s decision and the weight of the arguments as I perceive and understand them at this time. Otis



July 14 Dear Otis, Thank you for your note. I deeply appreciate your concern, especially regarding Fr. Nugent and Sr. Gramick. Such a shame, isn't it? Doesn't the Vatican understand that they do no harm to the souls of Nugent and Gramick by punishing them for their wonderful acts of mercy and compassion? The Vatican only makes itself look foolish.

Actually, what the Vatican hasn't learned is that whenever they do something like this, they create their own martyrs, and martyrdom is one of the strongest and irresistible archetypes in the human psyche. They actually do more harm to themselves and their cause by creating martyrs. In thousands of years of doing this, you might have thought they'd learn from their mistakes. I suppose the best we can hope for is that in another thousand years, Nugent and Gramick will be issued an "official" apology -- just as they finally did to Gallileo. Pity.

However, Otis, I think you give too much credence to the Vatican's decision and it's influence on my Church's decision-making process. You know, throughout history, the church has never THOUGHT it's way into believing, it's always ACTED it's way into believing. Church sacristy enthusiasts like to say, "liturgy precedes theology".

In 1991, my friend Kim Byham called several priests in every single one of the Episcopal dioceses in the USA, and found that at least one priest in EVERY diocese had already performed -- and would continue to perform -- ceremonies of same gender blessing. With or without their Bishop's knowledge and/or approval. That was 8 years ago.

So, from where I sit, it looks to me that a vote to authorize same gender blessings in the church is inevitable. Just a matter of time. We almost elected an open, non celibate gay man as our bishop in this diocese last year. Last month, the same gay man, my dear friend, Gene Robinson, lost the episcopal election in the diocese of Rochester by seven votes.

We are blessing same gender relationships. We will have an openly gay or lesbian bishop in the house of bishops -- perhaps even before General Convention 2000 -- but certainly within the next 2-3 years. THEN, we will develop a theology around it. And, we'll learn to live with it. Some may leave. Not many, I suspect. Enough so we can stop arguing about this "issue" and get on with "mission" -- which is what God wants us to do and why Jesus came among us.

Oh, I grow so weary of being an "issue". It's so dehumanizing to have the sum total of my humanity reduced to the identification with a sex act. Its' all so tiresome. As you can see, my biggest sin is my impatience.

Even so, I really do believe that it's going to be okay. As my ordaining bishop (who, by the way, originally voted against the ordination of women) used to say, "If it is of God, it will have out." Amen.

Yes, you have me right. I am saying that orientation and behavior are different and that behavior is wrong where its application is wrong. That's truth as I have come to know it. That's obviously different from the "truth by blatant assertion" from the "infallible" source of wisdom at the Vatican. I take comfort in the fact, however, that I'm in pretty good company with people who also do not believe in the infallibility of the Pope. Nice man. Good man. Holy man. Infallible? No.

One last thing. It's regarding "reconciliation". I have a different take on the word. Most people think that this means "kiss and make it all better and everybody gets along just swell". I think it means, ultimately, "acceptance". That's more difficult. It doesn't mean that we're necessarily "nice" but it does mean we must be tolerant of different sorts and conditions of humankind.

It means that I have to accept the fact that some people will never understand me and my position and that others will have to accept the fact that I will never fully understand them and their positions.

However, Jesus never said we had to "like" one another. He said we had to LOVE one another. That's why he could call a tax collector and a zealot and a bunch of fishermen together and called them his disciples. They were RECONCILED TO EACH OTHER AND TO GOD THROUGH CHRIST.

If you and I -- two strangers in cyberspace, of different genders and ages, sexuality and political positions -- can begin to do that, then there's hope for the church -- mine and the Vatican.

That's where you've been a real blessing to me, Otis. You've given me reason to hope. Sometimes, it gets pretty thin out here on the front lines, you know? So, thank you. And, bless you.

And, I'll put my essay in the mail. I think I may also have an extra tape of a sermon I preached at last General Convention in Philly. It was absolutely awesome to be able to preach in front of more than 1,000 people. I was scared silly but it was a great opportunity to talk about the gift I think we (lesbian and gay folk) bring to the church.

Found it! I'll put it in the mail when I get to the office in the morning. Blessing, e


July 15 Dear Elizabeth. Whether Nugent and Gramick will be martyrs, scapegoats or examples is a question that will be decided in time. The credence of the Vatican's decision and its influence on the Episcopal Church's decision-making process will be determined in Denver in the year 2000, the introduction to the third millennium. Am I correct about that?

Many non Catholics have a great respect for the Catholic Church. Bound by the chains of tradition, it has been unwavering in the face of change. (I define tradition as the momentum of the past imposed on the future. ) Understanding this, your statement is amusing, "Church sacristy enthusiasts like to say, 'liturgy precedes theology.'" You need not be reminded a great portion of Christendom's doctrinal heritage is shaped by that tradition. I honor its formality and consider it no greater barrier to your cause than the informal unsettled reaction by Evangelicals.

You do understand there is an aroused, although quiet, concern about the Homosexual Agenda, this concern being masked by the Christian quest for understanding and the duty of love. But Christian discernment is also an issue. Again, I am eager to learn the priority of your ministry, whether it is focused on the issues of your Church or is it a plank in the national secular agenda?

You cite the progress in your Church, that at least one priest in every diocese has performed ceremonies of same gender blessing - with or without Bishop knowledge and/or approval; that a vote to authorize same gender blessings in the church is inevitable; that you will have an openly gay or lesbian bishop in the house of bishops within the next 2-3 years. Then you will develop a theology so arguing may cease and the Church can get on with what God wants you to do.

This will be an impressive accomplishment providing it happens. It suggests a revolution as contrasted to the orderly redevelopment of doctrine. It seems to me that this process cannot be insensitive to a "fundamental" issue, and that being the final judgment on Scripture's teachings. I have received Scrogg's and McNeill's books along with another, Homosexuality in the Church - Both Sides of the Debate, edited by Jeffrey S. Siker. I am starting my readings.

Believe me, Elizabeth, you are not the "issue;" your identification with a sex act is not the issue; your impatience is not the issue. The issue is whether it is of God or not. Have you ever considered the possibility that you might be wrong in your social quest? I understand the ministry to save souls, but the Homosexual Agenda is a "corporate call" and not an individual one. Is your support of the "corporate call" in conflict with your sincerely held love for the suffering lost soul who does not know Jesus Christ? Not only will God will out, but His truth will out. And what is His truth? Jesus Christ crucified (1Cor 1:23,24)!

Forgive my weakness in appealing to Scripture. I have this terrible lack of confidence when I am not supported by some authority to guide me. After all, Elizabeth, if I cannot trust myself, a senior man of 68 years, who still has all his marbles, who now has some doubt that he knows everything, how can he trust an enthusiastic lass such as yourself who appears to have a revolutionary intent on
changing the Church and all social norms on the teaching of sexuality. Forgive me, if the Pope is infallible, so are both you and I.

At least some rules seem to be emerging from what you are saying, such as
orientation and behavior are different and that behavior is wrong where its application is wrong. And another rule, such as your thoughts on "reconciliation," and your explanation of it meaning "acceptance." I think it is best said in 2Cor 14-19. Fantastic verses. Right up your alley! Scripture is great. Hooray for the Bible! (Excuse me for being carried off.)

In responding to your concluding comments, I am trying to understand you and your position. Cast in the prism of love, there can be understanding and reconciliation. If I have given you reason to hope then it is in the great hope for His truth. And I do think we can find and agree on His truth. We may not like it sometimes. The young rich ruler left confused. Jesus said the gate is narrow.

You are where "the rubber meets the road." There is no question in my mind you are trying to do the right thing in your ministry to individuals who are lost and suffering. The corporate issue concerns me and that is why I seek an understanding. I sincerely pray that you have the courage to examine yourself in your witness for Christ. Remember, Paul was wrong before Jesus intervened on the road to Damascus. If he could be wrong, and the Pope can be wrong, then there is a possibility that either one of us could be wrong. Could that be possible? Lord forbid.
Otis


July 15 Otis, Thanks for your note. I've just sent you a package of stuff this am. This may be more than you wanted, but as those who know me and love me still say, "Give her and inch . . ."

I hope this stuff I'm sending you does two things: first, to assure you that the only Homosexual Agenda (whatever that is) that I am working from is the Christian agenda for truth and justice, and second, to give you some of my thoughts about sin and redemption, because that seems to be a fundamental place where we disagree.

Please know that I'm not offering these thoughts of mine to you as "THE TRUTH" (whatever that means), but as what I have come to know and believe as truth for me. I am also not trying to convert you or change you. That's not my job. That's God's.

If I am being used by God for that purpose -- fine. If not, that's also fine. I can only speak for myself: I am already changed by our encounter in cyberspace. You have helped me with some new and valuable insights into how some beliefs are shaped and formed by personal experience.

I'm sending you my thoughts on these things for one reason and one reason only: because you asked. Blessings e


July 15 Dear Elizabeth, I thank you in advance for the package of "stuff." I will take your "inch" and consider your objectives: 1) to establish that your agenda "is the Christian agenda for truth and justice," and 2) to educate me on your thoughts about "sin and redemption." Great! As a candidate for the grave, an early demise, I deserve edification! These documents, along with my other readings when considered with our conversations, should give me a reasonable picture.

Since you are having a difficult time with the word TRUTH, do you feel more comfortable with the word and concept of WISDOM, the reason for my reference to 1Cor 1:24 in my last e-mail. Most people respect the definition that wisdom is the knowledge of the truth. I'm not trying to be legalistic, I am trying to understand in a framework of authority.

I realize you are very busy "on the firing line" and I am here reading, contemplating. Do I sense some tension? If it is me, say so! Please, don't let horns impair those "fluttering wings." I will be patient in attempting to understand. You have not represented your thoughts to be objective "truth." I understand they are your belief and knowledge of what is true.

With that said, I assume you have danced down the intellectual corridor called Epistemology, where thinkers make distinctions between opinion, faith, belief and knowledge. These concepts tend to be concise differentiation's for me in establishing truth and certainty. More on this at a later date?

You humble yourself in leaving it to God. But He may be speaking through both of us. We should soberly consider this possibility before you tire of this colloquy.

Are you serious that our exchange has changed your thinking by providing "some new and valuable insights into how some beliefs are shaped and formed by personal experience?" May I inquire what insights have you gained? I have learned a few things, and they important for my understanding, for "now we see in a mirror dimly."

I am still waiting to fully understand. And I welcome that which you are sending me. You are right, I have asked you for this. You have been most generous and patient. I thank you. Otis (Phil 1:2)

No comments:

Post a Comment