The strongest statement in any religious book, including Holy Scripture, specifying the constituency of the Trinity (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) is in Chapter Mormon 7 verse 7 of the Book of Mormon!
Yet, Mormons do not recognize the Trinity and Christ's deity!
Mormon 7:7 in the Book of Mormon:
"And he hath brought to pass the redemption of the world, whereby he that is found guiltless before him at the judgment day hath it given unto him to dwell in the presence of God in his kingdom, to sing ceaseless praises with the choir above, unto the Father, and unto the Son, and unto the Holy Ghost, which are one God, in a state of happiness which hath no end."
Dr. Albert Mohler wrote:
As an evangelical Christian theologian, I must clarify that Mormonism is in no way consistent with orthodox Christianity. It borrows Christian themes and texts, but its most basic beliefs directly contradict the central teachings of Christianity.Mormonism holds that God is an exalted man, with a physical body.
Christianity teaches that God is Spirit. Mormonism denies the historic Christian understandings of the Trinity, the person and work of Christ, and the doctrine of salvation. Christianity promises salvation through Christ’s atonement and the sinner’s justification by faith. Mormonism promises deification. Christianity calls for personal faith in Jesus Christ. Mormonism calls for obedience to its own teachings as the path to exaltation. Mormonism replaces belief in the sole authority of the Bible with other writings, including the Book of Mormon.
This list is only a brief summary of the vast chasm that separates Christianity from Mormonism. Put simply, Mormonism is not just another form of Christianity. It is a rejection of historic Christianity. Yet, Mormon 7:7 offers a great theological contradiction.
Saturday, August 1, 2009
BACKGROUND OF HOMOSEXUAL AGENDA
Historical Background
The gay rights movement in the US is traced to June 27, 1969, in New York City, when police raided a Greenwich Village bar, the Stonewall Inn, and bar patrons rebelled in protest.
Seven years later, in 1976, in Dade County, Florida, Anita Bryant led the first religious campaign against gay rights. Bryant's campaign (run by Bryant, her husband Bob Green, and a political operative named Ed Rowe, who went on to head the Church League of America briefly and later Christian Mandate) was in opposition to a vote by the Dade County commissioners to prohibit discrimination against gay men and lesbians in housing, public accommodation, and employment. Bryant promoted a successful referendum to repeal the commissioners' vote, and her campaign gained strength and notoriety.
In 1977, Anita Bryant inspired a similar campaign in California, where State Senator John Briggs, who had worked with Bryant in Miami, sponsored the "California Defend Our Children Initiative," a binding initiative on the general election ballot in November 1978. The initiative provided for charges against school teachers and others advocating, encouraging, or publicly and "indiscreetly" engaging in homosexuality.
It prohibited the hiring and required the firing of homosexuals if the school board deemed them unfit. This was in reaction to a 1975 California law preventing local school boards from firing teachers for homosexuality. California Defend Our Children, the organizing group supporting the initiative, was chaired by State Senator John Briggs. Rev. Louis Sheldon, now head of the Anaheim-based organization Traditional Values, was executive director. The initiative failed, but Rev. Louis Sheldon would remain extremely active in anti-homosexual organizing. That same year, David A. Noebel, later to head Summit Ministries of Colorado, published The Homosexual Revolution, which he dedicated to Anita Bryant.
Bryant's anti-homosexual campaign ended in 1979 with the collapse of her two organizations, Anita Bryant Ministries and Protect America's Children, which were hampered by a lack of political sophistication. Contemporary techniques in influencing the political system--direct mail, computer technology, religious television ministries--were not available to Bryant.
Although US history is dotted with right-wing movements led by preachers (such as Father Charles Coughlin, who used radio to enormous effect), at that time few religious fundamentalists and evangelicals were interested in the political sphere. Bryant herself was plagued by personal problems, such as divorce, and her organizations were unable to respond effectively to a boycott mounted against Florida's orange industry, for which Bryant was a major spokesperson.
Her organizations collapsed because they were unable to expand their base through direct mail and fundraising, to use the media to build that base, or to use the political system for their own religious ends. With the creation of the New Right at the end of the 1970s, a political movement was born that incorporated conservative fundamentalists and evangelicals as full partners. Now there were tremendous political resources available to the Religious Right, and the success and influence of religious fundamentalists in the spheres of public policy and popular opinion improved dramatically.
Under the benign influence of the Reagan Administration, the New Right and its Religious Right component flourished. Several major leaders emerged, their individual fortunes rising and falling, but their collective political clout reaching into new spheres of influence, especially the political sphere. A focus of attention that emerged with the advent of the New Right was a rollback of gains made by the gay rights movement.
The Second Right-Wing Anti-Homosexual Campaign
The "second" anti-homosexual campaign, born within the New Right in the early 1980s, has been a far more sophisticated one. It has been planned at the national level, carried out by at least 15 large national organizations using the most refined computer technology, showing an understanding of the political system, and therefore exerting influence only dreamed of by the first movement.
The effects of this new sophistication are:
to make local anti-homosexual campaigns appear to be exclusively grassroots efforts, when they are guided by major national organizations;
to increase the effect of each New Right organization's efforts by building networks and coalitions among the organizations and by coordinating political campaigns;
to camouflage the religious content of the organizing and create the more secular theme of "defense of the family";
to pursue the anti-homosexual campaign under the slogan "no special rights," despite that slogan's inaccuracy.
The Anti-Homosexual Campaign of the Early 1980s
The opening of the second anti-homosexual campaign can be traced to three events:
1. the 1982 publication of Enrique T. Rueda's massive The Homosexual Network (Old Greenwich, CT: Devin Adair Co.);
2. the onset of the AIDS epidemic, which in its earliest days in the US, was almost exclusively confined to the gay male community. (For an account of the earliest days of the AIDS epidemic, see Randy Shilts, And The Band Played On (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1987.);
3. the work of anti-gay activist Dr. Paul Cameron, director in the early 1980s of the Institute for the Scientific Investigation of Sexuality in Lincoln, Nebraska, and now chairperson of the Family Research Institute in Washington, DC. Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation would prove an early supporter of Dr. Cameron: FCF distributed copies of Cameron's "Model Sexuality Statute" in 1983.
Enrique Rueda's massive book, The Homosexual Network, is a thorough examination of the organizations, activities, and ideology of the gay rights movement. The book does not discuss AIDS, and much of its critique of homosexual organizations is directed at their liberalism. Rueda, a native of Cuba and a Catholic theologian, is also interested in the moral dimension of homosexuality and its offense against the church.
In 1987, the Free Congress Foundation, which had sponsored Rueda's book, developed a new condensation that updated the critique of homosexuality to include the AIDS crisis. This book, Gays, AIDS and You, by Michael Schwartz and Enrique Rueda, stands as a seminal work in the right's analysis of homosexuality in the context of the AIDS crisis. A quote from the introduction illustrates the significance of this book to an understanding of Colorado's Amendment 2:
"For the homosexual movement is nothing less than an attack on our traditional, pro-family values. And now this movement is using the AIDS crisis to pursue its political agenda. This in turn, threatens not only our values but our lives. . . .
"They are loved by God as much as anyone else. This we believe while affirming the disordered nature of their sexual condition and the evil nature of the acts this condition leads to, and while fully committed to the proposition that homosexuals should not be entitled to special treatment under the law. That would be tantamount to rewarding evil."
It is significant that Rueda wrote his two important critiques of the gay rights movement at the suggestion of, and under the sponsorship of, Paul Weyrich and the Free Congress Foundation, which Weyrich directs. FCF's early and important work on the issue of homosexuality foreshadowed a national campaign to highlight homosexuality as a threat to the well-being of Americans.
Paul Weyrich is a founder and central leader of the New Right. He was more astute than many in the New Right in his early appreciation of the potential of anti-gay themes in building the success of the New Right. But he was not alone in understanding the appeal of this issue in right-wing organizing. As early as 1978, Tim LaHaye, "family counselor," husband of Beverly LaHaye (head of Concerned Women for America), and prominent leader in both the pro-family and Religious Right components of the New Right, wrote The Unhappy Gays (Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers, 1978).
In 1983, Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority sent out at least three mailings that highlighted the threats of homosexuality and AIDS.
In a similar vein, Robert G. Grant's organization, Christian Voice, used the threat of homosexuality as a major theme in a fundraising letter that began, "I am rushing you this urgent letter because the children in your neighborhood are in danger."
Phyllis Schlafly, head of Eagle Forum and grande dame of the pro-family movement, made heavy use of the accusation of lesbianism in her early 1980s attacks on Equal Rights Amendment organizers. She argued that the ERA would promote gay rights, leading, for example, to the legitimization of same-sex marriages, the protection of gay and lesbian rights in the military, the protection of the rights of persons with AIDS, and the voiding of sodomy laws.
Dr. Paul Cameron is a tireless anti-gay activist who has played an important roll in encouraging punitive measures against people with AIDS. In 1983, the American Psychological Association dropped Cameron from its membership rolls "for a violation of the Preamble to the Ethical Principles of Psychologists." Despite being discredited by reputable social scientists, Cameron has served as an "expert" on homosexuality at numerous right-wing and Religious Right conferences, and was hired as a consultant on AIDS by California Assemblyman William Dannemeyer.
As the 1980s unfolded and the New Right achieved substantial gains on economic, military, and foreign policy issues, its Religious Right and pro-family sectors devoted their most passionate organizing to the anti-abortion crusade, where there were significant successes. The campaign against homosexuality was not a major focus in the mid-1980s, though it was never repudiated as a goal of right-wing organizing. A shared alarm and loathing over the gains of the gay rights movement was understood within the New Right.
The Current Anti-Homosexual Campaign
In the late 1980s, three issues reinvigorated the New Right's anti-homosexual activism and focused added attention at the national level. The first issue was the promotion of school curriculum reform to reflect a greater acceptance of gay men and lesbians (e.g., Project 10 in southern California). The second was the religious and political right's objection to public funding for homoerotic art. The third issue was the passage of gay rights ordinances, bills, and initiatives in the local sphere and in state legislatures. According to People for the American Way, 19 states and more than 100 cities and counties now have laws or executive orders protecting gay and lesbian rights.
It is commonly thought that the local responses to each of these three gay rights issues are grassroots efforts, mounted by outraged citizens stirred to action by local manifestations of "gay power." In fact, while local anti-homosexual groups did and do exist, their power and effectiveness is enormously enhanced by the technical assistance provided by national New Right organizations.
Colorado provides a case study of the effective involvement of national right-wing groups at the local level. Colorado for Family Values (CFV), the local group that sponsored Amendment 2, was founded by Coloradans Kevin Tebedo and Tony Marco, and is headed by Colorado Springs car dealer Will Perkins. It promotes itself as a grassroots group, but its tactics, success, and power are largely the result of support from a national anti-homosexual campaign mounted by the New Right. Five of the national organizations active in this campaign are represented on the executive and advisory boards of CFV: Focus on the Family, Summit Ministries, Concerned Women for America, Eagle Forum, and Traditional Values. Pat Robertson's Christian Coalition is not officially represented on the board of CFV, but has a strong presence in Colorado and is ubiquitous in anti-homosexual organizing nationally. Many other New Right and "old right" organizations are climbing on the anti-homosexual bandwagon as the issue becomes more prominent.
Colorado for Family Values has maintained adamantly that its strategy was not coordinated by national religious or political groups. However, according to People for the American Way, a Washington, DC, organization that monitors the right wing, "the Religious Right's anti-gay vendetta is not, as its leaders often claim, a spontaneous outpouring of concern about gay issues. Theirs is a carefully orchestrated political effort, with a unified set of messages and tactics, that is deliberately designed to foster division and intolerance." A review of the national organizations involved with Colorado's Amendment 2 will support this analysis.
Key Groups Active Against Homosexuality
Rev. Louis Sheldon's Traditional Values
Traditional Values (often called the Traditional Values Coalition) is headed by Rev. Louis Sheldon and is based in Anaheim, California. Rev. Sheldon and his organization have taken leadership within the Religious Right's anti-homosexual campaign. In October 1989, Rev. Sheldon led the "West Coast Symposium on Homosexuality and Public Policy Implications" in Orange County, California. Two of the featured speakers were Roger Magnuson, Esq., author of Are Gay Rights Right?, and Congressman William Dannemeyer, author of Shadow in the Land: Homosexuality in America.
Building on the success of the west coast symposium, Rev. Sheldon convened a January 1990 conference in Washington, DC, that was billed as a "national summit meeting on homosexuality." One of the two dominant themes of the conference was that homosexuals have, since the 1960s, been seeking "special protection over and above the equal rights already given to all Americans." This theme would later appear in Colorado as the central theme of the Colorado for Family Values' promotion of Amendment 2.
Rev. Louis Sheldon was an aide to Pat Robertson in 1987, and he shares much of Robertson's interest in the legal codification of moral issues. In 1988, Sheldon led the opposition to Project 10, a counseling program for gay adolescents in the Los Angeles school system. In 1986 and 1988, his zeal against homosexuals led him to endorse the California anti-homosexual initiatives sponsored by far right extremist Lyndon LaRouche. The initiatives sought, in effect, to require
quarantine for people with AIDS. Sheldon himself has advocated establishing "cities of refuge" for people with the HIV infection. In 1991, Sheldon submitted to the California attorney general a constitutional amendment that would bar civil rights laws from protecting homosexuals, unless approved by a two-thirds vote of the California voters. Sheldon has recently announced his intention to pursue in California an initiative modeled on Colorado's Amendment 2.
Focus on the Family
It is widely agreed that the 1991 arrival in Colorado Springs of Dr. James Dobson and his organization, Focus on the Family, was an important catalyst for Colorado Springs' local anti-homosexual organization, Colorado for Family Values. CFV had already led a successful campaign against a local gay rights ordinance. Focus on the Family, however, brought to Colorado Springs a tremendous influx of resources and sophisticated political experience: it arrived with 750 employees (and has since added another 300) and an annual budget of nearly $70 million, including a $4 million grant from the El Pomar Foundation to buy 50 acres in Colorado Springs. Focus on the Family is indeed a national organization. While it has no official ties to CFV, it has offered "advice" to CFV, and several Focus on the Family employees, such as public policy representative Randy Hicks, sit on CFV advisory boards. Focus on the Family has given an in-kind donation worth $8,000 to Colorado for Family Values.
Dr. Dobson's background is in pediatrics and he is best known as an advocate of traditional discipline and corporal punishment for children. However, his organization has also been heavily involved in anti-homosexual organizing. In 1988, Focus on the Family merged with the Washington, DC-based Family Research Council, headed by Gary L. Bauer. The Family Research Council distributed a "homosexual packet," available through Focus on the Family, which contained the lengthy document, The Homosexual Agenda: Changing Your Community and Nation. This detailed guide includes a section titled "Starting An Initiative." In October 1992, the Family Research Council separated from Focus on the Family after warnings from the Internal Revenue Service that the Council's lobbying activities were endangering Focus on the Family's tax-exempt status.
In keeping with the Family Research Council's anti-gay organizing, Focus on the Family's newsletters have shown an increase in anti-gay articles over the last several years. For instance, in the May 1990 Focus on the Family newsletter, Dr. Dobson himself began a column with the statement, "I am familiar with the widespread effort to redefine the family. It is motivated by homosexual activists and others who see the traditional family as a barrier to the social engineering they hope to accomplish." A March 1991 article in the newsletter uses this argument against treating gays equally: "There are people in our society who find sexual satisfaction from engaging in intercourse with animals. . . .Would anyone suggest that these groups deserve special protection?"
Summit Ministries
Summit Ministries of Manitou Springs, Colorado, is a little-known Religious Right organization whose work is national in scope. It is a 30-year-old Christian organization specializing in educational materials and summer youth retreats. Its president is Rev. David A. Noebel, formerly a prominent preacher in Rev. Billy James Hargis's Christian Crusade. As early as 1977, Noebel authored The Homosexual Revolution, in which he claims that "homosexuality rapidly is becoming one of America's most serious social problems." He has also written several books claiming that rock'n'roll and soul music are communist plots to corrupt US youth. Summit Ministries later published AIDS: Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome: A Special Report, co-authored by David Noebel, Wayne C. Lutton, and Paul Cameron. For the last several years, virtually every issue of The Journal, Summit Ministries' monthly newsletter, has contained several anti-homosexual entries. Summit Ministries has just published Noebel's new book, Understanding the Times: The Story of the Biblical Christian, Marxist/Leninist and Secular Humanist Worldviews.
Noebel's background with Rev. Billy James Hargis's Christian Crusade helps to explain the historical friendly relationship between Summit Ministries and the John Birch Society (JBS). Both the Christian Crusade and the John Birch Society represent a political sector known in political science literature as the "old right." Born out of the conviction that communism was rampant in the United States, both organizations believed that the civil rights movement was manipulated by communists, that the National Council of Churches promoted communism, and that the United Nations was controlled by communists. In 1962, Rev. Billy James Hargis purchased an old resort hotel in Manitou Springs, which was renamed The Summit. The Summit became a retreat and anti-communism summer college.
Summit's relationship with the John Birch Society is deeper than mere ideological affinity. In fact, in 1983, a donor responding to a John Birch Society fundraising letter sent a check to Robert Welch of JBS, and received a thank-you letter from Welch. The check, however, was made out to Summit Ministries.
Rev. David Noebel was a member of the John Birch Society until at least 1987, and for many years Summit Ministries took out full-page advertisements for its summer youth retreats in Review of the News and American Opinion, two John Birch Society publications.
Summit Ministries is also politically close to Dr. James Dobson and Focus on the Family. Dr. Dobson, especially since moving to Colorado, leads seminars at Summit Ministries, and his endorsement of Summit's work was prominent in Summit's material promoting its 30th anniversary. David Noebel is on the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values.
Beverly LaHaye's Concerned Women for America
Touting itself as the largest women's organization in America, Concerned Women for America claims a membership of 500,000, a number disputed by many. CWA was founded in 1979 as "the Christian women's answer to the National Organization for Women." It is based in Washington, DC, and organizes its member chapters through prayer circles and LaHaye's monthly newsletter. CWA distributes a pamphlet titled The Hidden Homosexual Agenda that condemns the homosexual agenda for seeking "to take away the right of those who believe that homosexuality is wrong and immoral to voice that opinion."
CWA's most recent anti-homosexual pamphlet is The Homosexual Deception: Making Sin A Civil Right. It is a reprint of a treatise by Tony Marco, co-founder of Colorado for Family Values, that CFV filed with the state of Colorado as evidence supporting the correctness of Amendment 2. Here, to give a local activist his due, we see the local group creating material that is then used by a national group--a reversal of the usual pattern. Concerned Women for America is represented on the CFV advisory board by the president of its Colorado chapter, Bert Nelson.
Phyllis Schlafly's Eagle Forum
Phyllis Schlafly's Eagle Forum, based in Alton, Illinois, is another national organization whose local affiliate is represented on the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values. Phyllis Schlafly is perhaps best known for her successful campaign against the Equal Rights Amendment. During that campaign, she used the threat of homosexual and lesbian privileges as a central argument to support her opposition to the ERA. Eagle Forum continues to oppose gay and lesbian rights.
Other National Groups Prominent in the Anti-Homosexual Campaign
Pat Robertson's Christian Coalition
Rev. Pat Robertson, longtime host of the cable television program "The 700 Club," and prominent leader of the Religious Right, ran unsuccessfully in the Republican presidential primary in 1988. In October 1989, Robertson used the 1.9 million names he had collected from his 1988 campaign to identify 175,000 key activists and donors, and launch the Christian Coalition. The new Coalition's stated goal was "to build the most powerful political force in American politics."
The 175,000 activists were contacted and urged to establish chapters of the Christian Coalition in their precincts. Five goals were identified:
1. build a grassroots network using professional field organizers and training schools;
2. construct a lobbying organization to work at the national and state levels in every state and in Washington, DC;
3. create a mass media outreach program;
4. build a legal arm to defend the gains made in state legislatures from challenge by the American Civil Liberties Union;
5. build a prayer network to unite all evangelical and pro-family voters.
Paul Weyrich of the Free Congress Foundation was an early endorser of the Christian Coalition.
The Christian Coalition's training tapes teach activists to fight those forces pursuing "an agenda of chaos." An early videotape distributed by the Christian Coalition used homosexual scenes to illustrate the moral decline of America; opposition to homosexuality has always been a commitment of the Christian Coalition.
However, it was the 1990 political battle over a gay rights initiative in Broward County, Florida, that moved the anti-homosexual agenda to prominence within the organization. In its literature, the Christian Coalition took credit for "spearheading" the defeat. It claims to have "led the charge and won a major political victory." Robertson calls on Christian Coalition members to "duplicate this success in your city and state and throughout the nation."
By 1992, the organization had grown dramatically. Ralph Reed, its executive director, claimed 250,000 members in 49 states and $13 million in the bank. The Christian Coalition launched an election year get-out-the-vote effort which included "in-pew" registration at churches, the distribution of up to 40 million "voter guides," and the use of computer-assisted telephone banks to help elect favored candidates in key races.
Reed's tactics are self-confessedly surreptitious. "I want to be invisible," he told one reporter. "I do guerrilla warfare. I paint my face and travel at night. You don't know it's over until you're in a body bag. You don't know until election night." Despite this statement, Reed later publicly distanced himself from the "stealth" strategy.
According to the Wall Street Journal, the Christian Coalition overwhelmingly has targeted local Republican Party precinct and county organizations for takeover. It works closely with Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation, which was founded in 1974 with money from the Coors family and its foundation. County Christian Coalition chapters have been directed to subscribe to Weyrich's National Empowerment Television (NET) satellite program. Ralph Reed is on the NET board.
Colorado for Family Values is not an affiliate of, nor is it funded by, the Christian Coalition (unlike the group that led the anti-homosexual initiative campaign in Oregon, the Oregon Citizens Alliance); the link between the Christian Coalition and Colorado's Amendment 2 is an indirect one. The National Legal Foundation of Chesapeake, Virginia (a conservative Christian legal organization founded by Pat Robertson and funded by Robertson's Christian Broadcasting Network, but no longer affiliated with Robertson), gave advice to Colorado for Family Values as early as 1991, long before Amendment 2 was on the ballot. The consultation was intended to help CFV formulate ballot language that would survive legal and political challenges. By the end of 1992, the National Legal Foundation had taken over much of the legal work of CFV.
The Berean League
The Berean League, based in St. Paul, Minnesota, has published Roger J. Magnuson's much-cited book Are Gay Rights Right? This discredited work was used by Tony Marco in the treatise he wrote for Colorado for Family Values. In addition to publishing Magnuson's book, the Berean League developed a successful campaign to oppose a local civil rights ordinance for gay men and lesbians. On the basis of that success, it began to conduct workshops at national conferences on "Strategies for Defeating Homosexual Privilege Proposals."
A Christian organization, the Berean League states in its promotional literature that "the League's authority is Scripture." Recently, it has issued a "Back-grounder" report titled Some Things You May Not Know About Homosexuality. An inflammatory three-page document, it was circulated in Oregon as a tool to organize support for Oregon's 1992 anti-homosexual Measure 9, the Abnormal Behavior Initiative.
The American Family Association
Headed by Rev. Donald Wildmon and based in Tupelo, Mississippi, the American Family Association has an annual budget of $5 million, and focuses primarily on profanity, adultery, homosexuality, and other forms of anti-Christian behavior and language on television. An earlier Wildmon organization was called CLeaR-TV (Christian Leaders for Responsible Television) and was based in Wheaton, Illinois. Wildmon has specialized in boycotting the corporate sponsors of shows which he dislikes. He called for a boycott of American Express because it sponsored the television program "L. A. Law," which ran an episode featuring a bisexual woman kissing another woman. Wildmon opposes even the depiction of homosexuality. One of his "top goals" for 1989 was to force off the air three TV shows ("Heartbeat," "Hooperman," and "thirtysomething") that, he said, "promote the homosexual lifestyle and portray practicing homosexuals in a positive light." Wildmon was accused of anti-Semitism for inflammatory comments he made during his campaign against the film The Last Temptation of Christ.
The Rutherford Institute
The Rutherford Institute, based in Manassas, Virginia, and founded and headed by John W. Whitehead, is a non-profit, legal defense organization associated with the far-right fringe of the Religious Right. Speakers listed in its Speakers Bureau include R. J. Rushdoony, a prominent Christian Reconstructionist. Reconstructionists believe that the text of the Bible provides the only legitimate basis for civil law. The most zealous wing of Reconstructionism has called for the death penalty for homosexuals, adulterers, and recalcitrant children. In 1992, the Rutherford Institute spearheaded a suit in Hawaii to block implementation of that state's new gay rights law.
The John Birch Society
The John Birch Society is another national organization with a prominent anti-homosexual agenda. JBS is not properly categorized as a New Right organization, but is best seen as "old right." Historically, the John Birch Society has existed as an isolationist, anti-communist organization. It was founded near the end of the McCarthy era, and expanded on Senator Joseph McCarthy's conspiracy theory of communist penetration of the United States. Since the death of its founder, Robert Welch, the JBS has moved from Belmont, Massachusetts, to Appleton, Wisconsin. Its recent concerns have been family issues, AIDS, US internationalist foreign policy, opposition to government regulations, and the right to bear arms. High on its list of concerns within family issues is homosexuality. The September and October 1992 issues of its publication, New American (published immediately before the November votes on anti-gay initiatives in Colorado and Oregon), carried anti-homosexual stories. The October story was a two-page article supporting Oregon's Abnormal Behavior Initiative.
Lyndon LaRouche: A Special Case
Lyndon LaRouche is a far-right political extremist who is now serving a 15-year sentence in federal prison for mail fraud and tax evasion. LaRouche runs a vast empire of organizations with ideological positions that exactly mimic his bizarre conspiracy theories. His followers are seen in airports and on street corners, often campaigning to free LaRouche from jail or attacking the organization's mortal enemy--Henry Kissinger. LaRouche's many organizations have always incorporated sexual themes into their analysis, and have been obsessed with AIDS since the pandemic began. LaRouche has conducted a long-running and fanatical campaign against homosexuality. Most recently, LaRouche spearheaded Proposition 64 in California, which would have established restrictive public health policies regarding AIDS. Proposition 64 was opposed by virtually all public health officials and elected officials (one exception was legislator William Dannemeyer). A public health specialist for the California Medical Association described Proposition 64 as "absolute hysteria and calculated deception." LaRouche organizers continue to peddle hysteria over AIDS and homosexuality. Their embrace of anti-Jewish and other scapegoating conspiracy theories and use of demagoguery add a firm base to the claim that the LaRouchians are a neo-fascist movement. Many New Right groups avoid any official alliance with the LaRouchians.
Analyzing the Anti-Homosexual Campaign's Coordination & Networking
Since its earliest days in the late 1970s, the New Right has been a political and religious movement that has self-consciously networked among its members. The Religious Roundtable, the Free Congress Foundation, the Heritage Foundation, Christian Voice, the Conservative Caucus, the Moral Majority, Eagle Forum, and Concerned Women for America, among others, have held frequent conferences, published in each other's journals and newsletters, and promoted legislation within the context of a sympathetic Republican administration.
The anti-homosexual campaign nests within a sector of the New Right known as the pro-family movement. The major national gathering for the pro-family movement is the Family Forum conference, held annually since 1981. The conference has usually been sponsored by Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation and Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority. These conferences are symptomatic of the coordination and networking among the New Right leadership. The issues of concern to the pro-family movement are aptly described in a 1984 promotional letter for Family Forum III. They are "important moral issues such as: the economic survival of the family, parents' rights in education, the homosexual movement, personal charity, child pornography, and abortion."
Reflecting the New Right leadership's shared opposition to homosexuality, the Family Forum conferences nearly always feature an anti-homosexual speaker. With the arrival of the AIDS epidemic, and the publication of Gays, AIDS and You, sponsored by the Free Congress Foundation, the anti-homosexual profile became much higher. We see the fruits of a decade of organizing by the pro-family movement of the New Right in the many challenges to gay rights bills and initiatives, and most recently in the anti-gay initiatives in Colorado and Oregon.
The analysis underlying the pro-family movement's morality is a fervent distrust and irrational hatred of "secular humanism," which is used as a shorthand for all that is evil and opposed to God. This distrust of secular humanism can be traced to the US nativist right at the turn of the century, which believed secular humanists were engaged in a conspiracy to undermine the United States. The purported conspiracy was linked, from its beginning, to an extreme fear of communism and its undermining effect on Christianity and the Christian family. Today, a major focus of the New Right, and particularly of the pro-family movement, is unrelenting opposition to the perceived secular humanist conspiracy. As Paul Weyrich describes it, "Well, first of all, from our point of view, this is really the most significant battle of the age-old conflict between good and evil, between the forces of God and the forces against God, that we have seen in our country."
For a better understanding of how fear of secular humanism serves as the theoretical basis for right-wing organizing, see the Berlet/Quigley chapter on the Culture War: Theocracy and Racism.
Camouflage of the Christian Agenda
In the discussion above, three of the four national New Right organizations playing the highest profile role in organizing support for Colorado's Amendment 2 are explicitly Christian organizations. However, the association of anti-homosexual organizing with religious (specifically Christian) principles is highlighted only when activists are targeting fellow Christians in order to recruit or educate them. When organizing in the wider political arena, anti-homosexual organizing is cast in the secular terms of "family values" and "defense of the family."
This is an important aspect of the Religious Right's organizing style. Since the mid-1980s, when the heavy-handed style of Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority lost popularity, the Christian Right has cast its campaigns in terms not so obviously linked to the Bible. Ralph Reed of the Christian Coalition refers to the soft-peddling of the religious message in his own organization's work as conducting a "stealth campaign."
In the case of the anti-homosexual campaign, the Religious Right has dwelt on calumnious depictions of predatory behavior by homosexuals. Various anti-gay campaigns have accused homosexuals of eating feces, molesting children, and destroying the family. Many of these characterizations are "documented" by the work of Dr. Paul Cameron and Roger J. Magnuson. Oregon's 1992 anti-gay initiative (which was rejected by the voters) equates homosexuality with "pedophilia, sadism or masochism." While it is only in explicitly religious attacks on homosexuals that homosexuality is equated with Satan, that connection is uncontroversial among many involved in organizing against homosexuals.
Though the religious basis of this anti-homosexual fervor often is not mentioned, occasionally this bias becomes clear. On February 10, 1992, Bill McCartney, head football coach at the University of Colorado at Boulder, said at a press conference that homosexuality is a "sin" that is "an abomination of almighty God." McCartney is a member of the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values. Former US Representative William Armstrong, who describes himself as having had a "life-changing experience" when he became born again, is chairman of the advisory board of CFV.
But the clearest revelation of the religious basis for the work of CFV is a talk given by Kevin Tebedo, CFV executive director, at the First Congregational Church in Colorado Springs on August 23, 1992. In this setting, Tebedo states that Amendment 2 "is about authority."
He goes on to say, "It's about whose authority takes precedence in the society in which we live. . . [I]s it the authority of God? The authority of the supreme King of Kings and Lord of Lords? You see, we say we should have the separation of church and state, but you see, Jesus Christ is the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords. That is politics; that is rule; that is authority."
In spite of the obvious preeminence of Christian principles in the values of its national organizational supporters and some of its advisory board members, the literature of Colorado for Family Values does not refer to Christianity, Biblical admonitions regarding homosexuality, or religious principles. A large CFV packet of information dated January 9, 1992, does not mention a religious basis for CFV's work. Finally, there is no mention of religion in the CFV Mission Statement.
The History of "No Special Rights"
Another area of deception in the public face of the anti-homosexual campaign is its assertion that lesbians and gay men are seeking "special rights" or "special protections." This was the guiding premise behind Anita Bryant's campaign, was raised again by Enrique Rueda in The Homosexual Network and Gays, AIDS and You, and eventually emerged as the slogan of the national anti-homosexual campaign. In the case of Colorado's Amendment 2, the slogan was the dominant theme of CFV's advertising and promotion.
The use of "no special rights" is purposefully misleading. Gay rights initiatives do not provide "special rights," but a guarantee of equal rights for lesbians and gay men. Amendment 2 would deny equal protection against discrimination only to this group. CFV's decision to use "no special rights" only in its public materials and not in the legal language of the amendment itself was made on the advice of the National Legal Foundation.
A June 1991 letter from Brian McCormick of NLF advises CFV to stay away from the "no special rights" language in its legal formulations, but to use it as the centerpiece of its public campaign. Coloradans were bombarded with advertisements and flyers all drumming home the message that Amendment 2 did nothing but reverse the unfair granting of "special rights" through gay rights initiatives. Future anti-gay initiatives will undoubtedly continue the use of the "no special rights" slogan because the cohesiveness of the right's anti-homosexual campaign virtually guarantees that local initiatives will follow the lead of national organizations.
Conclusion
Calvinist attitudes toward sex, based in religious teaching that sex is only for procreation, and a patriarchal culture that is discomforted by any breaking down of rigid sex roles, combine to create a culture that can deal with homosexuality, if at all, only in the artistic and commercial spheres.
The lesbian and gay civil rights movement has pushed homosexuality out of the artistic and commercial world and into the political and social sphere. This is almost guaranteed to create a backlash while society absorbs and adjusts to new values.
While that backlash may be inevitable, it can be tamped down or fanned by political forces. This review of the right wing's organizing to promote a backlash against the gay rights movement is a study in reaction. Deprived of its old enemies and needing a new issue to promote, the right's anti-homosexual organizing is rank opportunism. The anti-gay backlash is generating funds, keeping right-wing organizations that were in danger of complete eclipse alive with an infusion of new support, and generating the all-important evidence of political power--media attention.
The threat this backlash represents is very real. Violence is its most blatant manifestation, but the litany of pain and waste caused by homophobia includes subtle attacks on gay men and lesbians as well. Furthermore, confronting the backlash distracts time, energy, and money from the work necessary to bring about equal rights for lesbians and gay men.
The skillful manipulation of homophobia by the right wing creates anti-gay sentiment and actions that bolster and promote intolerance.
In the United States, we must decide what role the church and religious tenets are going to play, especially when those tenets are in conflict with the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
It is not an attack on Christianity or religion to question the propriety of imposing Biblical law on a secular society. If ours is a society in which church and state are separate, then the prohibitions of church dogma cannot overrule the protections provided by the Constitution. And the Constitution, to paraphrase Mr. Justice McKenna in the 1910 case of Weems v. U.S., is progressive--it is not fastened to the obsolete, but may acquire new meaning as public opinion becomes enlightened by a humane justice.
Jean Hardisty, who holds a doctorate in political science, is Director of Political Research Associates. She is working on a book on the resurgent right. This article appeared in The Public Eye, March 1993. © 1995, Jean Hardisty.
The gay rights movement in the US is traced to June 27, 1969, in New York City, when police raided a Greenwich Village bar, the Stonewall Inn, and bar patrons rebelled in protest.
Seven years later, in 1976, in Dade County, Florida, Anita Bryant led the first religious campaign against gay rights. Bryant's campaign (run by Bryant, her husband Bob Green, and a political operative named Ed Rowe, who went on to head the Church League of America briefly and later Christian Mandate) was in opposition to a vote by the Dade County commissioners to prohibit discrimination against gay men and lesbians in housing, public accommodation, and employment. Bryant promoted a successful referendum to repeal the commissioners' vote, and her campaign gained strength and notoriety.
In 1977, Anita Bryant inspired a similar campaign in California, where State Senator John Briggs, who had worked with Bryant in Miami, sponsored the "California Defend Our Children Initiative," a binding initiative on the general election ballot in November 1978. The initiative provided for charges against school teachers and others advocating, encouraging, or publicly and "indiscreetly" engaging in homosexuality.
It prohibited the hiring and required the firing of homosexuals if the school board deemed them unfit. This was in reaction to a 1975 California law preventing local school boards from firing teachers for homosexuality. California Defend Our Children, the organizing group supporting the initiative, was chaired by State Senator John Briggs. Rev. Louis Sheldon, now head of the Anaheim-based organization Traditional Values, was executive director. The initiative failed, but Rev. Louis Sheldon would remain extremely active in anti-homosexual organizing. That same year, David A. Noebel, later to head Summit Ministries of Colorado, published The Homosexual Revolution, which he dedicated to Anita Bryant.
Bryant's anti-homosexual campaign ended in 1979 with the collapse of her two organizations, Anita Bryant Ministries and Protect America's Children, which were hampered by a lack of political sophistication. Contemporary techniques in influencing the political system--direct mail, computer technology, religious television ministries--were not available to Bryant.
Although US history is dotted with right-wing movements led by preachers (such as Father Charles Coughlin, who used radio to enormous effect), at that time few religious fundamentalists and evangelicals were interested in the political sphere. Bryant herself was plagued by personal problems, such as divorce, and her organizations were unable to respond effectively to a boycott mounted against Florida's orange industry, for which Bryant was a major spokesperson.
Her organizations collapsed because they were unable to expand their base through direct mail and fundraising, to use the media to build that base, or to use the political system for their own religious ends. With the creation of the New Right at the end of the 1970s, a political movement was born that incorporated conservative fundamentalists and evangelicals as full partners. Now there were tremendous political resources available to the Religious Right, and the success and influence of religious fundamentalists in the spheres of public policy and popular opinion improved dramatically.
Under the benign influence of the Reagan Administration, the New Right and its Religious Right component flourished. Several major leaders emerged, their individual fortunes rising and falling, but their collective political clout reaching into new spheres of influence, especially the political sphere. A focus of attention that emerged with the advent of the New Right was a rollback of gains made by the gay rights movement.
The Second Right-Wing Anti-Homosexual Campaign
The "second" anti-homosexual campaign, born within the New Right in the early 1980s, has been a far more sophisticated one. It has been planned at the national level, carried out by at least 15 large national organizations using the most refined computer technology, showing an understanding of the political system, and therefore exerting influence only dreamed of by the first movement.
The effects of this new sophistication are:
to make local anti-homosexual campaigns appear to be exclusively grassroots efforts, when they are guided by major national organizations;
to increase the effect of each New Right organization's efforts by building networks and coalitions among the organizations and by coordinating political campaigns;
to camouflage the religious content of the organizing and create the more secular theme of "defense of the family";
to pursue the anti-homosexual campaign under the slogan "no special rights," despite that slogan's inaccuracy.
The Anti-Homosexual Campaign of the Early 1980s
The opening of the second anti-homosexual campaign can be traced to three events:
1. the 1982 publication of Enrique T. Rueda's massive The Homosexual Network (Old Greenwich, CT: Devin Adair Co.);
2. the onset of the AIDS epidemic, which in its earliest days in the US, was almost exclusively confined to the gay male community. (For an account of the earliest days of the AIDS epidemic, see Randy Shilts, And The Band Played On (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1987.);
3. the work of anti-gay activist Dr. Paul Cameron, director in the early 1980s of the Institute for the Scientific Investigation of Sexuality in Lincoln, Nebraska, and now chairperson of the Family Research Institute in Washington, DC. Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation would prove an early supporter of Dr. Cameron: FCF distributed copies of Cameron's "Model Sexuality Statute" in 1983.
Enrique Rueda's massive book, The Homosexual Network, is a thorough examination of the organizations, activities, and ideology of the gay rights movement. The book does not discuss AIDS, and much of its critique of homosexual organizations is directed at their liberalism. Rueda, a native of Cuba and a Catholic theologian, is also interested in the moral dimension of homosexuality and its offense against the church.
In 1987, the Free Congress Foundation, which had sponsored Rueda's book, developed a new condensation that updated the critique of homosexuality to include the AIDS crisis. This book, Gays, AIDS and You, by Michael Schwartz and Enrique Rueda, stands as a seminal work in the right's analysis of homosexuality in the context of the AIDS crisis. A quote from the introduction illustrates the significance of this book to an understanding of Colorado's Amendment 2:
"For the homosexual movement is nothing less than an attack on our traditional, pro-family values. And now this movement is using the AIDS crisis to pursue its political agenda. This in turn, threatens not only our values but our lives. . . .
"They are loved by God as much as anyone else. This we believe while affirming the disordered nature of their sexual condition and the evil nature of the acts this condition leads to, and while fully committed to the proposition that homosexuals should not be entitled to special treatment under the law. That would be tantamount to rewarding evil."
It is significant that Rueda wrote his two important critiques of the gay rights movement at the suggestion of, and under the sponsorship of, Paul Weyrich and the Free Congress Foundation, which Weyrich directs. FCF's early and important work on the issue of homosexuality foreshadowed a national campaign to highlight homosexuality as a threat to the well-being of Americans.
Paul Weyrich is a founder and central leader of the New Right. He was more astute than many in the New Right in his early appreciation of the potential of anti-gay themes in building the success of the New Right. But he was not alone in understanding the appeal of this issue in right-wing organizing. As early as 1978, Tim LaHaye, "family counselor," husband of Beverly LaHaye (head of Concerned Women for America), and prominent leader in both the pro-family and Religious Right components of the New Right, wrote The Unhappy Gays (Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers, 1978).
In 1983, Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority sent out at least three mailings that highlighted the threats of homosexuality and AIDS.
In a similar vein, Robert G. Grant's organization, Christian Voice, used the threat of homosexuality as a major theme in a fundraising letter that began, "I am rushing you this urgent letter because the children in your neighborhood are in danger."
Phyllis Schlafly, head of Eagle Forum and grande dame of the pro-family movement, made heavy use of the accusation of lesbianism in her early 1980s attacks on Equal Rights Amendment organizers. She argued that the ERA would promote gay rights, leading, for example, to the legitimization of same-sex marriages, the protection of gay and lesbian rights in the military, the protection of the rights of persons with AIDS, and the voiding of sodomy laws.
Dr. Paul Cameron is a tireless anti-gay activist who has played an important roll in encouraging punitive measures against people with AIDS. In 1983, the American Psychological Association dropped Cameron from its membership rolls "for a violation of the Preamble to the Ethical Principles of Psychologists." Despite being discredited by reputable social scientists, Cameron has served as an "expert" on homosexuality at numerous right-wing and Religious Right conferences, and was hired as a consultant on AIDS by California Assemblyman William Dannemeyer.
As the 1980s unfolded and the New Right achieved substantial gains on economic, military, and foreign policy issues, its Religious Right and pro-family sectors devoted their most passionate organizing to the anti-abortion crusade, where there were significant successes. The campaign against homosexuality was not a major focus in the mid-1980s, though it was never repudiated as a goal of right-wing organizing. A shared alarm and loathing over the gains of the gay rights movement was understood within the New Right.
The Current Anti-Homosexual Campaign
In the late 1980s, three issues reinvigorated the New Right's anti-homosexual activism and focused added attention at the national level. The first issue was the promotion of school curriculum reform to reflect a greater acceptance of gay men and lesbians (e.g., Project 10 in southern California). The second was the religious and political right's objection to public funding for homoerotic art. The third issue was the passage of gay rights ordinances, bills, and initiatives in the local sphere and in state legislatures. According to People for the American Way, 19 states and more than 100 cities and counties now have laws or executive orders protecting gay and lesbian rights.
It is commonly thought that the local responses to each of these three gay rights issues are grassroots efforts, mounted by outraged citizens stirred to action by local manifestations of "gay power." In fact, while local anti-homosexual groups did and do exist, their power and effectiveness is enormously enhanced by the technical assistance provided by national New Right organizations.
Colorado provides a case study of the effective involvement of national right-wing groups at the local level. Colorado for Family Values (CFV), the local group that sponsored Amendment 2, was founded by Coloradans Kevin Tebedo and Tony Marco, and is headed by Colorado Springs car dealer Will Perkins. It promotes itself as a grassroots group, but its tactics, success, and power are largely the result of support from a national anti-homosexual campaign mounted by the New Right. Five of the national organizations active in this campaign are represented on the executive and advisory boards of CFV: Focus on the Family, Summit Ministries, Concerned Women for America, Eagle Forum, and Traditional Values. Pat Robertson's Christian Coalition is not officially represented on the board of CFV, but has a strong presence in Colorado and is ubiquitous in anti-homosexual organizing nationally. Many other New Right and "old right" organizations are climbing on the anti-homosexual bandwagon as the issue becomes more prominent.
Colorado for Family Values has maintained adamantly that its strategy was not coordinated by national religious or political groups. However, according to People for the American Way, a Washington, DC, organization that monitors the right wing, "the Religious Right's anti-gay vendetta is not, as its leaders often claim, a spontaneous outpouring of concern about gay issues. Theirs is a carefully orchestrated political effort, with a unified set of messages and tactics, that is deliberately designed to foster division and intolerance." A review of the national organizations involved with Colorado's Amendment 2 will support this analysis.
Key Groups Active Against Homosexuality
Rev. Louis Sheldon's Traditional Values
Traditional Values (often called the Traditional Values Coalition) is headed by Rev. Louis Sheldon and is based in Anaheim, California. Rev. Sheldon and his organization have taken leadership within the Religious Right's anti-homosexual campaign. In October 1989, Rev. Sheldon led the "West Coast Symposium on Homosexuality and Public Policy Implications" in Orange County, California. Two of the featured speakers were Roger Magnuson, Esq., author of Are Gay Rights Right?, and Congressman William Dannemeyer, author of Shadow in the Land: Homosexuality in America.
Building on the success of the west coast symposium, Rev. Sheldon convened a January 1990 conference in Washington, DC, that was billed as a "national summit meeting on homosexuality." One of the two dominant themes of the conference was that homosexuals have, since the 1960s, been seeking "special protection over and above the equal rights already given to all Americans." This theme would later appear in Colorado as the central theme of the Colorado for Family Values' promotion of Amendment 2.
Rev. Louis Sheldon was an aide to Pat Robertson in 1987, and he shares much of Robertson's interest in the legal codification of moral issues. In 1988, Sheldon led the opposition to Project 10, a counseling program for gay adolescents in the Los Angeles school system. In 1986 and 1988, his zeal against homosexuals led him to endorse the California anti-homosexual initiatives sponsored by far right extremist Lyndon LaRouche. The initiatives sought, in effect, to require
quarantine for people with AIDS. Sheldon himself has advocated establishing "cities of refuge" for people with the HIV infection. In 1991, Sheldon submitted to the California attorney general a constitutional amendment that would bar civil rights laws from protecting homosexuals, unless approved by a two-thirds vote of the California voters. Sheldon has recently announced his intention to pursue in California an initiative modeled on Colorado's Amendment 2.
Focus on the Family
It is widely agreed that the 1991 arrival in Colorado Springs of Dr. James Dobson and his organization, Focus on the Family, was an important catalyst for Colorado Springs' local anti-homosexual organization, Colorado for Family Values. CFV had already led a successful campaign against a local gay rights ordinance. Focus on the Family, however, brought to Colorado Springs a tremendous influx of resources and sophisticated political experience: it arrived with 750 employees (and has since added another 300) and an annual budget of nearly $70 million, including a $4 million grant from the El Pomar Foundation to buy 50 acres in Colorado Springs. Focus on the Family is indeed a national organization. While it has no official ties to CFV, it has offered "advice" to CFV, and several Focus on the Family employees, such as public policy representative Randy Hicks, sit on CFV advisory boards. Focus on the Family has given an in-kind donation worth $8,000 to Colorado for Family Values.
Dr. Dobson's background is in pediatrics and he is best known as an advocate of traditional discipline and corporal punishment for children. However, his organization has also been heavily involved in anti-homosexual organizing. In 1988, Focus on the Family merged with the Washington, DC-based Family Research Council, headed by Gary L. Bauer. The Family Research Council distributed a "homosexual packet," available through Focus on the Family, which contained the lengthy document, The Homosexual Agenda: Changing Your Community and Nation. This detailed guide includes a section titled "Starting An Initiative." In October 1992, the Family Research Council separated from Focus on the Family after warnings from the Internal Revenue Service that the Council's lobbying activities were endangering Focus on the Family's tax-exempt status.
In keeping with the Family Research Council's anti-gay organizing, Focus on the Family's newsletters have shown an increase in anti-gay articles over the last several years. For instance, in the May 1990 Focus on the Family newsletter, Dr. Dobson himself began a column with the statement, "I am familiar with the widespread effort to redefine the family. It is motivated by homosexual activists and others who see the traditional family as a barrier to the social engineering they hope to accomplish." A March 1991 article in the newsletter uses this argument against treating gays equally: "There are people in our society who find sexual satisfaction from engaging in intercourse with animals. . . .Would anyone suggest that these groups deserve special protection?"
Summit Ministries
Summit Ministries of Manitou Springs, Colorado, is a little-known Religious Right organization whose work is national in scope. It is a 30-year-old Christian organization specializing in educational materials and summer youth retreats. Its president is Rev. David A. Noebel, formerly a prominent preacher in Rev. Billy James Hargis's Christian Crusade. As early as 1977, Noebel authored The Homosexual Revolution, in which he claims that "homosexuality rapidly is becoming one of America's most serious social problems." He has also written several books claiming that rock'n'roll and soul music are communist plots to corrupt US youth. Summit Ministries later published AIDS: Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome: A Special Report, co-authored by David Noebel, Wayne C. Lutton, and Paul Cameron. For the last several years, virtually every issue of The Journal, Summit Ministries' monthly newsletter, has contained several anti-homosexual entries. Summit Ministries has just published Noebel's new book, Understanding the Times: The Story of the Biblical Christian, Marxist/Leninist and Secular Humanist Worldviews.
Noebel's background with Rev. Billy James Hargis's Christian Crusade helps to explain the historical friendly relationship between Summit Ministries and the John Birch Society (JBS). Both the Christian Crusade and the John Birch Society represent a political sector known in political science literature as the "old right." Born out of the conviction that communism was rampant in the United States, both organizations believed that the civil rights movement was manipulated by communists, that the National Council of Churches promoted communism, and that the United Nations was controlled by communists. In 1962, Rev. Billy James Hargis purchased an old resort hotel in Manitou Springs, which was renamed The Summit. The Summit became a retreat and anti-communism summer college.
Summit's relationship with the John Birch Society is deeper than mere ideological affinity. In fact, in 1983, a donor responding to a John Birch Society fundraising letter sent a check to Robert Welch of JBS, and received a thank-you letter from Welch. The check, however, was made out to Summit Ministries.
Rev. David Noebel was a member of the John Birch Society until at least 1987, and for many years Summit Ministries took out full-page advertisements for its summer youth retreats in Review of the News and American Opinion, two John Birch Society publications.
Summit Ministries is also politically close to Dr. James Dobson and Focus on the Family. Dr. Dobson, especially since moving to Colorado, leads seminars at Summit Ministries, and his endorsement of Summit's work was prominent in Summit's material promoting its 30th anniversary. David Noebel is on the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values.
Beverly LaHaye's Concerned Women for America
Touting itself as the largest women's organization in America, Concerned Women for America claims a membership of 500,000, a number disputed by many. CWA was founded in 1979 as "the Christian women's answer to the National Organization for Women." It is based in Washington, DC, and organizes its member chapters through prayer circles and LaHaye's monthly newsletter. CWA distributes a pamphlet titled The Hidden Homosexual Agenda that condemns the homosexual agenda for seeking "to take away the right of those who believe that homosexuality is wrong and immoral to voice that opinion."
CWA's most recent anti-homosexual pamphlet is The Homosexual Deception: Making Sin A Civil Right. It is a reprint of a treatise by Tony Marco, co-founder of Colorado for Family Values, that CFV filed with the state of Colorado as evidence supporting the correctness of Amendment 2. Here, to give a local activist his due, we see the local group creating material that is then used by a national group--a reversal of the usual pattern. Concerned Women for America is represented on the CFV advisory board by the president of its Colorado chapter, Bert Nelson.
Phyllis Schlafly's Eagle Forum
Phyllis Schlafly's Eagle Forum, based in Alton, Illinois, is another national organization whose local affiliate is represented on the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values. Phyllis Schlafly is perhaps best known for her successful campaign against the Equal Rights Amendment. During that campaign, she used the threat of homosexual and lesbian privileges as a central argument to support her opposition to the ERA. Eagle Forum continues to oppose gay and lesbian rights.
Other National Groups Prominent in the Anti-Homosexual Campaign
Pat Robertson's Christian Coalition
Rev. Pat Robertson, longtime host of the cable television program "The 700 Club," and prominent leader of the Religious Right, ran unsuccessfully in the Republican presidential primary in 1988. In October 1989, Robertson used the 1.9 million names he had collected from his 1988 campaign to identify 175,000 key activists and donors, and launch the Christian Coalition. The new Coalition's stated goal was "to build the most powerful political force in American politics."
The 175,000 activists were contacted and urged to establish chapters of the Christian Coalition in their precincts. Five goals were identified:
1. build a grassroots network using professional field organizers and training schools;
2. construct a lobbying organization to work at the national and state levels in every state and in Washington, DC;
3. create a mass media outreach program;
4. build a legal arm to defend the gains made in state legislatures from challenge by the American Civil Liberties Union;
5. build a prayer network to unite all evangelical and pro-family voters.
Paul Weyrich of the Free Congress Foundation was an early endorser of the Christian Coalition.
The Christian Coalition's training tapes teach activists to fight those forces pursuing "an agenda of chaos." An early videotape distributed by the Christian Coalition used homosexual scenes to illustrate the moral decline of America; opposition to homosexuality has always been a commitment of the Christian Coalition.
However, it was the 1990 political battle over a gay rights initiative in Broward County, Florida, that moved the anti-homosexual agenda to prominence within the organization. In its literature, the Christian Coalition took credit for "spearheading" the defeat. It claims to have "led the charge and won a major political victory." Robertson calls on Christian Coalition members to "duplicate this success in your city and state and throughout the nation."
By 1992, the organization had grown dramatically. Ralph Reed, its executive director, claimed 250,000 members in 49 states and $13 million in the bank. The Christian Coalition launched an election year get-out-the-vote effort which included "in-pew" registration at churches, the distribution of up to 40 million "voter guides," and the use of computer-assisted telephone banks to help elect favored candidates in key races.
Reed's tactics are self-confessedly surreptitious. "I want to be invisible," he told one reporter. "I do guerrilla warfare. I paint my face and travel at night. You don't know it's over until you're in a body bag. You don't know until election night." Despite this statement, Reed later publicly distanced himself from the "stealth" strategy.
According to the Wall Street Journal, the Christian Coalition overwhelmingly has targeted local Republican Party precinct and county organizations for takeover. It works closely with Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation, which was founded in 1974 with money from the Coors family and its foundation. County Christian Coalition chapters have been directed to subscribe to Weyrich's National Empowerment Television (NET) satellite program. Ralph Reed is on the NET board.
Colorado for Family Values is not an affiliate of, nor is it funded by, the Christian Coalition (unlike the group that led the anti-homosexual initiative campaign in Oregon, the Oregon Citizens Alliance); the link between the Christian Coalition and Colorado's Amendment 2 is an indirect one. The National Legal Foundation of Chesapeake, Virginia (a conservative Christian legal organization founded by Pat Robertson and funded by Robertson's Christian Broadcasting Network, but no longer affiliated with Robertson), gave advice to Colorado for Family Values as early as 1991, long before Amendment 2 was on the ballot. The consultation was intended to help CFV formulate ballot language that would survive legal and political challenges. By the end of 1992, the National Legal Foundation had taken over much of the legal work of CFV.
The Berean League
The Berean League, based in St. Paul, Minnesota, has published Roger J. Magnuson's much-cited book Are Gay Rights Right? This discredited work was used by Tony Marco in the treatise he wrote for Colorado for Family Values. In addition to publishing Magnuson's book, the Berean League developed a successful campaign to oppose a local civil rights ordinance for gay men and lesbians. On the basis of that success, it began to conduct workshops at national conferences on "Strategies for Defeating Homosexual Privilege Proposals."
A Christian organization, the Berean League states in its promotional literature that "the League's authority is Scripture." Recently, it has issued a "Back-grounder" report titled Some Things You May Not Know About Homosexuality. An inflammatory three-page document, it was circulated in Oregon as a tool to organize support for Oregon's 1992 anti-homosexual Measure 9, the Abnormal Behavior Initiative.
The American Family Association
Headed by Rev. Donald Wildmon and based in Tupelo, Mississippi, the American Family Association has an annual budget of $5 million, and focuses primarily on profanity, adultery, homosexuality, and other forms of anti-Christian behavior and language on television. An earlier Wildmon organization was called CLeaR-TV (Christian Leaders for Responsible Television) and was based in Wheaton, Illinois. Wildmon has specialized in boycotting the corporate sponsors of shows which he dislikes. He called for a boycott of American Express because it sponsored the television program "L. A. Law," which ran an episode featuring a bisexual woman kissing another woman. Wildmon opposes even the depiction of homosexuality. One of his "top goals" for 1989 was to force off the air three TV shows ("Heartbeat," "Hooperman," and "thirtysomething") that, he said, "promote the homosexual lifestyle and portray practicing homosexuals in a positive light." Wildmon was accused of anti-Semitism for inflammatory comments he made during his campaign against the film The Last Temptation of Christ.
The Rutherford Institute
The Rutherford Institute, based in Manassas, Virginia, and founded and headed by John W. Whitehead, is a non-profit, legal defense organization associated with the far-right fringe of the Religious Right. Speakers listed in its Speakers Bureau include R. J. Rushdoony, a prominent Christian Reconstructionist. Reconstructionists believe that the text of the Bible provides the only legitimate basis for civil law. The most zealous wing of Reconstructionism has called for the death penalty for homosexuals, adulterers, and recalcitrant children. In 1992, the Rutherford Institute spearheaded a suit in Hawaii to block implementation of that state's new gay rights law.
The John Birch Society
The John Birch Society is another national organization with a prominent anti-homosexual agenda. JBS is not properly categorized as a New Right organization, but is best seen as "old right." Historically, the John Birch Society has existed as an isolationist, anti-communist organization. It was founded near the end of the McCarthy era, and expanded on Senator Joseph McCarthy's conspiracy theory of communist penetration of the United States. Since the death of its founder, Robert Welch, the JBS has moved from Belmont, Massachusetts, to Appleton, Wisconsin. Its recent concerns have been family issues, AIDS, US internationalist foreign policy, opposition to government regulations, and the right to bear arms. High on its list of concerns within family issues is homosexuality. The September and October 1992 issues of its publication, New American (published immediately before the November votes on anti-gay initiatives in Colorado and Oregon), carried anti-homosexual stories. The October story was a two-page article supporting Oregon's Abnormal Behavior Initiative.
Lyndon LaRouche: A Special Case
Lyndon LaRouche is a far-right political extremist who is now serving a 15-year sentence in federal prison for mail fraud and tax evasion. LaRouche runs a vast empire of organizations with ideological positions that exactly mimic his bizarre conspiracy theories. His followers are seen in airports and on street corners, often campaigning to free LaRouche from jail or attacking the organization's mortal enemy--Henry Kissinger. LaRouche's many organizations have always incorporated sexual themes into their analysis, and have been obsessed with AIDS since the pandemic began. LaRouche has conducted a long-running and fanatical campaign against homosexuality. Most recently, LaRouche spearheaded Proposition 64 in California, which would have established restrictive public health policies regarding AIDS. Proposition 64 was opposed by virtually all public health officials and elected officials (one exception was legislator William Dannemeyer). A public health specialist for the California Medical Association described Proposition 64 as "absolute hysteria and calculated deception." LaRouche organizers continue to peddle hysteria over AIDS and homosexuality. Their embrace of anti-Jewish and other scapegoating conspiracy theories and use of demagoguery add a firm base to the claim that the LaRouchians are a neo-fascist movement. Many New Right groups avoid any official alliance with the LaRouchians.
Analyzing the Anti-Homosexual Campaign's Coordination & Networking
Since its earliest days in the late 1970s, the New Right has been a political and religious movement that has self-consciously networked among its members. The Religious Roundtable, the Free Congress Foundation, the Heritage Foundation, Christian Voice, the Conservative Caucus, the Moral Majority, Eagle Forum, and Concerned Women for America, among others, have held frequent conferences, published in each other's journals and newsletters, and promoted legislation within the context of a sympathetic Republican administration.
The anti-homosexual campaign nests within a sector of the New Right known as the pro-family movement. The major national gathering for the pro-family movement is the Family Forum conference, held annually since 1981. The conference has usually been sponsored by Paul Weyrich's Free Congress Foundation and Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority. These conferences are symptomatic of the coordination and networking among the New Right leadership. The issues of concern to the pro-family movement are aptly described in a 1984 promotional letter for Family Forum III. They are "important moral issues such as: the economic survival of the family, parents' rights in education, the homosexual movement, personal charity, child pornography, and abortion."
Reflecting the New Right leadership's shared opposition to homosexuality, the Family Forum conferences nearly always feature an anti-homosexual speaker. With the arrival of the AIDS epidemic, and the publication of Gays, AIDS and You, sponsored by the Free Congress Foundation, the anti-homosexual profile became much higher. We see the fruits of a decade of organizing by the pro-family movement of the New Right in the many challenges to gay rights bills and initiatives, and most recently in the anti-gay initiatives in Colorado and Oregon.
The analysis underlying the pro-family movement's morality is a fervent distrust and irrational hatred of "secular humanism," which is used as a shorthand for all that is evil and opposed to God. This distrust of secular humanism can be traced to the US nativist right at the turn of the century, which believed secular humanists were engaged in a conspiracy to undermine the United States. The purported conspiracy was linked, from its beginning, to an extreme fear of communism and its undermining effect on Christianity and the Christian family. Today, a major focus of the New Right, and particularly of the pro-family movement, is unrelenting opposition to the perceived secular humanist conspiracy. As Paul Weyrich describes it, "Well, first of all, from our point of view, this is really the most significant battle of the age-old conflict between good and evil, between the forces of God and the forces against God, that we have seen in our country."
For a better understanding of how fear of secular humanism serves as the theoretical basis for right-wing organizing, see the Berlet/Quigley chapter on the Culture War: Theocracy and Racism.
Camouflage of the Christian Agenda
In the discussion above, three of the four national New Right organizations playing the highest profile role in organizing support for Colorado's Amendment 2 are explicitly Christian organizations. However, the association of anti-homosexual organizing with religious (specifically Christian) principles is highlighted only when activists are targeting fellow Christians in order to recruit or educate them. When organizing in the wider political arena, anti-homosexual organizing is cast in the secular terms of "family values" and "defense of the family."
This is an important aspect of the Religious Right's organizing style. Since the mid-1980s, when the heavy-handed style of Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority lost popularity, the Christian Right has cast its campaigns in terms not so obviously linked to the Bible. Ralph Reed of the Christian Coalition refers to the soft-peddling of the religious message in his own organization's work as conducting a "stealth campaign."
In the case of the anti-homosexual campaign, the Religious Right has dwelt on calumnious depictions of predatory behavior by homosexuals. Various anti-gay campaigns have accused homosexuals of eating feces, molesting children, and destroying the family. Many of these characterizations are "documented" by the work of Dr. Paul Cameron and Roger J. Magnuson. Oregon's 1992 anti-gay initiative (which was rejected by the voters) equates homosexuality with "pedophilia, sadism or masochism." While it is only in explicitly religious attacks on homosexuals that homosexuality is equated with Satan, that connection is uncontroversial among many involved in organizing against homosexuals.
Though the religious basis of this anti-homosexual fervor often is not mentioned, occasionally this bias becomes clear. On February 10, 1992, Bill McCartney, head football coach at the University of Colorado at Boulder, said at a press conference that homosexuality is a "sin" that is "an abomination of almighty God." McCartney is a member of the advisory board of Colorado for Family Values. Former US Representative William Armstrong, who describes himself as having had a "life-changing experience" when he became born again, is chairman of the advisory board of CFV.
But the clearest revelation of the religious basis for the work of CFV is a talk given by Kevin Tebedo, CFV executive director, at the First Congregational Church in Colorado Springs on August 23, 1992. In this setting, Tebedo states that Amendment 2 "is about authority."
He goes on to say, "It's about whose authority takes precedence in the society in which we live. . . [I]s it the authority of God? The authority of the supreme King of Kings and Lord of Lords? You see, we say we should have the separation of church and state, but you see, Jesus Christ is the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords. That is politics; that is rule; that is authority."
In spite of the obvious preeminence of Christian principles in the values of its national organizational supporters and some of its advisory board members, the literature of Colorado for Family Values does not refer to Christianity, Biblical admonitions regarding homosexuality, or religious principles. A large CFV packet of information dated January 9, 1992, does not mention a religious basis for CFV's work. Finally, there is no mention of religion in the CFV Mission Statement.
The History of "No Special Rights"
Another area of deception in the public face of the anti-homosexual campaign is its assertion that lesbians and gay men are seeking "special rights" or "special protections." This was the guiding premise behind Anita Bryant's campaign, was raised again by Enrique Rueda in The Homosexual Network and Gays, AIDS and You, and eventually emerged as the slogan of the national anti-homosexual campaign. In the case of Colorado's Amendment 2, the slogan was the dominant theme of CFV's advertising and promotion.
The use of "no special rights" is purposefully misleading. Gay rights initiatives do not provide "special rights," but a guarantee of equal rights for lesbians and gay men. Amendment 2 would deny equal protection against discrimination only to this group. CFV's decision to use "no special rights" only in its public materials and not in the legal language of the amendment itself was made on the advice of the National Legal Foundation.
A June 1991 letter from Brian McCormick of NLF advises CFV to stay away from the "no special rights" language in its legal formulations, but to use it as the centerpiece of its public campaign. Coloradans were bombarded with advertisements and flyers all drumming home the message that Amendment 2 did nothing but reverse the unfair granting of "special rights" through gay rights initiatives. Future anti-gay initiatives will undoubtedly continue the use of the "no special rights" slogan because the cohesiveness of the right's anti-homosexual campaign virtually guarantees that local initiatives will follow the lead of national organizations.
Conclusion
Calvinist attitudes toward sex, based in religious teaching that sex is only for procreation, and a patriarchal culture that is discomforted by any breaking down of rigid sex roles, combine to create a culture that can deal with homosexuality, if at all, only in the artistic and commercial spheres.
The lesbian and gay civil rights movement has pushed homosexuality out of the artistic and commercial world and into the political and social sphere. This is almost guaranteed to create a backlash while society absorbs and adjusts to new values.
While that backlash may be inevitable, it can be tamped down or fanned by political forces. This review of the right wing's organizing to promote a backlash against the gay rights movement is a study in reaction. Deprived of its old enemies and needing a new issue to promote, the right's anti-homosexual organizing is rank opportunism. The anti-gay backlash is generating funds, keeping right-wing organizations that were in danger of complete eclipse alive with an infusion of new support, and generating the all-important evidence of political power--media attention.
The threat this backlash represents is very real. Violence is its most blatant manifestation, but the litany of pain and waste caused by homophobia includes subtle attacks on gay men and lesbians as well. Furthermore, confronting the backlash distracts time, energy, and money from the work necessary to bring about equal rights for lesbians and gay men.
The skillful manipulation of homophobia by the right wing creates anti-gay sentiment and actions that bolster and promote intolerance.
In the United States, we must decide what role the church and religious tenets are going to play, especially when those tenets are in conflict with the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
It is not an attack on Christianity or religion to question the propriety of imposing Biblical law on a secular society. If ours is a society in which church and state are separate, then the prohibitions of church dogma cannot overrule the protections provided by the Constitution. And the Constitution, to paraphrase Mr. Justice McKenna in the 1910 case of Weems v. U.S., is progressive--it is not fastened to the obsolete, but may acquire new meaning as public opinion becomes enlightened by a humane justice.
Jean Hardisty, who holds a doctorate in political science, is Director of Political Research Associates. She is working on a book on the resurgent right. This article appeared in The Public Eye, March 1993. © 1995, Jean Hardisty.
SCRIPTURE'S REJECTION OF SAME-SEX SEX
Robert A. J. Gagnon concludes the following in his book, The Bible and Homosexual Practice (Pages 487, 488):
“Scripture does not reject same-sex intercourse because of some alleged ignorance of non-exploitive forms of homosexual behavior or genetic causation factors. It does not reject homosexual intercourse because of some misperception that only idolaters in the strict sense could engage in such behavior or because of some superstition about defilement and purity.
It does not reject homosexual practice, at least not primarily, out of some need to assert the rule of men over women.
Rather, Scripture rejects homosexual behavior because it is a violation of the gendered existence of male and female ordained by God at creation.
Homosexual intercourse … distorts the sexuality intended by God for the health and vitality of the human race. God intended the very act of sexual intercourse to be an act of pluralism (numerous distinct ethnic, religious, or cultural groups), embracing a sexual ‘other’ rather than a sexual ‘same.’
The biblical proscription of same-sex intercourse, like those against incest, adultery, and bestiality, is absolute (encompassing all cases), pervasive (by both Testaments and with each Testament), and severe (mandating exclusion from God’s kingdom.)”
“Scripture does not reject same-sex intercourse because of some alleged ignorance of non-exploitive forms of homosexual behavior or genetic causation factors. It does not reject homosexual intercourse because of some misperception that only idolaters in the strict sense could engage in such behavior or because of some superstition about defilement and purity.
It does not reject homosexual practice, at least not primarily, out of some need to assert the rule of men over women.
Rather, Scripture rejects homosexual behavior because it is a violation of the gendered existence of male and female ordained by God at creation.
Homosexual intercourse … distorts the sexuality intended by God for the health and vitality of the human race. God intended the very act of sexual intercourse to be an act of pluralism (numerous distinct ethnic, religious, or cultural groups), embracing a sexual ‘other’ rather than a sexual ‘same.’
The biblical proscription of same-sex intercourse, like those against incest, adultery, and bestiality, is absolute (encompassing all cases), pervasive (by both Testaments and with each Testament), and severe (mandating exclusion from God’s kingdom.)”
RECOGNIZING HOMOSEXUALS AS A LEGAL CLASS
The U.S. Supreme Court has reached far beyond the original thinking of the “Founding Fathers” in providing civil rights protection to homosexuals and in separating God from the government’s civil activities. This paper’s objective is to make citizens aware of these excesses so that necessary political corrections can be made in the Court’s actions.
This paper addresses two major issues:
1) The 1st Amendment as misapplied to the marriage issue and the separation of Church and State, and
2) Differentiating homosexuals erroneously as a class per the 14th Amendment’s “due process” clause.
The Marriage/Church and State issue
When considered in terms of the 1st Amendment of our Constitution, there is an important link between marriage and the matter of Church and State. God’s existence and religious practices are confused by the US Supreme Court.
A vast multitude of Americans believe God’s revelations are self evident, that God exists. Various religions serve as a way to worship and understand His revelations. In this context, there is an important legal distinction between the reality of God and those religions that serve Him. This is where the marriage issue joins the matter of Church and State.
The 1st Amendment provides “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” In no way does the 1st Amendment conclude there is no God! The 1st Amendment also confirms the “free exercise” of various religions to worship God and the institution of marriage as a heterosexual union between a man and a woman as confirmed by all religions.
A vast multitude of Americans also believe that same-sex marriage is wrong. That God's existence is not denied by the U.S. Constitution. That God’s existence and religion are legally confused by the Supreme Court. That secularist groups (such as the ACLU) purposefully misconstrue and oppose religion and the reality of God's existence.
Consider the special insight on marriage as provided by the eminent theologian, John Stott:
“What this was Genesis tells us and Jesus confirmed: 'At the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female', and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh.' So they are no longer two, but one.' Then Jesus added his personal endorsement and deduction; ‘Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate.' (Mt 19:14)
In other words, God created humankind male and female; God instituted marriage as a heterosexual union; and what God has thus united, we have no liberty to separate. This threefold action of God established that the only context which he intends for the 'one flesh' experience is heterosexual monogamy, and that a homosexual partnership (however loving and committed it may claim to be) … can never be regarded as a legitimate alternative to marriage."
Here lays the tension on the issues of the separation of Church and State and the meaning of marriage. That God ordained marriage to be between a man and a woman. That the 1st Amendment affirms God’s religions and their “free exercise,” a “freedom of religion” explicitly specified in terms of marriage to be only between a man and a woman. God’s existence and religion are legally confused by the Supreme Court.
Differentiating homosexuals as a class
The 14th Amendment was designed to ensure that all former slaves were granted automatic United States citizenship, and that they would have all the rights and privileges as any other citizen.
The 14th Amendment provides that, “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”
Homosexuals claim a 14th Amendment “liberty”, that they are deprived of the “due process” right and freedom to be married because they are a differentiated social and cultural "class" based on their fixed sexual orientation. This claim is expected to be a major issue with the Supreme Court because of the decision in Lawrence v. Texas that favored homosexuals.
The requirement of a "class" is fundamental to a claim of discrimination under the "due process" clause provided by the 14th Amendment. But, there is growing evidence homosexuals may make the choice to change their sexual orientation with the will to do so. This confirms their sexual orientation is not fixed, that their sexual conduct is classic sexual behavior.
If homosexuality is a behavior (that is: it is not innate or indigenous) then homosexuals should not be considered a "class" entitled to civil rights protection.
Dr. Robert Spitzer, the prominent psychiatrist and researcher at Columbia University has been the chief architect of the American Psychiatric Association's diagnostic manual and he was the chief decision-maker in the 1973 removal of homosexuality from the diagnostic manual. He considers himself a gay-affirmative psychiatrist, and a long time supporter of gay rights. He has long been convinced that homosexuality is neither a disorder nor changeable. Because of the increasingly heated debate over the latter point within the professional community, Spitzer decided to conduct his own study of the matter. He concluded:
"I'm convinced from the people I have interviewed, that for many of them, they have made substantial changes toward becoming heterosexual...I think that's news...I came to this study skeptical. I now claim that these changes can be sustained."
Obviously, if this is the case, and the evidence strongly suggests it is, then homosexual marriage in a secular civil context is wrong. Neither religious nor civil unions are justified for homosexuals as a "class" because homosexuals may change their sexual orientation.
Otherwise, womanizers and bisexuals may have civil provisions to marry. As improbable as it may be, one could even marry a horse.
And that is the “thread” that unravels the fraudulent spin on “fixed sexual orientation”: that homosexuals should not be a “legitimate group or class" recognized under the “due process” provision of the 14th Amendment.
These facts are clear. When considering the legal issues stated before, the Country's Fathers, and those who conceived the 14th Amendment, did not require the following to sustain and protect the integrity of the Constitution:
That God should be excluded from the thinking, consideration and prayer of citizens and their governors.
That religions worshiping God must be excluded from our governing institutions.
That the concept of Civil Rights must be legally extended to embrace differentiated sexual practices.
That marriage should include same-sex individuals.
Yet, the legal arguments, supporting -- Civil Rights based on sexual orientation -- the expected “due process” application on same-sex marriage -- the Supreme Court’s confusion on excluding God and religion from our public governments, reach to this conclusion.
In Lawrence v. Texas, the Supreme Court is twisted on differentiating homosexuals as a class as opposed to the notion of homosexual conduct.
This exemplifies the confusion where “homosexuals as a class” becomes a Civil Rights group, where the class is identified because of its sexual “proclivity” , or behavior or conduct. See the following from the record:
Cite as: 539 U. S. ____ (2003) 17 SCALIA, J., dissenting
Justice Scalia states in Lawrence v. Texas, “JUSTICE OCONNOR argues that the discrimination in this law which must be justified is not its discrimination with regard to the sex of the partner but its discrimination with regard to the sexual proclivity of the principal actor.
“While it is true that the law applies only to conduct, the conduct targeted by this law is conduct that is closely correlated with being homosexual. Under such circumstances, Texas sodomy law is targeted at more than conduct. It is instead directed toward gay persons as a class.”
Saclia goes on to say, “Of course the same could be said of any law. A law against public nudity targets the conduct that is closely correlated with being a nudist, and hence is targeted at more than conduct, it is directed toward nudists as a class. But be that as it may. Even if the Texas law does deny equal protection to homosexuals as a class, that denial still does not need to be justified by anything more than a rational basis, which our cases show is satisfied by the enforcement of traditional notions of sexual morality.”
My reason for citing this is the fact that no argument was made, based on my cursory reading of the whole record, refuting that Homosexuals are a class (except the reference by Scalia above), that they are males or females who are participating in a certain behavior or conduct.
The counter to this by homosexual activists, if the argument had been made, would be it isn’t conduct, it is the function of a sexual orientation, a fixed sexual orientation.
And that is the thread that unravels the spin on “sexual orientation” as being a fraud, the homosexuals are not a “legitimate group or class".
Amendment I
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
Amendment 14
The 14th was designed to ensure that all former slaves were granted automatic United States citizenship, and that they would have all the rights and privileges as any other citizen. The amendment passed Congress on June 13, 1866, and was ratified on July 9, 1868 (757 days).
This paper addresses two major issues:
1) The 1st Amendment as misapplied to the marriage issue and the separation of Church and State, and
2) Differentiating homosexuals erroneously as a class per the 14th Amendment’s “due process” clause.
The Marriage/Church and State issue
When considered in terms of the 1st Amendment of our Constitution, there is an important link between marriage and the matter of Church and State. God’s existence and religious practices are confused by the US Supreme Court.
A vast multitude of Americans believe God’s revelations are self evident, that God exists. Various religions serve as a way to worship and understand His revelations. In this context, there is an important legal distinction between the reality of God and those religions that serve Him. This is where the marriage issue joins the matter of Church and State.
The 1st Amendment provides “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” In no way does the 1st Amendment conclude there is no God! The 1st Amendment also confirms the “free exercise” of various religions to worship God and the institution of marriage as a heterosexual union between a man and a woman as confirmed by all religions.
A vast multitude of Americans also believe that same-sex marriage is wrong. That God's existence is not denied by the U.S. Constitution. That God’s existence and religion are legally confused by the Supreme Court. That secularist groups (such as the ACLU) purposefully misconstrue and oppose religion and the reality of God's existence.
Consider the special insight on marriage as provided by the eminent theologian, John Stott:
“What this was Genesis tells us and Jesus confirmed: 'At the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female', and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh.' So they are no longer two, but one.' Then Jesus added his personal endorsement and deduction; ‘Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate.' (Mt 19:14)
In other words, God created humankind male and female; God instituted marriage as a heterosexual union; and what God has thus united, we have no liberty to separate. This threefold action of God established that the only context which he intends for the 'one flesh' experience is heterosexual monogamy, and that a homosexual partnership (however loving and committed it may claim to be) … can never be regarded as a legitimate alternative to marriage."
Here lays the tension on the issues of the separation of Church and State and the meaning of marriage. That God ordained marriage to be between a man and a woman. That the 1st Amendment affirms God’s religions and their “free exercise,” a “freedom of religion” explicitly specified in terms of marriage to be only between a man and a woman. God’s existence and religion are legally confused by the Supreme Court.
Differentiating homosexuals as a class
The 14th Amendment was designed to ensure that all former slaves were granted automatic United States citizenship, and that they would have all the rights and privileges as any other citizen.
The 14th Amendment provides that, “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”
Homosexuals claim a 14th Amendment “liberty”, that they are deprived of the “due process” right and freedom to be married because they are a differentiated social and cultural "class" based on their fixed sexual orientation. This claim is expected to be a major issue with the Supreme Court because of the decision in Lawrence v. Texas that favored homosexuals.
The requirement of a "class" is fundamental to a claim of discrimination under the "due process" clause provided by the 14th Amendment. But, there is growing evidence homosexuals may make the choice to change their sexual orientation with the will to do so. This confirms their sexual orientation is not fixed, that their sexual conduct is classic sexual behavior.
If homosexuality is a behavior (that is: it is not innate or indigenous) then homosexuals should not be considered a "class" entitled to civil rights protection.
Dr. Robert Spitzer, the prominent psychiatrist and researcher at Columbia University has been the chief architect of the American Psychiatric Association's diagnostic manual and he was the chief decision-maker in the 1973 removal of homosexuality from the diagnostic manual. He considers himself a gay-affirmative psychiatrist, and a long time supporter of gay rights. He has long been convinced that homosexuality is neither a disorder nor changeable. Because of the increasingly heated debate over the latter point within the professional community, Spitzer decided to conduct his own study of the matter. He concluded:
"I'm convinced from the people I have interviewed, that for many of them, they have made substantial changes toward becoming heterosexual...I think that's news...I came to this study skeptical. I now claim that these changes can be sustained."
Obviously, if this is the case, and the evidence strongly suggests it is, then homosexual marriage in a secular civil context is wrong. Neither religious nor civil unions are justified for homosexuals as a "class" because homosexuals may change their sexual orientation.
Otherwise, womanizers and bisexuals may have civil provisions to marry. As improbable as it may be, one could even marry a horse.
And that is the “thread” that unravels the fraudulent spin on “fixed sexual orientation”: that homosexuals should not be a “legitimate group or class" recognized under the “due process” provision of the 14th Amendment.
These facts are clear. When considering the legal issues stated before, the Country's Fathers, and those who conceived the 14th Amendment, did not require the following to sustain and protect the integrity of the Constitution:
That God should be excluded from the thinking, consideration and prayer of citizens and their governors.
That religions worshiping God must be excluded from our governing institutions.
That the concept of Civil Rights must be legally extended to embrace differentiated sexual practices.
That marriage should include same-sex individuals.
Yet, the legal arguments, supporting -- Civil Rights based on sexual orientation -- the expected “due process” application on same-sex marriage -- the Supreme Court’s confusion on excluding God and religion from our public governments, reach to this conclusion.
In Lawrence v. Texas, the Supreme Court is twisted on differentiating homosexuals as a class as opposed to the notion of homosexual conduct.
This exemplifies the confusion where “homosexuals as a class” becomes a Civil Rights group, where the class is identified because of its sexual “proclivity” , or behavior or conduct. See the following from the record:
Cite as: 539 U. S. ____ (2003) 17 SCALIA, J., dissenting
Justice Scalia states in Lawrence v. Texas, “JUSTICE OCONNOR argues that the discrimination in this law which must be justified is not its discrimination with regard to the sex of the partner but its discrimination with regard to the sexual proclivity of the principal actor.
“While it is true that the law applies only to conduct, the conduct targeted by this law is conduct that is closely correlated with being homosexual. Under such circumstances, Texas sodomy law is targeted at more than conduct. It is instead directed toward gay persons as a class.”
Saclia goes on to say, “Of course the same could be said of any law. A law against public nudity targets the conduct that is closely correlated with being a nudist, and hence is targeted at more than conduct, it is directed toward nudists as a class. But be that as it may. Even if the Texas law does deny equal protection to homosexuals as a class, that denial still does not need to be justified by anything more than a rational basis, which our cases show is satisfied by the enforcement of traditional notions of sexual morality.”
My reason for citing this is the fact that no argument was made, based on my cursory reading of the whole record, refuting that Homosexuals are a class (except the reference by Scalia above), that they are males or females who are participating in a certain behavior or conduct.
The counter to this by homosexual activists, if the argument had been made, would be it isn’t conduct, it is the function of a sexual orientation, a fixed sexual orientation.
And that is the thread that unravels the spin on “sexual orientation” as being a fraud, the homosexuals are not a “legitimate group or class".
Amendment I
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
Amendment 14
The 14th was designed to ensure that all former slaves were granted automatic United States citizenship, and that they would have all the rights and privileges as any other citizen. The amendment passed Congress on June 13, 1866, and was ratified on July 9, 1868 (757 days).
A PROPOSED TEN POINT SEXUAL ETHIC
A set of principles of right sexual conduct:
1) Sexuality is the characterization of one’s sex (male and female) and sexual activity. One's sexuality is a very sensitive and private matter.
2) One’s professed “sexual orientation” is the direction of one’s sexual interest. It is not fixed and is a matter of choice and consequence.
3) In matters of adult sexuality one has the freedom to act and the will to do so but is responsible for the moral and physical consequences of the sexual act. (Adult: one who has attained maturity and/or a legal age)
4) One should be happy with their sexuality and are free to do what they wish when attaining adulthood, except as proscribed by law and guided by religious belief.
5) All teachings of human sexuality must be taught with a strong emphasis on morality, moral and physical consequences.
6) Normal sexual relations are performed by males and females with the objective of propagating children.
7) Sexual experimentation during youth has certain serious moral and physical consequences.
8) Sexual experimentation by or with children is extremely dangerous to the child’s mental and physical well being.
9) The appropriate human relationship within which intimate sexual activity should be conducted is between a man and woman joined in marriage.
10) Aberrant sexual practices include bestiality (sex with animals), pedophilia (sex between adults and children), homosexuality (sex between people of the same sex), bisexuality (where a person has sex with people of both sexes).
1) Sexuality is the characterization of one’s sex (male and female) and sexual activity. One's sexuality is a very sensitive and private matter.
2) One’s professed “sexual orientation” is the direction of one’s sexual interest. It is not fixed and is a matter of choice and consequence.
3) In matters of adult sexuality one has the freedom to act and the will to do so but is responsible for the moral and physical consequences of the sexual act. (Adult: one who has attained maturity and/or a legal age)
4) One should be happy with their sexuality and are free to do what they wish when attaining adulthood, except as proscribed by law and guided by religious belief.
5) All teachings of human sexuality must be taught with a strong emphasis on morality, moral and physical consequences.
6) Normal sexual relations are performed by males and females with the objective of propagating children.
7) Sexual experimentation during youth has certain serious moral and physical consequences.
8) Sexual experimentation by or with children is extremely dangerous to the child’s mental and physical well being.
9) The appropriate human relationship within which intimate sexual activity should be conducted is between a man and woman joined in marriage.
10) Aberrant sexual practices include bestiality (sex with animals), pedophilia (sex between adults and children), homosexuality (sex between people of the same sex), bisexuality (where a person has sex with people of both sexes).
THE HOMOSEXUAL AGENDA 1993
September 2, 1993
As a concerned grandfather and citizen, I sincerely believe a significant issue faces all Americans, especially parents of young children. That issue deals with the legal concept of "sexual orientation" as this concept relates to one's civil rights. This issue is a legal fraud on American Society. It raises devastatingly serious long term social and moral questions affecting the family and the education of children.
The sexual orientation theme is promoted by homosexuals as a part of a well financed campaign to establish civil rights legal precedents supporting nondiscrimination of gays and lesbians. This campaign to justify homosexuality has exploded on the national scene coincident with the AIDS epidemic.
But before this is accomplished, this issue must confront the moral opposition of the great majority of Americans whose social standards hold that same-sex sexual behavior is wrong.
Discerning individuals, with an astute moral sense, demand the right to discriminate, to rightfully discriminate against evil sexual practices, the right to reject the Homosexual Social Agenda that promotes the lie of the homosexual life-style. Discerning individuals demand this right for the same reason that society would reject an agenda supporting other wrongful "sexual orientations" as advocated by womanizers, sexual harassers, adulterers, pedophiles, and rapists.
Discerning individuals have the right to discriminate where the object of the discrimination is an evil matter that violates public values, the religious or civil laws, the consensus of social standards that support the moral upbringing of children and the moral conduct of adults in society.
Our Country's Fathers certainly did not contemplate that the concept of Civil Rights must be legally extended to embrace immoral sexual practices to protect the integrity of the Constitution and/or the Bill of Rights. Yet, the legal arguments supporting Civil Rights based on sexual orientation reach to this conclusion!!!
This is exactly what the homosexual movement proposes. And that is now the issue. Every American must take up the flag and defend the American Way against the social lie proposed by advocates of same-sex sexual behavior. That American Way does not have room for granting Civil Rights based on the fraudulent legal concept of sexual orientation. This is where the fight is.
For homosexuals are as wrong as sexual harassers, adulterers, womanizers, pedophiles, rapists, any one whose "sexual orientation" proposes to seek, possess and use persons who are not rightly the objects of sexual desire.
Americans have every right to be intolerant of and to discriminate against homosexuals, whether they be white or black, no matter the race or color whether they be Christian, Jew or Muslim, no matter their religion, whether they be male or female, no matter what their sex may be.
For the basic Civil Rights that protect individual freedom based on race, religion and sex must not be diluted to embrace an evil that disgraces the rights of individuals in society-at-large. And the Supreme Court and the Congress must protect us from social legislation and legal decisions that condones evil sexual practices, which erode and undermine the family and society with devastating certainty.
As a concerned grandfather and citizen, I sincerely believe a significant issue faces all Americans, especially parents of young children. That issue deals with the legal concept of "sexual orientation" as this concept relates to one's civil rights. This issue is a legal fraud on American Society. It raises devastatingly serious long term social and moral questions affecting the family and the education of children.
The sexual orientation theme is promoted by homosexuals as a part of a well financed campaign to establish civil rights legal precedents supporting nondiscrimination of gays and lesbians. This campaign to justify homosexuality has exploded on the national scene coincident with the AIDS epidemic.
But before this is accomplished, this issue must confront the moral opposition of the great majority of Americans whose social standards hold that same-sex sexual behavior is wrong.
Discerning individuals, with an astute moral sense, demand the right to discriminate, to rightfully discriminate against evil sexual practices, the right to reject the Homosexual Social Agenda that promotes the lie of the homosexual life-style. Discerning individuals demand this right for the same reason that society would reject an agenda supporting other wrongful "sexual orientations" as advocated by womanizers, sexual harassers, adulterers, pedophiles, and rapists.
Discerning individuals have the right to discriminate where the object of the discrimination is an evil matter that violates public values, the religious or civil laws, the consensus of social standards that support the moral upbringing of children and the moral conduct of adults in society.
Our Country's Fathers certainly did not contemplate that the concept of Civil Rights must be legally extended to embrace immoral sexual practices to protect the integrity of the Constitution and/or the Bill of Rights. Yet, the legal arguments supporting Civil Rights based on sexual orientation reach to this conclusion!!!
This is exactly what the homosexual movement proposes. And that is now the issue. Every American must take up the flag and defend the American Way against the social lie proposed by advocates of same-sex sexual behavior. That American Way does not have room for granting Civil Rights based on the fraudulent legal concept of sexual orientation. This is where the fight is.
For homosexuals are as wrong as sexual harassers, adulterers, womanizers, pedophiles, rapists, any one whose "sexual orientation" proposes to seek, possess and use persons who are not rightly the objects of sexual desire.
Americans have every right to be intolerant of and to discriminate against homosexuals, whether they be white or black, no matter the race or color whether they be Christian, Jew or Muslim, no matter their religion, whether they be male or female, no matter what their sex may be.
For the basic Civil Rights that protect individual freedom based on race, religion and sex must not be diluted to embrace an evil that disgraces the rights of individuals in society-at-large. And the Supreme Court and the Congress must protect us from social legislation and legal decisions that condones evil sexual practices, which erode and undermine the family and society with devastating certainty.
PRIMORDIAL BIAS AND PREJUDICE
April 9, 2008
During my college days in the Boston area in 1950 - 51 I bought a book titled "Prejudice". As a young State of Mainer I was impressed with the ethnic and cultural melting pot of Boston. The book was filled with boring statistics but had a great introduction that included a story.
The story told of the Catholic Archbishop riding in his limousine down Massachusetts Ave. A little black boy was hitchhiking and the Archbishop directed the driver to stop and pick him up. The boy and the Archbishop began to talk and the Archbishop asked, "Son, tell me, are you Catholic?" The boy replied, "No sir Boss, its bad enough being black without being one of them!"
I joined IBM in Boston in 1953. As a part of my training on IBM machines I did systems work at Combined Jewish Appeal. It was a large installation. I noticed every one there were Irish. I asked the manager why? He replied, "Son, you don't understand Boston. The Irish don't care who owns it as long as they run it. And the Jews don't care who runs it as long as they own it." Such was the eco/ethnic delineation that contributed to prejudice in Boston.
Later, when we arrived in Washington in 1957, where I managed IBM's business with the Navy, we moved into a nice home in Silver Spring Maryland. A Black, a doctor who taught at Howard University moved into the neighborhood – the first black to move into Montgomery County! Everyone went nuts! The neighbors wanted to stop it fearing the prices of their home would go down. In a meeting I suggested this would not happen unless they all decided to sell – a function of supply and demand. The lawyers, who were Jewish (!) firmly stated there was nothing the neighbors could do to force the doctor to leave.
The Doctor turned out to be a great neighbor. It was after that time that I learned that in Washington DC blacks were very sensitive to black classes. That they were sensitive to low class backs moving into a neighbor hood of higher class blacks!
Still later when we arrived in the NY area I was impressed by the strong bias among high class Jews and Christians – to the point where there were and still are Jewish Country Clubs and "others".
All of this caused me to reflect on my growing up in Maine, where geographic distances of ten miles separated people and instilled feelings of differences that fostered prejudice -- and these people were typically 5th and 6th generation State of Mainers of German, English and Scotch Irish backgrounds!
I suggest the greatest of all differences in the tree of ethnic, racial, and now sexual divide was and is the economic delineation. I do not pretend here to fully explain the problem or to suggest its solution.
But I have this belief as it pertains to Obama. Our President was elected on the basis to resolve the issues facing this nation: the paramount ones pertain to the nation's security and economic health. Resolving the racial divide with blacks is not a paramount issue, but the culling of this as a problem with Obama's background may significantly dilute his other qualities. It will further confuse the political issue of his liberalism and lack of experience as a leader.
The assessment of Obama will not be based on his black background as much as his other credentials to lead. To say that those credentials suggest he can unite the nation in a new politic is contradicted by what and who he is – because by his very cultural and ethnic makeup he will play the "race card", and that does fact detracts from his Presidential image.
Is this view all a function of prejudice? No, I suggest that it's a matter of discernment – a balanced discernment that leads to a judgment of the issue of discrimination based on prejudice and bias. That suggests a specification of the attributes required in being president – of which, the racial question should be and must be a subsidiary and minor issue.
Considered in another way, there is a fundamental characteristic and attribute of the human nature to be biased and prejudiced. This inclination in the human condition has existed since the beginning of time.
The inclination impairs one's judgment resulting in perpetual denial about judging others of differing backgrounds. For example, I will not admit that I can be subjectively judgmental and prone to comparing other lesser people to my magnificent being and status in life. No hypocrisy here!
In terms of how others behave, feelings of difference appear to be a primary discriminating instinct! That instinct manifests an innate aptitude and pattern of behavior that responds to the distinct ethnic, racial, cultural, intellectual differences in various classes of human beings.
There is the old sayings, "Everyone is queer except ye and me … and sometimes I wonder about ye". So one may be socially, beiologically, physically, religiously and culturally differentiating as a function of a possible primary instinct. Most deny the principle considering their relative perfection, that "the fault we see in others oft times exist in ourselves". The attitude is expressed as, "No doubt about it. Others are biased and prejudiced and I am not. That is the reason why I am so reasonable."
During my college days in the Boston area in 1950 - 51 I bought a book titled "Prejudice". As a young State of Mainer I was impressed with the ethnic and cultural melting pot of Boston. The book was filled with boring statistics but had a great introduction that included a story.
The story told of the Catholic Archbishop riding in his limousine down Massachusetts Ave. A little black boy was hitchhiking and the Archbishop directed the driver to stop and pick him up. The boy and the Archbishop began to talk and the Archbishop asked, "Son, tell me, are you Catholic?" The boy replied, "No sir Boss, its bad enough being black without being one of them!"
I joined IBM in Boston in 1953. As a part of my training on IBM machines I did systems work at Combined Jewish Appeal. It was a large installation. I noticed every one there were Irish. I asked the manager why? He replied, "Son, you don't understand Boston. The Irish don't care who owns it as long as they run it. And the Jews don't care who runs it as long as they own it." Such was the eco/ethnic delineation that contributed to prejudice in Boston.
Later, when we arrived in Washington in 1957, where I managed IBM's business with the Navy, we moved into a nice home in Silver Spring Maryland. A Black, a doctor who taught at Howard University moved into the neighborhood – the first black to move into Montgomery County! Everyone went nuts! The neighbors wanted to stop it fearing the prices of their home would go down. In a meeting I suggested this would not happen unless they all decided to sell – a function of supply and demand. The lawyers, who were Jewish (!) firmly stated there was nothing the neighbors could do to force the doctor to leave.
The Doctor turned out to be a great neighbor. It was after that time that I learned that in Washington DC blacks were very sensitive to black classes. That they were sensitive to low class backs moving into a neighbor hood of higher class blacks!
Still later when we arrived in the NY area I was impressed by the strong bias among high class Jews and Christians – to the point where there were and still are Jewish Country Clubs and "others".
All of this caused me to reflect on my growing up in Maine, where geographic distances of ten miles separated people and instilled feelings of differences that fostered prejudice -- and these people were typically 5th and 6th generation State of Mainers of German, English and Scotch Irish backgrounds!
I suggest the greatest of all differences in the tree of ethnic, racial, and now sexual divide was and is the economic delineation. I do not pretend here to fully explain the problem or to suggest its solution.
But I have this belief as it pertains to Obama. Our President was elected on the basis to resolve the issues facing this nation: the paramount ones pertain to the nation's security and economic health. Resolving the racial divide with blacks is not a paramount issue, but the culling of this as a problem with Obama's background may significantly dilute his other qualities. It will further confuse the political issue of his liberalism and lack of experience as a leader.
The assessment of Obama will not be based on his black background as much as his other credentials to lead. To say that those credentials suggest he can unite the nation in a new politic is contradicted by what and who he is – because by his very cultural and ethnic makeup he will play the "race card", and that does fact detracts from his Presidential image.
Is this view all a function of prejudice? No, I suggest that it's a matter of discernment – a balanced discernment that leads to a judgment of the issue of discrimination based on prejudice and bias. That suggests a specification of the attributes required in being president – of which, the racial question should be and must be a subsidiary and minor issue.
Considered in another way, there is a fundamental characteristic and attribute of the human nature to be biased and prejudiced. This inclination in the human condition has existed since the beginning of time.
The inclination impairs one's judgment resulting in perpetual denial about judging others of differing backgrounds. For example, I will not admit that I can be subjectively judgmental and prone to comparing other lesser people to my magnificent being and status in life. No hypocrisy here!
In terms of how others behave, feelings of difference appear to be a primary discriminating instinct! That instinct manifests an innate aptitude and pattern of behavior that responds to the distinct ethnic, racial, cultural, intellectual differences in various classes of human beings.
There is the old sayings, "Everyone is queer except ye and me … and sometimes I wonder about ye". So one may be socially, beiologically, physically, religiously and culturally differentiating as a function of a possible primary instinct. Most deny the principle considering their relative perfection, that "the fault we see in others oft times exist in ourselves". The attitude is expressed as, "No doubt about it. Others are biased and prejudiced and I am not. That is the reason why I am so reasonable."
THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT FOR THOSE WHO BELIEVE
KNOWING THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT
By Otis Page[1]
Each Christian has their own precious relationship with and understanding of God and may be sensitive to and sometimes offended by other’s views and interpretations of Scripture. The writer hopes the following is not offensive to the reader, that the reader may consider and enjoy this view on “Knowing the Reality of the Holy Spirit”.
INTRODUCTION
Ontology is the philosophic consideration of reality: "What is the nature of the knowable things?" that typically can not be proven scientifically. Epistemology asks "What do you know?" and "How do you know it?”. The meanings of words such as opinion, faith and belief, and knowledge convey the lesson on what is means to “know”, to have knowledge.
Some scholars hold that opinion is the weakest conviction, followed by faith/belief, followed by knowing. For example, you might have an opinion that it is going to rain tomorrow. That opinion would be a belief if you relied on an authority, such as the report of a weatherman. And the opinion/belief would become knowing when tomorrow comes and it is actually raining.
A more relevant example pertains to this paper: One might have an opinion that God exists. That opinion changes to being faith that He exists when trusting a religious authority. It could be a conviction of belief where there is evidence of God in a person’s life. And the conviction may become “knowing” when the believer experiences the indwelling of God’s Holy Spirit.
Therefore, this paper addresses the ontological concept of “knowing” the reality of the past existence and present manifestation of God. It further attempts to answer the epistemological question how does one “know” God besides just believing that God exists? What is the reality of God and how do we know that reality in the Christian experience? This paper’s thesis attempts to provide the objective evidence of the reality of knowing God as framed in Romans 6-8!
THE HISTORICITY OF THE EVIDENT CHRIST
Christ’s witness compared to the prior witness of the Jews provides a startling contradiction between the two dispensations – that of Law and that of Grace. The following exemplifies the contrast with the Torah (the Law) compared to the compelling ministry of Christ and the Holy Spirit as depicted in Romans 6, 7 & 8. Paul frames the juxtaposition contrasting the “Law” and the “law of sin and death:
The following “transitional” analysis in Romans 7 with 6 and 8 is stated in Gordon Fee’s summary (God’s Empowering Presence):
A 7,12,23 The Law, Torah, is good just and holy.
B 7:14-24, 25b But the first Law was used by another “law,”
Sin, which in turn leads to death.
C 8,2A Enter the third “law”, the Spirit of life.
B’ 8:2B The third “law” sets one free from the second “law”,
both sin and death.
A’ 8: 3, 4 The third “law” fulfills the intent of the first Law, which was incapable of dealing with sin and thus producing righteousness.
Rom 7: 14-25 is a “transitional statement” bridging Romans 6 (no longer a slave to sin) to 8:1, 2 (the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death) by contrasting the Law (TORAH), the law of sin and death, and the law of the Spirit of life in Jesus Christ.
Consider the totality of Romans 7:14-25 as follows:
" So then, the Law (TORAH) is holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good. (12) Therefore did that which is good become a cause of death for me? May it never be! Rather it was sin, in order that it night be shown to be sin be effecting my death through that which is good, that through the commandment sin might become utterly sinful.” (13) For we know that the Law is spiritual; but I am of flesh, sold into bondage to sin. (14) For that which I am doing, I do not understand; for I am not practicing what I would like to do, but I am doing the very thing I hate. (15) But if I do the very thing I do not wish to, I agree with the Law, confessing that it is good. (16) So now, no longer am I the one doing it, but the sin which indwells me. (17) For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh; for the wishing is present in me, but the doing of the good is not. (18) For the good that I wish, I do not do; but practice the very evil that I do not wish. (19) But if I am doing the very thing I do not wish, I am no longer the one doing it, but sin which dwells in me.(20) I find then the principle that evil is present in me, the one who wishes to do good. (21) For I joyfully concur with the law of God in the inner man, (22) but I see a different law in the members of my body, waging war against the law of my mind, and making me a prisoner of the law of sin which is in my members. (23)
The following quote is presented here as a vital commentary on Romans 7:7-25 and as an introduction to the inspired answer given to us in Chapter 8 of Romans.
“This remarkable section (Romans 7:7-25) describes the psychological progress of the human heart to Christ: from the heathen state of carnal security, when sin is dead because it is unknown, through the Jewish state of legal conflict, when sin, roused by the stimulus of the divine command, springs into life,and the higher and nobler nature of man strives in vain to overcome this fearful monster, until at last the free grace of God in Christ gains victory. Some of the profoundest divines - Augustine, Luther, Calvin - transfer this conflict into the regenerate state; but this is described in the eighth chapter (of Romans) which ends in an exulting song of triumph.”
(Footnote 5, Page 299, The Conversion of Paul, Volume 1, The History of the Christian Church, by Philip Schaff.)
Consider this review of Paul’s declaration:
“What shall we say then? Is the Law (TORAH) sin? May it never be! On the contrary, I would not come to know sin except through the Law;” Romans 7:7
Paul cries out, “Wretched man that I am! Who will set me free from the body of this death?" Romans 7:24. "Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ! So then, on the one hand I myself with my mind am serving the Law of God, but on the other, with my flesh the law of sin. 7:25 “There is, therefore now no condemnation for those in Jesus Christ. For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death." 8:1, 2
Christ’s fulfillment of the Law (Torah)
“Do not think that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish, but to fulfill.” Matthew 5:17
“Do we then nullify the Law through faith? May it never be! On the contrary we establish the Law” Romans 3:31
“For what the Law could not do, weak as it was through the flesh, God did: sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and as an offering for sin. He condemned sin in the flesh, in order that the requirement of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who do not walk according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit.” 8: 3,4
Christ’s Holy Spirit fulfills the requirement of the Law for those indwelled. Romans 8:9
Therefore: “But now we have been released from the Law, having died to that which we were bound (6:10-18) , so that we serve in newness of the Spirit and not the oldness of the letter.” 7:6
And then 8:5-17 – where the Spirit is way of the Christian life as contrasted with the Law in the Jewish religious domain.
“For through the Law I died to the Law, that I might live to God. I have been crucified with Christ; and Christ lives in me; and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and delivered Himself up for me. I do not nullify the grace of God; for if righteousness comes through the Law, then Christ died needlessly." Galatians 2:19-21
This state of Paul's unrighteous unbelief stated in 1st Timothy 1:12-15, "And yet I was shown mercy, because I acted ignorantly in unbelief;" gives full credence to the fact that all Paul could do in following the Law was to excite what the Law defines as unrighteousness. That while "serving the Law of God", he only served the "law of sin" in his flesh sustained by his human nature. The only result for him was that the Law taught him that he was unrighteous, that he was a sinner (7:7). But the Law did not by itself make him right with God or make him personally righteous. For as Paul exclaims, "for sin, taking every opportunity through the commandment, deceived me, and through it killed me" (7:11).
The righteousness that Paul aspired to - being right with God, and being personally made righteous - was provided by Jesus Christ:
"But we know that the Law is good, if one uses it lawfully, realizing the fact that law is not made for a righteous man, but for those who are lawless and rebellious, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who kill their fathers or mothers, for murderers and immoral men and homosexuals and kidnappers and liars and perjurers and whatever else is contrary to sound teaching," 1 Timothy 1:8,9
"You who boast in the Law, through your breaking the Law, do you dishonor God?" Romans 2:23
"for until the Law sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law." Romans 5:13
"Why the Law then? It was added because of transgressions, having been ordained through angels by the agency of a mediator until the seed should come to whom the promise had been made." Galatians 3:19
"Is the Law then contrary to the promises of God? May it never be! For if the law had been given which was able to impart life, then righteousness would have been indeed based on law." Galatians 3:21
The New Testament’s determination of the Trinity[2] establishes the relationship of Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The New represents a departure from God’s prior exclusive revelation to the Jews in the Old (Torah). This fact is exemplified in Romans 1-8. It authenticates and exemplifies the profound new covenant of Christ’s blood “for the forgiveness of sins” and justification “as a gift by His grace”[3] to those who believe.
The inclusive covenant of the New Testament does not terminate the exclusive covenant of the Old, however. It is a new dispensation[4] of God’s plan to extend His revelation in the Scriptures[5] to the world through Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit. The New Testament is a revelation to those chosen, “just as he chose us before the foundation of the world”, “predestined - according to His will”.[6]
Questions in the early developing theology of Christianity dealt with two mighty theological determinations regarding the nature of Christ’s humanity, deity and His relationship or subordination/succession with the Father and the role of the Holy Spirit. These were characterized as the Trinitarian and Christological[7] controversies. They evolved during the first centuries (400 years!), including the Catholic and Greek Orthodox Churches as known at the present time.
Christ’s ministry reintroduced and reaffirmed the compelling and existing ministry[8] of the omnipresent Holy Spirit[9], as invoked in John[10] and as described by implementation of the indwelling[11] and filling[12] of the Christian believer. The Holy Spirit conceived Christ[13] convicts mankind[14], regenerates [15], sanctifies[16], gives discernment[17], is grieved and illuminates and inspires the believer[18]. It may now be apparent that the Holy Spirit, as the executive of Christ’s Church on earth, plays the major role in furthering Here is the major point as it relates to today, in this very instance when reading and considering this paper: It is important to acknowledge that Christ’s ministry exists today[19] through the Holy Spirit’s indwelling of the believer[20] and the calling by prevenient grace of those of the elect coming to belief.[21]
KNOWING THE HOLY SPIRIT
It is a fact that God in the form of the Holy Spirit exists today and forever. This is Christ’s Holy Spirit! And here is the extraordinary evidentiary conclusion: He is with us now, today, indwelled in those who believe and walk with Him, and that is the truth expressed in Romans 8:6-9 and as confirmed in References 3 and 9 of this paper. The Holy Spirit as person is the personal empowering presence of God. As sure as the certainty that God’s glory is imaged through Christ in His humanity, the same is true of the Holy Spirit now indwelled personally in the Christian, the temple of the Holy Spirit.[22] The Holy Spirit, thereby, today, establishes the promises made in the Old Testament[23] that are now fulfilled in the New. What is the proof of all this, the truly objective proof?
The epistemological question on what and how the indwelled Christian knows God’s reality is confirmed empirically by the momentum of tradition in Christ’s diverse church, the witness of His Word in the New Testament, and the inspired one-on-one personal revelation of the Holy Spirit to the believer. The ontological question was first framed in the vibrant intellectual period of the 18th Century Enlightenment dealing with skeptical questions regarding the reality of God. That reality, today, is the “good news”[24] of the present ministry of the Holy Spirit – God with us, for as Christ states in John 16:14 “He will glorify Me; for He shall take of Mine, and disclose it to you.”
The Holy Spirit’s “empowerment” of the indwelled Christian[25] provides a “knowing” witness that God does exist and that Jesus Christ is the confirmed expression (the Logos) of that reality. God’s presence, the Holy Spirit, exists in the daily experience of the true Christian believer, even though this fact may boggle the minds of nonbelievers.[26] If a Christian does not know this truth – then that person probably is not a Christian![27]
The real “good news” is the “bad news” (Rom 6:14-18; 8:1-13) is ended for those who believe. This truth applies to all Christians without respect to any religious affiliation! The Age of Grace presents the implementation of Christ's witness to the individual believer through the Holy Spirit (Rom 8)!
There is hope for the true Chistian Saint that seeks the true understanding of the “good news”, especially that explained in Romans 6 thru 8!The Holy Spirit as person is the personal empowering presence of God. As sure as the certainty that God’s glory is imaged through Christ in His humanity, the same is true of the Holy Spirit now indwelled personally in the Christian, the temple of the Holy Spirit. (1Cor 3:16, 17) The Holy Spirit, thereby, today, establishes the promises made in the Old Testament (Jer 31:31; Eze 37:14; Joel 2:28,29; Zech 12:10 ) that are now fulfilled in the New. So the “good news” is the “bad news” is ended except where the “sad news” applies either by ignorance or the lack of confession of sin (1John 1:5-10) by those who say they are Christians but really are not since they are not indwelt with His Holy Spirit. (Rom 8:1,2)
REFERENCES
References: 1.The Historicity of Christ 2: The Trinity 3: Dispensational Theology 4: The Scriptures 5: Christology 6: Comparing the Law with that of Grace 7: The reality of the Holy Spirit 8: Background
1: CHRIST’S HISTORICITY
Given the context of the question on Christ’s preexistence, there is the more fundamental question addressing whether Christ really existed in the first place.
Is the story of Christ just a mythical concoction? Did he really exist? Is the New Testament an authentic record since the original manuscripts making up the New Testament are no where to be found.
There have been and there still exists attempts to analyze and determine the authenticity of the Scriptures, especially those of the New Testament. So there are questions that preempt the issue of preexistence where critiques allege that mysticism and mythology strangle the truth of the historical record as to Christ’s true existence, ministry and the amazing story of His trial, death, resurrection and ascension!
Will Durant is the author of the "The Story of Civilization" and the "The Lessons of History" culminating a lifetime journey in the study of history and philosophy. A "reluctant" atheist, Durant's conclusions on Christianity provide a formidable view by which one may learn, and possibly understand, the atheistic "persuasion" regarding disbelief in God and the revelation of Jesus Christ in the Bible.
Yet in “The History of Civilization”; Volume III; Caesar and Christ, Durant provides a convicting witness authenticating Christ’s historicity. Here is Durant’s objective assessment:
"In summary, it is clear that there are many contradictions between one gospel and another, many dubious statements of history, many suspicious resemblances to the legends told of pagan gods, many incidents apparently designed to prove the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies, many passages possibly aiming to establish a historical basis for some later doctrine or ritual of the Church. The evangelist shared with Cicero, Sallust, and Tacitus the conception of history as a vehicle for moral ideas. And presumably the conversations and speeches reported in the Gospels were subject to the frailties of illiterate memories, and the errors or emendations of copyists.
All this granted, much remains. The contradictions are of minutiae, not substance; in essentials the synoptic gospels agree remarkably well, and form a consistent portrait of Christ. In the enthusiasm of its discoveries the Higher Criticism has applied to the new testament tests of authenticity so severe that by them a hundred ancient worthies - e.g., Hammurabi, David, Socrates - would fade into legend (Says a great Jewish scholar, perhaps too strongly: 'If we had ancient sources like those in the Gospels for the history of Alexander or Caesar, we should not cast any doubt upon them whatsoever.' – Klausner., From Jesus to Paul, 260.).
Despite the prejudices and theological preconceptions of the evangelists, they record many incidents that mere inventors would have concealed - the competition of the apostles for high places in the Kingdom, their flight after Jesus' arrest, Peter's denial, the failure of Christ to work miracles in Galilee, the references of some auditors to his possible insanity, his early uncertainty as to his mission, his confessions of ignorance as to the future, his moments of bitterness, his despairing cry on the cross; no one reading these scenes can doubt the reality of the figure behind them. That a few simple men should in one generation have invented so powerful and appealing a personality, so lofty an ethic and so inspiring a vision of human brotherhood, would be a miracle far more incredible than any recorded in the Gospels. After two centuries of Higher Criticism the outlines of the life, character, and teaching of Christ, remain reasonably clear, and constitute the most fascinating feature in the history of Western man."
In his attempt to define the historicity of Jesus Christ, Durant concludes that the writings of the New Testament are valid and have been subjected to tests of scrutiny so severe that many other conclusions of history, if so tested, would not survive. He makes the authenticating judgment that, "Despite the prejudices and theological preconceptions of the evangelists, they record many incidents that mere inventors would have concealed."
Regardless of his atheism, Durant concludes, "That a few simple men should in one generation have invented so powerful and appealing a personality, so lofty an ethic and so inspiring a vision of human brotherhood, would be a miracle for more incredible than any recorded in the Gospels."
3: THE TRINITY
Before any considerations of Christ’s preexistence there came the important findings on the Trinity. The Trinitarian definition dealt with the relationship of Jesus Christ, the Son, the Father and the Holy Spirit as persons of the Godhead (One God). It determined that Christ was of the same essence as the Father and not subordinate to Him, even though Christ confessed that the Father is greater than He! (John 14:28). The Trinity, as a Biblical doctrine, came into effect recognizing this Truth while, at the same time, determining the Holy Spirit as the third person of one God in essence.
It should be logically inferred from this if Christ is of the same essence as God, He must have preexisted as God, a fact that one disputes. But the important issue is that Christ did not preexist as a human being – but possibly as one with the Spirit and Father.
The resolution of the Trinitarian conflict, at the Council of Nicea in 325 A.D., marked a major event in the Church’s and Western civilization’s histories. It initiated the reconciliation of the informal structure of the Christian Church and the formalized secular institution of the Roman Empire through the remarkable leadership of the Emperor Constantine, who was not overly religious, whose political power became a significant instrument of the Holy Spirit in exercising this stage of God’s plan for mankind and His Church.
The result of this was the eventual structuring of the Roman Catholic Church, where the Church and the Roman Empire joined as partners in the conquering, subjugation and conversion of the European nations and peoples. The resolution of the conflict was finalized at the council of Constantinople in the year 381, and resulted in the following doctrine within the Niceno - Constantinopolitian Creed:
“We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and of all things visible and invisible. And in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father;”
5: DISPENSATIONAL THEOLOGY
Dispensationalism: The distinctiveness of God’s plan as beheld in terms of time periods or phases with specific reference to His revelations. The dispensations according to Chafer’s Systematic Theology, Vol 1, Pages 40, 41:
Of innocence: from creation to Adam’s fall;
Of Conscience: from Adam to the flood;
Of Human Government: from the flood to Abraham;
Of Promise: from Abraham to the giving of the Law;
Of the Law: from the giving of the Law to Christ’s coming:
Of Grace: Of Christ till the creation of a new heaven and earth.
The writer believes the dispensation of Grace is split in two parts. The first is the witness of Christ and the second is the administration of the Holy Spirit “till the creation of a new heaven and earth.”
6: THE NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES
The evolution of the Christian Bible begins with the Hebrew Scriptures, which are characterized in Romans as being the “Law and the Prophets” (Torah), including the other honored books in the Old Testament (Rom 3:21). The reason for this is the simple fact that Christians were first of all Jews (Acts 2:5), not that any Jew except the Pharisees (including Paul) could read or interpret them.
But the new Church was not founded on the Hebrew Scriptures; it was established on the distinctive being of a person - to Jesus of Nazareth, crucified, dead and buried, but “designated Son of God in power ... by His resurrection from the dead.” (Rom 1:4)
Jesus wrote no book. His teachings as an inspired human being were conveyed in by word of mouth, personal example and by incidents of miracles that were later accomplished by His human disciples. What Jesus said, the word-of-mouth conveyance of His teachings, the historical events pertaining to what He said and accomplished, were lovingly recollected and documented by His hearers, His Apostles and Disciples.
These early writings became with various letters the eventual “confession of Faith,” the inspired written Word which now comprises the New Testament. They were inspired by an exalted process guided by His Holy Spirit (Eph 6:17) leading to the formalization of the Canon of Scripture evolved over the first four hundred years of Christian history.
The Bible was held as an exclusive intellectual property of the Church, until the coincident development of the printing press and the explosive generation of the Protestant movement in the early 16th century, a period of twelve hundred years. Nevertheless, the Scriptures served as the foundation for the developing theology of the Church during this extensive time, by a small number of thoughtful, literate theologians who studied the Word and used it as a foundation for their speculations on the meaning and application of what it taught as a part of the theological evolution of the Church.
Theologian John Walvoord instructs the believer on the lessons of righteousness contained in the Bible, in his Abridged Edition of Lewis Perry Shafer’s Systematic Theology:
“The ethics of the Bible are the only sure word regarding what is right and wrong in the world. While false religions often elevate immorality to a place of acceptance and morality, only the Bible presents sin as it really is and characterizes humanity as totally and hopelessly depraved apart from the grace of God. Human history in the Bible describes what fallen humans can do in living a life totally contrary to the will of God which can take individuals in all their depravity, sanctify them, and ultimately present them perfect in eternity to come.”
7: CHRISTOLOGY
The formulation of the Trinitarian doctrine framed the definition of the complex person of Jesus Christ. The famed reformed theologian, Louis Berkoff, instructs us in his History of Christian Doctrines, “The decision to which the trinitarian controversy led, namely, that Christ as the Son of God is consubstantial with the Father and therefore very God, immediately gave birth to the question of the relation between the divine and the human nature in Christ.”
This controversy occurred over three hundred years after Christ’s ascension! This event should be considered today in terms of Christ’s preexistence, since that if it took three hundred years to decide on Christ’s nature, it is again appropriate two thousand years later to confirm the nature of His preexistanence. Such questions delight theologians of those who love those who wish to learn the true meaning of Christ’s witness and ministry.
The Christological events dealt with the person of Jesus Christ and the logical contradiction suggested by one having both a divine and human nature, a problem that still bothers some religions today, religions that either deny Christ being the Son of God or deny His divine and human nature such as Jehovah’s Witnesses, Mormons, and the various Islamic religions. Arianism fed the flames of the controversy regarding the preexistence of Christ in that it held that Christ was not of the same “essence” as the Father.
In the 5th Century Nestorius, the bishop of Constantinople, believed Christ had two natures and two persons: one human and the other divine. He was opposed to calling Mary the “Mother of God” (theotokos; Greek for “God bearer”). As with the Council of Nicea in 325 AD in determing the Trinity, the Council of Chalcedon in the year 451AD provided the beginning for the final resolution of the Christological definition by the issuance of the following:
“We then, following the holy Fathers, all with one consent, teach men to confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, the same perfect in Godhead and also perfect in manhood; truly God and also truly man, of reasonable soul and body; consubstantial with us according to manhood; in all things like unto us, without sin; begotten before all ages of the Father according to the Godhead, and in these latter days, for us and for our salvation, born of the virgin Mary, the Mother of God, according to the manhood; one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only-begotten, to be acknowledged in two natures, inconfusedly, unchangeably, indivisibly, inseparably, the distinction of natures being by no means taken away by union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring in one Person and one subsistence, not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same Son, the Only-begotten, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ; as the prophets from the beginning have declared concerning Him, and the Lord Jesus Christ Himself has taught us, and the Creed of the Holy Fathers has handed down to us.”
The Christological and Trinitarian disputes were fundamental events that brought the Church to a point of understanding itself, in a very important sense. The developing doctrines pertaining to God (Theology Proper), Jesus Christ (Christology), the Holy Spirit (Pneumatology) and the Church (Ecclesiology) found their beginnings in the Spirit inspired consensus facilitated by these centuries of Holy Spirit led dialectics. The question of Christ’s preexistence was never considered in these controversies except as implied by His deity as being of the same essence as the Father.
8. THE AGE OF THE LAW COMPARED TO GRACE
A comparison of the age of the Law with that of Grace establishes a dramatically different requirement of human conduct defining the relationship of mankind to God. The conduct-regulating requirements of the Age of Grace are differentiated from that of the Law by the role of the Holy Spirit.
The Mosaic system of Law is void of the Holy Sprit’s enablement that exists in the Age of Grace. Being indwelt and walking in the Spirit fulfill the requirements of the Law and frees the believer form “law of sin and death”.
The Age of Grace presents superhuman ideals supported by the indwelling and filling of the believer by the Holy Spirit. These ideals are “divine beseechings”. They are not commands. They are the polite, considerate expression of persuasion extended to those for which it is rightfully expected since they are realized on the sanctifying walk with the Holy Spirit.
Romans 12:1 “I urge you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living and holy sacrifice, acceptable to God, which is your spiritual service of worship.”
Ephesians 4:1,2 “I, therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, entreat you to walk in a manner worthy of the calling with which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, showing forbearance to one another in love.”
There is a fundamental difference between these directions and “beseechings” and the teachings of the Mosaic Law which imposed a curse on those who failed!
Deuteronomy 28:15 “But it shall come about, if you will not obey the Lord your God, to observe to do all His commandments and His statutes which I charge you today, that all these curses shall come upon you and overtake you.” (The curses are specified in verses 16 through 68)
God’s Grace provides an incredibly different life under Grace compared to life under the Law:
Romans 8:1, 2 “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Jesus Christ. For the Law of the Spirit of life in Jesus Christ has set you free from the Law of sin and death.”
God’s Grace through the gift of Faith in Jesus Christ (Eph 2:8) provides that there can be no separation of the believer from the love of God.
Romans 8: 38,39 “For I am convinced that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, not things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor any other created thing, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.”
7. THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT
The Christian comes to know and understand a personal one-on-one relationship with the Triune God, through the ministry of the third person of the Trinity, the executive of the Godhead and Christ’s Church on earth. He is referred to and honored by the following names in the Bible:
· The Advocate (1John 2:1),
· The Helper (John 14:16): the “Paraclete” (Greek for
“Helper” and “Advocate”), the Spirit of truth (John 14:17), the Spirit of the Father (Mat 10:20), The Spirit of God (Rom 8:9),
· The Holy Ghost (King James version),
· The Holy Spirit (Mat 28:19).
· The Comforter (Acts 9:31),
The believer is set free from the law of sin and death through the righteousness provided as a gift by Jesus Christ:
Rom 8:1-17 “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Jesus Christ. For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death. For what the Law could not do, weak as it was through the flesh, God did by sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and as an offering for sin.”
The requirement of the Law can not be fulfilled by serving the Law. It can only be fulfilled by walking with the Holy Spirit, Jesus Christ’s greatest gift to the believer.
“He condemned sin in the flesh in order that the requirement of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who do not walk according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit. For those who are according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who are according to the Spirit, the things of the Spirit. For the mind set on the flesh is death, but the mind set on the Spirit is life and peace, because the mind set on the flesh is hostile toward God, for it is not even able to do so; and those who are in flesh cannot please God.”
Instead of being indwelled by the fleshly unrighteousness of sin, as specified by the Law, the believer is indwelled by the Spirit of God.
“However, you are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if indeed the Spirit of God dwells in you. But if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Him. And if Christ is in you, though the body is dead because of sin, yet the spirit is alive because of righteousness. But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised Christ Jesus from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who indwells you.”
Death is the flesh’s reward, for it possesses the inheritance of disobedient unrighteousness from Adam. But the free gift of righteousness results in being justified by God through the conviction called faith, and the believer’s belief in God and His Word. The sanctifying walk with the Holy Spirit gives life, eternal life for those who believe.
“So then brethren, we are under obligation, not to the flesh, to live according to the flesh, for if you are living according to the flesh you must die; but if by the Spirit you are putting to death the deeds of the body, you will live.”
Those who are led by the Spirit are the sons of God the Father.
“For all who are being led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God. For you have not received a spirit of slavery to fear again, but you have received a spirit of adoption as sons by which we cry out, ‘Abba! Father!’”
Following this great revelation, consider John Walvoord’s instruction on the Holy Spirit in his Abridged Systematic Theology:
“The period between the two advents of Christ is often designated ‘the age of the Holy Spirit’ because it is a time when the Holy Spirit of God is resident in the world and especially in the child of God. Christians are indwelt by the Holy Spirit with the special purpose of providing supernatural enablement in all areas of the spiritual life including that of comprehending truth. The Spirit of God can even reveal ‘the deep things of God’ (1 Cor. 2:10).
This truth opens up a vast horizon of spiritual knowledge to the spiritual Christian with its corresponding warning to Christians who are not walking with God and who are not being taught by the Spirit. Even as Christ revealed the Scriptures to His companions on the Road to Emmaus on the day of His resurrection (Luke 24:13-35), so today the Holy Spirit can open minds of spiritual Christians to understand and accept the limitless truth of God revealed in the Bible.”
The point should be established that the Holy Spirit’s ministry is decisive in terms of your being a true Christian, for as Christ said in contemplating His death:
John 16:7-11 “But I tell you the truth: It is for your own good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Counselor will not come to you; but if I go, I will send Him to you. When He comes, He will convict the world of guilt in regard to sin and righteousness and judgment: in regard to sin, because men do not believe in Me; in regard to righteousness, because I am going to the Father, where you can see me no longer, and in regard to judgment, because the prince of this world now stands condemned.”
What is meant by the statement regarding righteousness in terms of the Holy Spirit’s mission? John Walvoord provides an answer pertaining to the unsaved in his Abridged Edition of Systematic Theology:
“This righteousness is related to the fact that Christ would ascend into heaven and no longer be present on earth. In other words, while on earth He demonstrated the righteousness of God for all to see. But now with Christ in heaven the Holy Spirit will teach the unsaved the righteousness of God and with it the fact that in the Gospel God is offering His righteousness to sinful men who put trust in Christ. This concept would not be understood by an unsaved person apart from the work of the Spirit.”
Now as regards the saved person, Lewis Sperry Chafer provides guidance regarding being filled in the walk with the Spirit in his honored Systematic Theology:
“To be filled with the Spirit is to have the Spirit fulfilling all that He came in the heart to do. This truth is far removed from the notion that the Holy Spirit is to be received as ‘a second work of grace’ or ‘a second blessing.’ The Spirit-filled life is a realization in actual experience of what has been possessed from the moment one is saved. Ephesians 1:3 reveals the truth that every spiritual blessing is secured when one is saved. The verse reads: ‘Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ.’
Of all five ministries of the Spirit to the believer - regenerating, indwelling, sealing, baptizing, and filling - the last-named is alone commanded and expected of the believer. The implication is that this ministry, unlike the other four, depends upon human cooperation and adjustment. It is clear that beyond the one responsibility of believing on Christ unto salvation, no obligation rests upon the Christian respecting the first four ministries named. The command to be filled by the spirit (Eph 5:18), being addressed to the child of God, not only indicates that it is an experience subsequent to salvation, but the Christian’s own faithfulness determines the degree of filling.”
It is, therefore, apparent that the key fulfillment of Paul’s message in Romans involves the Christian walk with the Holy Spirit. And the key to that walk involves the awesome concept of “being filled” by the Spirit.
Charles C. Ryrie puts Spirit-filling in a precise perspective for both the nonbeliever and the believer in his book on Basic Theology (Page 376, The Filling of the Spirit):
“There seems to be two facets to Spirit-filling. The first may described as a sovereign act of God whereby He possesses someone for special activity. This is expressed by the Greek phrase pimplemi pneumatos agiou, and highlights the event of being filled rather than the resultant state of fullness. It occurs in Luke 1:15 (John the Baptist), 41 (Elizabeth), 67 (Zacharias);
Acts 2:4 (the group on the day of Pentecost); 4:8 (Peter), 31 (the believers); 9:17(Paul); and 13:9 (Paul).
The second facet of Spirit-filling may be described as the extensive influence and control of the Spirit in a believer’s life. It evidences an abiding state of fullness rather than the specific event. It produces a certain character of life, and seems to be a close synonym to spirituality. It is indicated by the Greek phrase plere or pleroo pneumatos agiou. It occurs in Luke 4:1 (Christ); Acts 6:3,5 (the first helpers of the apostles); 7:55 (Stephen); 11:24 (Barnabas); 13:52 (the disciples); and Ephesians 5:18 (believers).”
How does the believer become filled so that the gift of righteousness can be maintained? John F. Walvoord provides the important answer in his Systematic Theology (Abridged Edition, Page 273, The Holy Spirit in Relation to Christians):
“The works of the Holy Spirit that are related to the believer’s salvation are accomplished once and for all. By contrast the filling of the Spirit relates to believers’ experiences and can be a repeated spiritual condition. The Bible specifies certain steps a believer should take in order to be filled with the Spirit. It is unnecessary to pray for the filling of the Spirit. Instead a believer should seek to be obedient to the revelation of God regarding the conditions He has set forth in His Word. If he meets those conditions, he will be filled with the Spirit.
1. Do not grieve the Holy Spirit (Eph. 4:30). What grieves the Holy Spirit is sin. The cure of the effects of sin in the spiritual child of God is repentance, which leads to making a genuine confession of sin. Because sin is a common problem in Christian lives, the Bible suggest three ways it can be prevented (the following points are abbreviated):
a - The study of God’s word.
b - Resist sin by praying for the Spirit’s help.
c - The intercession of Christ as the believer’s High Priest (Heb. 7:25).
2. Do not put out the Spirit’s fire:
1 Thessalonians 5:19, ‘Do not put out the Spirit’s fire.’ Translated literally, the verse reads,
‘Do not keep on quenching the Spirit of God.’ In other words a believer should not refuse to Spirit of God direct his life. Grieving the Holy Spirit is the effect after a sin is committed, but quenching the Spirit is what leads to sin in the first place.
Though this exhortation is included in a series of exhortations, it obviously relates to the central truth of the necessity of being completely yielded to the will of God in order to experience the filling of the Holy Spirit.”
The following is an appropriate summary (amended from Charles Ryrie’s Basic Theology) of the meaning of being filled by the Spirit compared to the important event when a new believer is “born again”, the Spirit’s baptism:
SPIRIT’S BAPTISM SPIRIT’S FILLING
Occurs only once Is a repeated
in each believer’s experience.
life.
Never happened before Occurred in the
Day of Pentecost. Old Testament.
Cannot be undone. Must be maintained
by the believer.
Results in position as Results in Power and
a believer. personal Character.
Occurs when one believes Occurs throughout the
in Christ. Christian life.
Belief and Faith is Filling is based on the
required. The baptism initiative of the believer
is a one time event. in the walk with the Spirit.
It may now be apparent that the Holy Spirit, as the executive of Christ’s Church on earth, plays the major role in promoting righteousness in the indwelled believer.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
All Scriptural references used are from the NAS Open Bible
The writer acknowledges the extensive use of the following in the preparation of this and other papers:
Philip Schaff History of the Christian Church
Lewis Sperry Chafer Systematic Theology
John Calvin Institutes of the Christian Religion
Charles Hodge Systematic Theology
John F. Walvoord Abridged Edition of Chafer's Systematic Theology
Louis Berkhof Systematic Theology
Wolfhart Pannenberg Systematic Theology
John Miley Systematic Theology
Chales C Ryrie Basic Theology
Ludwig Ott Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma
Gordon D. Fee God’s Empowering Presence
F.F. Bruce The Canon of Scripture
Lawrence O. Richard Expository Dictionary of Bible Words
The New Dictionary of Theology edited by Sinclair B. Ferguson, David F. Wright, J. I. Packer
Henry Sheldon History of the Christian Church
Philip Schaff Creeds of Christendom
James and William Nichols Works of Arminius
Catechism of the Catholic Church
The Contemporary Parallel New Testament
The New American Standard (NAS) Bible, The Open Bible Edition.
The MacArthur Study Bible
Romans Commentaries: MacArthur, Loyd-Jones, Dunn, Barnhouse, Luther, Barth
Torry’s The Treasury of Scriptural Knowledge
[1] Acts 1:5 BAKGROUND in Reference 8 Page 13
[2] See Reference 2: THE TRINITY Page 10
[3] Matthew 26:28; Mark 14:24; Luke 22:29 1Cor: 11:25-29; Rom 3:24-26, 6:14,15
[4] See Reference 3: DISPENSATIONAL THEOLOGY Page 11
[5] See reference 4: THE NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES Page 11
[6] Eph 1:4, 5; Rom 8:30
[7] See Reference 5: CHRISTOLOGY Page 12
[8] Gen 1:2
[9]Acts 5: 3,4; Luke 1:35
[10] John 14:16, 26
[11] Rom 8:9-11
[12] Acts 2:4; Luke 4:1
[13] Luke 1:35
[14] John 16:8-11
[15] John 3: 3,
[16] Rom 15:16; 2Thess 2:13
[17] 1Cor 2:10-16; 1John 4:1-6
[18] 1Cor 2:12, 13; Eph 4:30; Heb 12:6
[19] John 15:26; 16:7-11; Eph 4:30
[20] Rom 8:9-11
[21] John 6:37, 44, 65; Col 1:12-13
[22] 1Cor 3:16,17
[23] Jer 31:31; Eze 37:14; Joel 2:28,29; Zech 12:10
[24] See Reference 6 The GOOD NEWS
[25] See Reference 7 THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT Page 16; See Gordon Fee’s book: God’s Empowering Presence
[26] 1Cor 2:14
[27] Rom 8:6-8; Gal 3:3
By Otis Page[1]
Each Christian has their own precious relationship with and understanding of God and may be sensitive to and sometimes offended by other’s views and interpretations of Scripture. The writer hopes the following is not offensive to the reader, that the reader may consider and enjoy this view on “Knowing the Reality of the Holy Spirit”.
INTRODUCTION
Ontology is the philosophic consideration of reality: "What is the nature of the knowable things?" that typically can not be proven scientifically. Epistemology asks "What do you know?" and "How do you know it?”. The meanings of words such as opinion, faith and belief, and knowledge convey the lesson on what is means to “know”, to have knowledge.
Some scholars hold that opinion is the weakest conviction, followed by faith/belief, followed by knowing. For example, you might have an opinion that it is going to rain tomorrow. That opinion would be a belief if you relied on an authority, such as the report of a weatherman. And the opinion/belief would become knowing when tomorrow comes and it is actually raining.
A more relevant example pertains to this paper: One might have an opinion that God exists. That opinion changes to being faith that He exists when trusting a religious authority. It could be a conviction of belief where there is evidence of God in a person’s life. And the conviction may become “knowing” when the believer experiences the indwelling of God’s Holy Spirit.
Therefore, this paper addresses the ontological concept of “knowing” the reality of the past existence and present manifestation of God. It further attempts to answer the epistemological question how does one “know” God besides just believing that God exists? What is the reality of God and how do we know that reality in the Christian experience? This paper’s thesis attempts to provide the objective evidence of the reality of knowing God as framed in Romans 6-8!
THE HISTORICITY OF THE EVIDENT CHRIST
Christ’s witness compared to the prior witness of the Jews provides a startling contradiction between the two dispensations – that of Law and that of Grace. The following exemplifies the contrast with the Torah (the Law) compared to the compelling ministry of Christ and the Holy Spirit as depicted in Romans 6, 7 & 8. Paul frames the juxtaposition contrasting the “Law” and the “law of sin and death:
The following “transitional” analysis in Romans 7 with 6 and 8 is stated in Gordon Fee’s summary (God’s Empowering Presence):
A 7,12,23 The Law, Torah, is good just and holy.
B 7:14-24, 25b But the first Law was used by another “law,”
Sin, which in turn leads to death.
C 8,2A Enter the third “law”, the Spirit of life.
B’ 8:2B The third “law” sets one free from the second “law”,
both sin and death.
A’ 8: 3, 4 The third “law” fulfills the intent of the first Law, which was incapable of dealing with sin and thus producing righteousness.
Rom 7: 14-25 is a “transitional statement” bridging Romans 6 (no longer a slave to sin) to 8:1, 2 (the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death) by contrasting the Law (TORAH), the law of sin and death, and the law of the Spirit of life in Jesus Christ.
Consider the totality of Romans 7:14-25 as follows:
" So then, the Law (TORAH) is holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good. (12) Therefore did that which is good become a cause of death for me? May it never be! Rather it was sin, in order that it night be shown to be sin be effecting my death through that which is good, that through the commandment sin might become utterly sinful.” (13) For we know that the Law is spiritual; but I am of flesh, sold into bondage to sin. (14) For that which I am doing, I do not understand; for I am not practicing what I would like to do, but I am doing the very thing I hate. (15) But if I do the very thing I do not wish to, I agree with the Law, confessing that it is good. (16) So now, no longer am I the one doing it, but the sin which indwells me. (17) For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh; for the wishing is present in me, but the doing of the good is not. (18) For the good that I wish, I do not do; but practice the very evil that I do not wish. (19) But if I am doing the very thing I do not wish, I am no longer the one doing it, but sin which dwells in me.(20) I find then the principle that evil is present in me, the one who wishes to do good. (21) For I joyfully concur with the law of God in the inner man, (22) but I see a different law in the members of my body, waging war against the law of my mind, and making me a prisoner of the law of sin which is in my members. (23)
The following quote is presented here as a vital commentary on Romans 7:7-25 and as an introduction to the inspired answer given to us in Chapter 8 of Romans.
“This remarkable section (Romans 7:7-25) describes the psychological progress of the human heart to Christ: from the heathen state of carnal security, when sin is dead because it is unknown, through the Jewish state of legal conflict, when sin, roused by the stimulus of the divine command, springs into life,and the higher and nobler nature of man strives in vain to overcome this fearful monster, until at last the free grace of God in Christ gains victory. Some of the profoundest divines - Augustine, Luther, Calvin - transfer this conflict into the regenerate state; but this is described in the eighth chapter (of Romans) which ends in an exulting song of triumph.”
(Footnote 5, Page 299, The Conversion of Paul, Volume 1, The History of the Christian Church, by Philip Schaff.)
Consider this review of Paul’s declaration:
“What shall we say then? Is the Law (TORAH) sin? May it never be! On the contrary, I would not come to know sin except through the Law;” Romans 7:7
Paul cries out, “Wretched man that I am! Who will set me free from the body of this death?" Romans 7:24. "Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ! So then, on the one hand I myself with my mind am serving the Law of God, but on the other, with my flesh the law of sin. 7:25 “There is, therefore now no condemnation for those in Jesus Christ. For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death." 8:1, 2
Christ’s fulfillment of the Law (Torah)
“Do not think that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish, but to fulfill.” Matthew 5:17
“Do we then nullify the Law through faith? May it never be! On the contrary we establish the Law” Romans 3:31
“For what the Law could not do, weak as it was through the flesh, God did: sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and as an offering for sin. He condemned sin in the flesh, in order that the requirement of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who do not walk according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit.” 8: 3,4
Christ’s Holy Spirit fulfills the requirement of the Law for those indwelled. Romans 8:9
Therefore: “But now we have been released from the Law, having died to that which we were bound (6:10-18) , so that we serve in newness of the Spirit and not the oldness of the letter.” 7:6
And then 8:5-17 – where the Spirit is way of the Christian life as contrasted with the Law in the Jewish religious domain.
“For through the Law I died to the Law, that I might live to God. I have been crucified with Christ; and Christ lives in me; and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and delivered Himself up for me. I do not nullify the grace of God; for if righteousness comes through the Law, then Christ died needlessly." Galatians 2:19-21
This state of Paul's unrighteous unbelief stated in 1st Timothy 1:12-15, "And yet I was shown mercy, because I acted ignorantly in unbelief;" gives full credence to the fact that all Paul could do in following the Law was to excite what the Law defines as unrighteousness. That while "serving the Law of God", he only served the "law of sin" in his flesh sustained by his human nature. The only result for him was that the Law taught him that he was unrighteous, that he was a sinner (7:7). But the Law did not by itself make him right with God or make him personally righteous. For as Paul exclaims, "for sin, taking every opportunity through the commandment, deceived me, and through it killed me" (7:11).
The righteousness that Paul aspired to - being right with God, and being personally made righteous - was provided by Jesus Christ:
"But we know that the Law is good, if one uses it lawfully, realizing the fact that law is not made for a righteous man, but for those who are lawless and rebellious, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who kill their fathers or mothers, for murderers and immoral men and homosexuals and kidnappers and liars and perjurers and whatever else is contrary to sound teaching," 1 Timothy 1:8,9
"You who boast in the Law, through your breaking the Law, do you dishonor God?" Romans 2:23
"for until the Law sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law." Romans 5:13
"Why the Law then? It was added because of transgressions, having been ordained through angels by the agency of a mediator until the seed should come to whom the promise had been made." Galatians 3:19
"Is the Law then contrary to the promises of God? May it never be! For if the law had been given which was able to impart life, then righteousness would have been indeed based on law." Galatians 3:21
The New Testament’s determination of the Trinity[2] establishes the relationship of Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The New represents a departure from God’s prior exclusive revelation to the Jews in the Old (Torah). This fact is exemplified in Romans 1-8. It authenticates and exemplifies the profound new covenant of Christ’s blood “for the forgiveness of sins” and justification “as a gift by His grace”[3] to those who believe.
The inclusive covenant of the New Testament does not terminate the exclusive covenant of the Old, however. It is a new dispensation[4] of God’s plan to extend His revelation in the Scriptures[5] to the world through Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit. The New Testament is a revelation to those chosen, “just as he chose us before the foundation of the world”, “predestined - according to His will”.[6]
Questions in the early developing theology of Christianity dealt with two mighty theological determinations regarding the nature of Christ’s humanity, deity and His relationship or subordination/succession with the Father and the role of the Holy Spirit. These were characterized as the Trinitarian and Christological[7] controversies. They evolved during the first centuries (400 years!), including the Catholic and Greek Orthodox Churches as known at the present time.
Christ’s ministry reintroduced and reaffirmed the compelling and existing ministry[8] of the omnipresent Holy Spirit[9], as invoked in John[10] and as described by implementation of the indwelling[11] and filling[12] of the Christian believer. The Holy Spirit conceived Christ[13] convicts mankind[14], regenerates [15], sanctifies[16], gives discernment[17], is grieved and illuminates and inspires the believer[18]. It may now be apparent that the Holy Spirit, as the executive of Christ’s Church on earth, plays the major role in furthering Here is the major point as it relates to today, in this very instance when reading and considering this paper: It is important to acknowledge that Christ’s ministry exists today[19] through the Holy Spirit’s indwelling of the believer[20] and the calling by prevenient grace of those of the elect coming to belief.[21]
KNOWING THE HOLY SPIRIT
It is a fact that God in the form of the Holy Spirit exists today and forever. This is Christ’s Holy Spirit! And here is the extraordinary evidentiary conclusion: He is with us now, today, indwelled in those who believe and walk with Him, and that is the truth expressed in Romans 8:6-9 and as confirmed in References 3 and 9 of this paper. The Holy Spirit as person is the personal empowering presence of God. As sure as the certainty that God’s glory is imaged through Christ in His humanity, the same is true of the Holy Spirit now indwelled personally in the Christian, the temple of the Holy Spirit.[22] The Holy Spirit, thereby, today, establishes the promises made in the Old Testament[23] that are now fulfilled in the New. What is the proof of all this, the truly objective proof?
The epistemological question on what and how the indwelled Christian knows God’s reality is confirmed empirically by the momentum of tradition in Christ’s diverse church, the witness of His Word in the New Testament, and the inspired one-on-one personal revelation of the Holy Spirit to the believer. The ontological question was first framed in the vibrant intellectual period of the 18th Century Enlightenment dealing with skeptical questions regarding the reality of God. That reality, today, is the “good news”[24] of the present ministry of the Holy Spirit – God with us, for as Christ states in John 16:14 “He will glorify Me; for He shall take of Mine, and disclose it to you.”
The Holy Spirit’s “empowerment” of the indwelled Christian[25] provides a “knowing” witness that God does exist and that Jesus Christ is the confirmed expression (the Logos) of that reality. God’s presence, the Holy Spirit, exists in the daily experience of the true Christian believer, even though this fact may boggle the minds of nonbelievers.[26] If a Christian does not know this truth – then that person probably is not a Christian![27]
The real “good news” is the “bad news” (Rom 6:14-18; 8:1-13) is ended for those who believe. This truth applies to all Christians without respect to any religious affiliation! The Age of Grace presents the implementation of Christ's witness to the individual believer through the Holy Spirit (Rom 8)!
There is hope for the true Chistian Saint that seeks the true understanding of the “good news”, especially that explained in Romans 6 thru 8!The Holy Spirit as person is the personal empowering presence of God. As sure as the certainty that God’s glory is imaged through Christ in His humanity, the same is true of the Holy Spirit now indwelled personally in the Christian, the temple of the Holy Spirit. (1Cor 3:16, 17) The Holy Spirit, thereby, today, establishes the promises made in the Old Testament (Jer 31:31; Eze 37:14; Joel 2:28,29; Zech 12:10 ) that are now fulfilled in the New. So the “good news” is the “bad news” is ended except where the “sad news” applies either by ignorance or the lack of confession of sin (1John 1:5-10) by those who say they are Christians but really are not since they are not indwelt with His Holy Spirit. (Rom 8:1,2)
REFERENCES
References: 1.The Historicity of Christ 2: The Trinity 3: Dispensational Theology 4: The Scriptures 5: Christology 6: Comparing the Law with that of Grace 7: The reality of the Holy Spirit 8: Background
1: CHRIST’S HISTORICITY
Given the context of the question on Christ’s preexistence, there is the more fundamental question addressing whether Christ really existed in the first place.
Is the story of Christ just a mythical concoction? Did he really exist? Is the New Testament an authentic record since the original manuscripts making up the New Testament are no where to be found.
There have been and there still exists attempts to analyze and determine the authenticity of the Scriptures, especially those of the New Testament. So there are questions that preempt the issue of preexistence where critiques allege that mysticism and mythology strangle the truth of the historical record as to Christ’s true existence, ministry and the amazing story of His trial, death, resurrection and ascension!
Will Durant is the author of the "The Story of Civilization" and the "The Lessons of History" culminating a lifetime journey in the study of history and philosophy. A "reluctant" atheist, Durant's conclusions on Christianity provide a formidable view by which one may learn, and possibly understand, the atheistic "persuasion" regarding disbelief in God and the revelation of Jesus Christ in the Bible.
Yet in “The History of Civilization”; Volume III; Caesar and Christ, Durant provides a convicting witness authenticating Christ’s historicity. Here is Durant’s objective assessment:
"In summary, it is clear that there are many contradictions between one gospel and another, many dubious statements of history, many suspicious resemblances to the legends told of pagan gods, many incidents apparently designed to prove the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies, many passages possibly aiming to establish a historical basis for some later doctrine or ritual of the Church. The evangelist shared with Cicero, Sallust, and Tacitus the conception of history as a vehicle for moral ideas. And presumably the conversations and speeches reported in the Gospels were subject to the frailties of illiterate memories, and the errors or emendations of copyists.
All this granted, much remains. The contradictions are of minutiae, not substance; in essentials the synoptic gospels agree remarkably well, and form a consistent portrait of Christ. In the enthusiasm of its discoveries the Higher Criticism has applied to the new testament tests of authenticity so severe that by them a hundred ancient worthies - e.g., Hammurabi, David, Socrates - would fade into legend (Says a great Jewish scholar, perhaps too strongly: 'If we had ancient sources like those in the Gospels for the history of Alexander or Caesar, we should not cast any doubt upon them whatsoever.' – Klausner., From Jesus to Paul, 260.).
Despite the prejudices and theological preconceptions of the evangelists, they record many incidents that mere inventors would have concealed - the competition of the apostles for high places in the Kingdom, their flight after Jesus' arrest, Peter's denial, the failure of Christ to work miracles in Galilee, the references of some auditors to his possible insanity, his early uncertainty as to his mission, his confessions of ignorance as to the future, his moments of bitterness, his despairing cry on the cross; no one reading these scenes can doubt the reality of the figure behind them. That a few simple men should in one generation have invented so powerful and appealing a personality, so lofty an ethic and so inspiring a vision of human brotherhood, would be a miracle far more incredible than any recorded in the Gospels. After two centuries of Higher Criticism the outlines of the life, character, and teaching of Christ, remain reasonably clear, and constitute the most fascinating feature in the history of Western man."
In his attempt to define the historicity of Jesus Christ, Durant concludes that the writings of the New Testament are valid and have been subjected to tests of scrutiny so severe that many other conclusions of history, if so tested, would not survive. He makes the authenticating judgment that, "Despite the prejudices and theological preconceptions of the evangelists, they record many incidents that mere inventors would have concealed."
Regardless of his atheism, Durant concludes, "That a few simple men should in one generation have invented so powerful and appealing a personality, so lofty an ethic and so inspiring a vision of human brotherhood, would be a miracle for more incredible than any recorded in the Gospels."
3: THE TRINITY
Before any considerations of Christ’s preexistence there came the important findings on the Trinity. The Trinitarian definition dealt with the relationship of Jesus Christ, the Son, the Father and the Holy Spirit as persons of the Godhead (One God). It determined that Christ was of the same essence as the Father and not subordinate to Him, even though Christ confessed that the Father is greater than He! (John 14:28). The Trinity, as a Biblical doctrine, came into effect recognizing this Truth while, at the same time, determining the Holy Spirit as the third person of one God in essence.
It should be logically inferred from this if Christ is of the same essence as God, He must have preexisted as God, a fact that one disputes. But the important issue is that Christ did not preexist as a human being – but possibly as one with the Spirit and Father.
The resolution of the Trinitarian conflict, at the Council of Nicea in 325 A.D., marked a major event in the Church’s and Western civilization’s histories. It initiated the reconciliation of the informal structure of the Christian Church and the formalized secular institution of the Roman Empire through the remarkable leadership of the Emperor Constantine, who was not overly religious, whose political power became a significant instrument of the Holy Spirit in exercising this stage of God’s plan for mankind and His Church.
The result of this was the eventual structuring of the Roman Catholic Church, where the Church and the Roman Empire joined as partners in the conquering, subjugation and conversion of the European nations and peoples. The resolution of the conflict was finalized at the council of Constantinople in the year 381, and resulted in the following doctrine within the Niceno - Constantinopolitian Creed:
“We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and of all things visible and invisible. And in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father;”
5: DISPENSATIONAL THEOLOGY
Dispensationalism: The distinctiveness of God’s plan as beheld in terms of time periods or phases with specific reference to His revelations. The dispensations according to Chafer’s Systematic Theology, Vol 1, Pages 40, 41:
Of innocence: from creation to Adam’s fall;
Of Conscience: from Adam to the flood;
Of Human Government: from the flood to Abraham;
Of Promise: from Abraham to the giving of the Law;
Of the Law: from the giving of the Law to Christ’s coming:
Of Grace: Of Christ till the creation of a new heaven and earth.
The writer believes the dispensation of Grace is split in two parts. The first is the witness of Christ and the second is the administration of the Holy Spirit “till the creation of a new heaven and earth.”
6: THE NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES
The evolution of the Christian Bible begins with the Hebrew Scriptures, which are characterized in Romans as being the “Law and the Prophets” (Torah), including the other honored books in the Old Testament (Rom 3:21). The reason for this is the simple fact that Christians were first of all Jews (Acts 2:5), not that any Jew except the Pharisees (including Paul) could read or interpret them.
But the new Church was not founded on the Hebrew Scriptures; it was established on the distinctive being of a person - to Jesus of Nazareth, crucified, dead and buried, but “designated Son of God in power ... by His resurrection from the dead.” (Rom 1:4)
Jesus wrote no book. His teachings as an inspired human being were conveyed in by word of mouth, personal example and by incidents of miracles that were later accomplished by His human disciples. What Jesus said, the word-of-mouth conveyance of His teachings, the historical events pertaining to what He said and accomplished, were lovingly recollected and documented by His hearers, His Apostles and Disciples.
These early writings became with various letters the eventual “confession of Faith,” the inspired written Word which now comprises the New Testament. They were inspired by an exalted process guided by His Holy Spirit (Eph 6:17) leading to the formalization of the Canon of Scripture evolved over the first four hundred years of Christian history.
The Bible was held as an exclusive intellectual property of the Church, until the coincident development of the printing press and the explosive generation of the Protestant movement in the early 16th century, a period of twelve hundred years. Nevertheless, the Scriptures served as the foundation for the developing theology of the Church during this extensive time, by a small number of thoughtful, literate theologians who studied the Word and used it as a foundation for their speculations on the meaning and application of what it taught as a part of the theological evolution of the Church.
Theologian John Walvoord instructs the believer on the lessons of righteousness contained in the Bible, in his Abridged Edition of Lewis Perry Shafer’s Systematic Theology:
“The ethics of the Bible are the only sure word regarding what is right and wrong in the world. While false religions often elevate immorality to a place of acceptance and morality, only the Bible presents sin as it really is and characterizes humanity as totally and hopelessly depraved apart from the grace of God. Human history in the Bible describes what fallen humans can do in living a life totally contrary to the will of God which can take individuals in all their depravity, sanctify them, and ultimately present them perfect in eternity to come.”
7: CHRISTOLOGY
The formulation of the Trinitarian doctrine framed the definition of the complex person of Jesus Christ. The famed reformed theologian, Louis Berkoff, instructs us in his History of Christian Doctrines, “The decision to which the trinitarian controversy led, namely, that Christ as the Son of God is consubstantial with the Father and therefore very God, immediately gave birth to the question of the relation between the divine and the human nature in Christ.”
This controversy occurred over three hundred years after Christ’s ascension! This event should be considered today in terms of Christ’s preexistence, since that if it took three hundred years to decide on Christ’s nature, it is again appropriate two thousand years later to confirm the nature of His preexistanence. Such questions delight theologians of those who love those who wish to learn the true meaning of Christ’s witness and ministry.
The Christological events dealt with the person of Jesus Christ and the logical contradiction suggested by one having both a divine and human nature, a problem that still bothers some religions today, religions that either deny Christ being the Son of God or deny His divine and human nature such as Jehovah’s Witnesses, Mormons, and the various Islamic religions. Arianism fed the flames of the controversy regarding the preexistence of Christ in that it held that Christ was not of the same “essence” as the Father.
In the 5th Century Nestorius, the bishop of Constantinople, believed Christ had two natures and two persons: one human and the other divine. He was opposed to calling Mary the “Mother of God” (theotokos; Greek for “God bearer”). As with the Council of Nicea in 325 AD in determing the Trinity, the Council of Chalcedon in the year 451AD provided the beginning for the final resolution of the Christological definition by the issuance of the following:
“We then, following the holy Fathers, all with one consent, teach men to confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, the same perfect in Godhead and also perfect in manhood; truly God and also truly man, of reasonable soul and body; consubstantial with us according to manhood; in all things like unto us, without sin; begotten before all ages of the Father according to the Godhead, and in these latter days, for us and for our salvation, born of the virgin Mary, the Mother of God, according to the manhood; one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only-begotten, to be acknowledged in two natures, inconfusedly, unchangeably, indivisibly, inseparably, the distinction of natures being by no means taken away by union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring in one Person and one subsistence, not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same Son, the Only-begotten, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ; as the prophets from the beginning have declared concerning Him, and the Lord Jesus Christ Himself has taught us, and the Creed of the Holy Fathers has handed down to us.”
The Christological and Trinitarian disputes were fundamental events that brought the Church to a point of understanding itself, in a very important sense. The developing doctrines pertaining to God (Theology Proper), Jesus Christ (Christology), the Holy Spirit (Pneumatology) and the Church (Ecclesiology) found their beginnings in the Spirit inspired consensus facilitated by these centuries of Holy Spirit led dialectics. The question of Christ’s preexistence was never considered in these controversies except as implied by His deity as being of the same essence as the Father.
8. THE AGE OF THE LAW COMPARED TO GRACE
A comparison of the age of the Law with that of Grace establishes a dramatically different requirement of human conduct defining the relationship of mankind to God. The conduct-regulating requirements of the Age of Grace are differentiated from that of the Law by the role of the Holy Spirit.
The Mosaic system of Law is void of the Holy Sprit’s enablement that exists in the Age of Grace. Being indwelt and walking in the Spirit fulfill the requirements of the Law and frees the believer form “law of sin and death”.
The Age of Grace presents superhuman ideals supported by the indwelling and filling of the believer by the Holy Spirit. These ideals are “divine beseechings”. They are not commands. They are the polite, considerate expression of persuasion extended to those for which it is rightfully expected since they are realized on the sanctifying walk with the Holy Spirit.
Romans 12:1 “I urge you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living and holy sacrifice, acceptable to God, which is your spiritual service of worship.”
Ephesians 4:1,2 “I, therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, entreat you to walk in a manner worthy of the calling with which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, showing forbearance to one another in love.”
There is a fundamental difference between these directions and “beseechings” and the teachings of the Mosaic Law which imposed a curse on those who failed!
Deuteronomy 28:15 “But it shall come about, if you will not obey the Lord your God, to observe to do all His commandments and His statutes which I charge you today, that all these curses shall come upon you and overtake you.” (The curses are specified in verses 16 through 68)
God’s Grace provides an incredibly different life under Grace compared to life under the Law:
Romans 8:1, 2 “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Jesus Christ. For the Law of the Spirit of life in Jesus Christ has set you free from the Law of sin and death.”
God’s Grace through the gift of Faith in Jesus Christ (Eph 2:8) provides that there can be no separation of the believer from the love of God.
Romans 8: 38,39 “For I am convinced that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, not things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor any other created thing, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.”
7. THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT
The Christian comes to know and understand a personal one-on-one relationship with the Triune God, through the ministry of the third person of the Trinity, the executive of the Godhead and Christ’s Church on earth. He is referred to and honored by the following names in the Bible:
· The Advocate (1John 2:1),
· The Helper (John 14:16): the “Paraclete” (Greek for
“Helper” and “Advocate”), the Spirit of truth (John 14:17), the Spirit of the Father (Mat 10:20), The Spirit of God (Rom 8:9),
· The Holy Ghost (King James version),
· The Holy Spirit (Mat 28:19).
· The Comforter (Acts 9:31),
The believer is set free from the law of sin and death through the righteousness provided as a gift by Jesus Christ:
Rom 8:1-17 “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Jesus Christ. For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has set you free from the law of sin and death. For what the Law could not do, weak as it was through the flesh, God did by sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and as an offering for sin.”
The requirement of the Law can not be fulfilled by serving the Law. It can only be fulfilled by walking with the Holy Spirit, Jesus Christ’s greatest gift to the believer.
“He condemned sin in the flesh in order that the requirement of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who do not walk according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit. For those who are according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who are according to the Spirit, the things of the Spirit. For the mind set on the flesh is death, but the mind set on the Spirit is life and peace, because the mind set on the flesh is hostile toward God, for it is not even able to do so; and those who are in flesh cannot please God.”
Instead of being indwelled by the fleshly unrighteousness of sin, as specified by the Law, the believer is indwelled by the Spirit of God.
“However, you are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if indeed the Spirit of God dwells in you. But if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Him. And if Christ is in you, though the body is dead because of sin, yet the spirit is alive because of righteousness. But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised Christ Jesus from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who indwells you.”
Death is the flesh’s reward, for it possesses the inheritance of disobedient unrighteousness from Adam. But the free gift of righteousness results in being justified by God through the conviction called faith, and the believer’s belief in God and His Word. The sanctifying walk with the Holy Spirit gives life, eternal life for those who believe.
“So then brethren, we are under obligation, not to the flesh, to live according to the flesh, for if you are living according to the flesh you must die; but if by the Spirit you are putting to death the deeds of the body, you will live.”
Those who are led by the Spirit are the sons of God the Father.
“For all who are being led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God. For you have not received a spirit of slavery to fear again, but you have received a spirit of adoption as sons by which we cry out, ‘Abba! Father!’”
Following this great revelation, consider John Walvoord’s instruction on the Holy Spirit in his Abridged Systematic Theology:
“The period between the two advents of Christ is often designated ‘the age of the Holy Spirit’ because it is a time when the Holy Spirit of God is resident in the world and especially in the child of God. Christians are indwelt by the Holy Spirit with the special purpose of providing supernatural enablement in all areas of the spiritual life including that of comprehending truth. The Spirit of God can even reveal ‘the deep things of God’ (1 Cor. 2:10).
This truth opens up a vast horizon of spiritual knowledge to the spiritual Christian with its corresponding warning to Christians who are not walking with God and who are not being taught by the Spirit. Even as Christ revealed the Scriptures to His companions on the Road to Emmaus on the day of His resurrection (Luke 24:13-35), so today the Holy Spirit can open minds of spiritual Christians to understand and accept the limitless truth of God revealed in the Bible.”
The point should be established that the Holy Spirit’s ministry is decisive in terms of your being a true Christian, for as Christ said in contemplating His death:
John 16:7-11 “But I tell you the truth: It is for your own good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Counselor will not come to you; but if I go, I will send Him to you. When He comes, He will convict the world of guilt in regard to sin and righteousness and judgment: in regard to sin, because men do not believe in Me; in regard to righteousness, because I am going to the Father, where you can see me no longer, and in regard to judgment, because the prince of this world now stands condemned.”
What is meant by the statement regarding righteousness in terms of the Holy Spirit’s mission? John Walvoord provides an answer pertaining to the unsaved in his Abridged Edition of Systematic Theology:
“This righteousness is related to the fact that Christ would ascend into heaven and no longer be present on earth. In other words, while on earth He demonstrated the righteousness of God for all to see. But now with Christ in heaven the Holy Spirit will teach the unsaved the righteousness of God and with it the fact that in the Gospel God is offering His righteousness to sinful men who put trust in Christ. This concept would not be understood by an unsaved person apart from the work of the Spirit.”
Now as regards the saved person, Lewis Sperry Chafer provides guidance regarding being filled in the walk with the Spirit in his honored Systematic Theology:
“To be filled with the Spirit is to have the Spirit fulfilling all that He came in the heart to do. This truth is far removed from the notion that the Holy Spirit is to be received as ‘a second work of grace’ or ‘a second blessing.’ The Spirit-filled life is a realization in actual experience of what has been possessed from the moment one is saved. Ephesians 1:3 reveals the truth that every spiritual blessing is secured when one is saved. The verse reads: ‘Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ.’
Of all five ministries of the Spirit to the believer - regenerating, indwelling, sealing, baptizing, and filling - the last-named is alone commanded and expected of the believer. The implication is that this ministry, unlike the other four, depends upon human cooperation and adjustment. It is clear that beyond the one responsibility of believing on Christ unto salvation, no obligation rests upon the Christian respecting the first four ministries named. The command to be filled by the spirit (Eph 5:18), being addressed to the child of God, not only indicates that it is an experience subsequent to salvation, but the Christian’s own faithfulness determines the degree of filling.”
It is, therefore, apparent that the key fulfillment of Paul’s message in Romans involves the Christian walk with the Holy Spirit. And the key to that walk involves the awesome concept of “being filled” by the Spirit.
Charles C. Ryrie puts Spirit-filling in a precise perspective for both the nonbeliever and the believer in his book on Basic Theology (Page 376, The Filling of the Spirit):
“There seems to be two facets to Spirit-filling. The first may described as a sovereign act of God whereby He possesses someone for special activity. This is expressed by the Greek phrase pimplemi pneumatos agiou, and highlights the event of being filled rather than the resultant state of fullness. It occurs in Luke 1:15 (John the Baptist), 41 (Elizabeth), 67 (Zacharias);
Acts 2:4 (the group on the day of Pentecost); 4:8 (Peter), 31 (the believers); 9:17(Paul); and 13:9 (Paul).
The second facet of Spirit-filling may be described as the extensive influence and control of the Spirit in a believer’s life. It evidences an abiding state of fullness rather than the specific event. It produces a certain character of life, and seems to be a close synonym to spirituality. It is indicated by the Greek phrase plere or pleroo pneumatos agiou. It occurs in Luke 4:1 (Christ); Acts 6:3,5 (the first helpers of the apostles); 7:55 (Stephen); 11:24 (Barnabas); 13:52 (the disciples); and Ephesians 5:18 (believers).”
How does the believer become filled so that the gift of righteousness can be maintained? John F. Walvoord provides the important answer in his Systematic Theology (Abridged Edition, Page 273, The Holy Spirit in Relation to Christians):
“The works of the Holy Spirit that are related to the believer’s salvation are accomplished once and for all. By contrast the filling of the Spirit relates to believers’ experiences and can be a repeated spiritual condition. The Bible specifies certain steps a believer should take in order to be filled with the Spirit. It is unnecessary to pray for the filling of the Spirit. Instead a believer should seek to be obedient to the revelation of God regarding the conditions He has set forth in His Word. If he meets those conditions, he will be filled with the Spirit.
1. Do not grieve the Holy Spirit (Eph. 4:30). What grieves the Holy Spirit is sin. The cure of the effects of sin in the spiritual child of God is repentance, which leads to making a genuine confession of sin. Because sin is a common problem in Christian lives, the Bible suggest three ways it can be prevented (the following points are abbreviated):
a - The study of God’s word.
b - Resist sin by praying for the Spirit’s help.
c - The intercession of Christ as the believer’s High Priest (Heb. 7:25).
2. Do not put out the Spirit’s fire:
1 Thessalonians 5:19, ‘Do not put out the Spirit’s fire.’ Translated literally, the verse reads,
‘Do not keep on quenching the Spirit of God.’ In other words a believer should not refuse to Spirit of God direct his life. Grieving the Holy Spirit is the effect after a sin is committed, but quenching the Spirit is what leads to sin in the first place.
Though this exhortation is included in a series of exhortations, it obviously relates to the central truth of the necessity of being completely yielded to the will of God in order to experience the filling of the Holy Spirit.”
The following is an appropriate summary (amended from Charles Ryrie’s Basic Theology) of the meaning of being filled by the Spirit compared to the important event when a new believer is “born again”, the Spirit’s baptism:
SPIRIT’S BAPTISM SPIRIT’S FILLING
Occurs only once Is a repeated
in each believer’s experience.
life.
Never happened before Occurred in the
Day of Pentecost. Old Testament.
Cannot be undone. Must be maintained
by the believer.
Results in position as Results in Power and
a believer. personal Character.
Occurs when one believes Occurs throughout the
in Christ. Christian life.
Belief and Faith is Filling is based on the
required. The baptism initiative of the believer
is a one time event. in the walk with the Spirit.
It may now be apparent that the Holy Spirit, as the executive of Christ’s Church on earth, plays the major role in promoting righteousness in the indwelled believer.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
All Scriptural references used are from the NAS Open Bible
The writer acknowledges the extensive use of the following in the preparation of this and other papers:
Philip Schaff History of the Christian Church
Lewis Sperry Chafer Systematic Theology
John Calvin Institutes of the Christian Religion
Charles Hodge Systematic Theology
John F. Walvoord Abridged Edition of Chafer's Systematic Theology
Louis Berkhof Systematic Theology
Wolfhart Pannenberg Systematic Theology
John Miley Systematic Theology
Chales C Ryrie Basic Theology
Ludwig Ott Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma
Gordon D. Fee God’s Empowering Presence
F.F. Bruce The Canon of Scripture
Lawrence O. Richard Expository Dictionary of Bible Words
The New Dictionary of Theology edited by Sinclair B. Ferguson, David F. Wright, J. I. Packer
Henry Sheldon History of the Christian Church
Philip Schaff Creeds of Christendom
James and William Nichols Works of Arminius
Catechism of the Catholic Church
The Contemporary Parallel New Testament
The New American Standard (NAS) Bible, The Open Bible Edition.
The MacArthur Study Bible
Romans Commentaries: MacArthur, Loyd-Jones, Dunn, Barnhouse, Luther, Barth
Torry’s The Treasury of Scriptural Knowledge
[1] Acts 1:5 BAKGROUND in Reference 8 Page 13
[2] See Reference 2: THE TRINITY Page 10
[3] Matthew 26:28; Mark 14:24; Luke 22:29 1Cor: 11:25-29; Rom 3:24-26, 6:14,15
[4] See Reference 3: DISPENSATIONAL THEOLOGY Page 11
[5] See reference 4: THE NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES Page 11
[6] Eph 1:4, 5; Rom 8:30
[7] See Reference 5: CHRISTOLOGY Page 12
[8] Gen 1:2
[9]Acts 5: 3,4; Luke 1:35
[10] John 14:16, 26
[11] Rom 8:9-11
[12] Acts 2:4; Luke 4:1
[13] Luke 1:35
[14] John 16:8-11
[15] John 3: 3,
[16] Rom 15:16; 2Thess 2:13
[17] 1Cor 2:10-16; 1John 4:1-6
[18] 1Cor 2:12, 13; Eph 4:30; Heb 12:6
[19] John 15:26; 16:7-11; Eph 4:30
[20] Rom 8:9-11
[21] John 6:37, 44, 65; Col 1:12-13
[22] 1Cor 3:16,17
[23] Jer 31:31; Eze 37:14; Joel 2:28,29; Zech 12:10
[24] See Reference 6 The GOOD NEWS
[25] See Reference 7 THE REALITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT Page 16; See Gordon Fee’s book: God’s Empowering Presence
[26] 1Cor 2:14
[27] Rom 8:6-8; Gal 3:3
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
